UNITED STATES

SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION

Washington, D.C. 20549

FORM 10-Q

[X] QUARTERLY REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d)

OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934

For the Quarterly Period Ended September 30, ~~2018~~2019

[ ] TRANSITION REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d)

OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934

Commission File Number: 0-12507

ARROW FINANCIAL CORPORATION

(Exact name of registrant as specified in its charter)



New York			22-2448962
(State or other jurisdiction of incorporation or organization)			(I.R.S. Employer Identification No.)
250 GLEN STREET, GLENS FALLS, NEW YORK 12801
(Address of principal executive offices) (Zip Code)
Registrant’s telephone number, including area code: (518) 745-1000

Securities registered pursuant to Section 12(b) of the Act:



Title of Each Class	Trading Symbol	Name of Each Exchange on Which Registered
Common Stock, Par Value $1.00 per share	AROW	NASDAQ Global Select Market

Indicate by check mark whether the registrant (1) has filed all reports required to be filed by Section 13 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 during the preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to file such reports), and (2) has been subject to such filing requirements for the past 90 days. x Yes No

Indicate by check mark whether the registrant has submitted electronically every Interactive Data File required to be submitted pursuant to Rule 405 of Regulation S-T (§ 232.405 of this chapter) during the preceding 12 months (or for such shorter period that the registrant was required to submit such files). x Yes No

Indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a large accelerated filer, an accelerated filer, a non-accelerated filer, or a smaller reporting company. See the definitions of “large accelerated filer,” “accelerated filer” and “smaller reporting company” in Rule 12b-2 of the Exchange Act.



Large accelerated filer	Accelerated filer x
Non-accelerated filer
Smaller reporting company
Emerging growth company
If an emerging growth company, indicate by check mark if the registrant has elected not to use the extended transition period for complying with any new or revised financial accounting standard provided pursuant to Section 13(a) of the Exchange Act. __

Indicate by check mark whether the registrant is a shell company (as defined in Rule 12b-2 of the Exchange Act). Yes x No

Indicate the number of shares outstanding of each of the issuer’s classes of common stock, as of the latest practicable date.



Class		Outstanding as of October 31, ~~2018~~2019
Common Stock, par value $1.00 per share		~~14,452,521~~14,976,493

ARROW FINANCIAL CORPORATION

FORM 10-Q

TABLE OF CONTENTS

PART I - FINANCIAL INFORMATION

Item 1.

FINANCIAL STATEMENTS

ARROW FINANCIAL CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS (In Thousands, Except Share and Per Share Amounts) (Unaudited)	ARROW FINANCIAL CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS (In Thousands, Except Share and Per Share Amounts) (Unaudited)									ARROW FINANCIAL CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS (In Thousands, Except Share and Per Share Amounts) (Unaudited)

	September 30, 2018			December 31, 2017			September 30, 2017			September 30, 2019			December 31, 2018			September 30, 2018
ASSETS
Cash and Due From Banks	$	57,385		$	42,562		$	55,683		$	65,882		$	56,529		$	57,385
Interest-Bearing Deposits at Banks	34,910			30,276			24,983			26,416			27,710			34,910
Investment Securities:
Available-for-Sale	340,411			300,200			315,459			314,182			317,535			340,411
Held-to-Maturity (Approximate Fair Value of $282,719 at September 30, 2018; $335,901 at December 31, 2017; and $343,899 at September 30, 2017)	289,952			335,907			341,526
Held-to-Maturity (Approximate Fair Value of $259,128 at September 30, 2019; $280,338 at December 31, 2018; and $282,719 at September 30, 2018)										255,095			283,476			289,952
Equity Securities	1,916			—			—			1,996			1,774			1,916
Other Investments	10,866			9,949			6,704			6,627			15,506			10,866
Loans	2,126,100			1,950,770			1,908,799			2,335,591			2,196,215			2,126,100
Allowance for Loan Losses	(20,003		)	(18,586		)	(17,695		)	(20,931		)	(20,196		)	(20,003		)
Net Loans	2,106,097			1,932,184			1,891,104			2,314,660			2,176,019			2,106,097
Premises and Equipment, Net	28,601			27,619			26,432			40,228			30,446			28,601
Goodwill	21,873			21,873			21,873			21,873			21,873			21,873
Other Intangible Assets, Net	1,954			2,289			2,395			1,713			1,852			1,954
Other Assets	59,255			57,606			58,303			64,150			55,614			59,255
Total Assets	$	2,953,220		$	2,760,465		$	2,744,462		$	3,112,822		$	2,988,334		$	2,953,220
LIABILITIES
Noninterest-Bearing Deposits	$	490,469		$	441,945		$	448,515		$	516,876		$	472,768		$	490,469
Interest-Bearing Checking Accounts	899,547			907,315			967,250			801,446			790,781			899,547
Savings Deposits	758,727			694,573			696,805			929,691			818,048			758,727
Time Deposits over $250,000	76,226			38,147			28,464			96,770			73,583			76,226
Other Time Deposits	182,886			163,136			166,082			269,764			190,404			182,886
Total Deposits	2,407,855			2,245,116			2,307,116			2,614,547			2,345,584			2,407,855
Federal Funds Purchased and Securities Sold Under Agreements to Repurchase	62,503			64,966			61,419			72,869			54,659			62,503
Federal Home Loan Bank Overnight Advances	131,000			105,000			33,000			48,000			234,000			131,000
Federal Home Loan Bank Term Advances	45,000			55,000			55,000			30,000			45,000			45,000
Junior Subordinated Obligations Issued to Unconsolidated Subsidiary Trusts	20,000			20,000			20,000			20,000			20,000			20,000
Finance Leases										5,263			—			—
Other Liabilities	22,052			20,780			23,279			29,915			19,507			22,052
Total Liabilities	2,688,410			2,510,862			2,499,814			2,820,594			2,718,750			2,688,410
STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY
Preferred Stock, $5 Par Value; 1,000,000 Shares Authorized	—			—			—
Common Stock, $1 Par Value; 20,000,000 Shares Authorized (19,035,565 Shares Issued at September 30, 2018; 18,481,301 at December 31, 2017 and 18,481,301 at September 30, 2017)	19,035			18,481			18,481
Preferred Stock, $1 Par Value and 1,000,000 Shares Authorized at September 30, 2019; $5 Par Value and 1,000,000 Shares Authorized at December 31, 2018 and September 30, 2018										—			—			—
Common Stock, $1 Par Value; 30,000,000 Shares Authorized at September 30, 2019 and 20,000,000 Shares Authorized at December 31, 2018 and September 30, 2018 (19,606,449 Shares Issued at September 30, 2019 and 19,035,565 at December 31, 2018 and September 30, 2018)										19,606			19,035			19,035
Additional Paid-in Capital	313,763			290,219			289,294			334,597			314,533			313,763
Retained Earnings	24,258			28,818			22,581			27,375			29,257			24,258
Unallocated ESOP Shares (9,932 Shares at September 30, 2018; 9,643 Shares at December 31, 2017 and 20,050 Shares at September 30, 2017)	(200		)	(200		)	(400		)
Unallocated ESOP Shares (5,151 Shares at September 30, 2019; 5,001 Shares at December 31, 2018 and 9,932 Shares at September 30, 2018)										(100		)	(100		)	(200		)
Accumulated Other Comprehensive Loss	(12,621		)	(8,514		)	(6,135		)	(8,979		)	(13,810		)	(12,621		)
Treasury Stock, at Cost (4,584,147 Shares at September 30, 2018; 4,541,524 Shares at December 31, 2017 and 4,570,291 Shares at September 30, 2017)	(79,425		)	(79,201		)	(79,173		)
Treasury Stock, at Cost (4,632,657 Shares at September 30, 2019; 4,558,207 Shares at December 31, 2018 and 4,584,147 Shares at September 30, 2018)										(80,271		)	(79,331		)	(79,425		)
Total Stockholders’ Equity	264,810			249,603			244,648			292,228			269,584			264,810
Total Liabilities and Stockholders’ Equity	$	2,953,220		$	2,760,465		$	2,744,462		$	3,112,822		$	2,988,334		$	2,953,220

See Notes to Unaudited Interim Consolidated Financial Statements.

ARROW FINANCIAL CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF INCOME (In Thousands, Except Per Share Amounts) (Unaudited)	ARROW FINANCIAL CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF INCOME (In Thousands, Except Per Share Amounts) (Unaudited)								ARROW FINANCIAL CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF INCOME (In Thousands, Except Per Share Amounts) (Unaudited)

	Three Months Ended September 30,				Nine Months Ended September 30,				Three Months Ended September 30,					Nine Months Ended September 30,
	2018		2017		2018		2017		2019			2018		2019			2018
INTEREST AND DIVIDEND INCOME
Interest and Fees on Loans	$	20,839	$	17,996	$	59,606	$	51,693	$	24,620		$	20,839	$	70,543		$	59,606
Interest on Deposits at Banks	182		104		474		242		182			182		572			474
Interest and Dividends on Investment Securities:
Fully Taxable	2,187		1,924		6,128		5,927		2,018			2,187		6,671			6,128
Exempt from Federal Taxes	1,287		1,575		4,295		4,660		1,132			1,287		3,606			4,295
Total Interest and Dividend Income	24,495		21,599		70,503		62,522		27,952			24,495		81,392			70,503
INTEREST EXPENSE
Interest-Bearing Checking Accounts	390		376		1,165		1,088		500			390		1,435			1,165
Savings Deposits	901		356		2,134		963		2,317			901		5,926			2,134
Time Deposits over $250,000	301		66		833		187		451			301		1,362			833
Other Time Deposits	370		241		911		702		1,255			370		3,099			911
Federal Funds Purchased and Securities Sold Under Agreements to Repurchase	15		13		47		29		28			15		75			47
Federal Home Loan Bank Advances	1,270		700		2,340		1,651		820			1,270		3,513			2,340
Junior Subordinated Obligations Issued to Unconsolidated Subsidiary Trusts	251		197		712		564		250			251		780			712
Interest on Financing Leases									28			—		71			—
Total Interest Expense	3,498		1,949		8,142		5,184		5,649			3,498		16,261			8,142
NET INTEREST INCOME	20,997		19,650		62,361		57,338		22,303			20,997		65,131			62,361
Provision for Loan Losses	586		800		1,961		1,580		518			586		1,445			1,961
NET INTEREST INCOME AFTER PROVISION FOR LOAN LOSSES	20,411		18,850		60,400		55,758		21,785			20,411		63,686			60,400
NONINTEREST INCOME
Income From Fiduciary Activities	2,262		2,116		7,106		6,284		2,212			2,262		6,571			7,106
Fees for Other Services to Customers	2,605		2,453		7,555		6,875		2,623			2,605		7,570			7,555
Insurance Commissions	2,024		2,113		6,119		6,426		1,936			2,024		5,590			6,119
Net Gain on Securities	114		10		355		10
Net Gain on Securities Transactions									146			114		222			355
Net Gain on Sales of Loans	54		182		115		431		257			54		501			115
Other Operating Income	291		267		900		867		517			291		1,020			900
Total Noninterest Income	7,350		7,141		22,150		20,893		7,691			7,350		21,474			22,150
NONINTEREST EXPENSE
Salaries and Employee Benefits	9,771		9,382		28,952		27,740		10,015			9,771		29,061			28,952
Occupancy Expenses, Net	2,262		2,371		7,223		7,410		1,324			1,132		4,023			3,742
Technology and Equipment Expense									3,305			2,759		9,689			8,306
FDIC Assessments	218		225		658		679		(480		)	218		(56		)	658
Other Operating Expense	3,775		3,570		11,341		10,832		2,627			2,146		7,634			6,516
Total Noninterest Expense	16,026		15,548		48,174		46,661		16,791			16,026		50,351			48,174
INCOME BEFORE PROVISION FOR INCOME TAXES	11,735		10,443		34,376		29,990		12,685			11,735		34,809			34,376
Provision for Income Taxes	2,475		3,027		6,855		8,735		2,618			2,475		7,074			6,855
NET INCOME	$	9,260	$	7,416	$	27,521	$	21,255	$	10,067		$	9,260	$	27,735		$	27,521
Average Shares Outstanding ¹:
Basic	14,431		14,305		14,393		14,306		14,955			14,864		14,927			14,825
Diluted	14,520		14,385		14,479		14,401		14,991			14,956		14,968			14,914
Per Common Share:
Basic Earnings	$	0.64	$	0.52	$	1.91	$	1.49	$	0.67		$	0.62	$	1.86		$	1.85
Diluted Earnings	0.64		0.52		1.90		1.48		0.67			0.62		1.85			1.84

¹~~2017~~ 2018 Share and Per Share Amounts have been restated for the September 27, ~~2018~~2019 3% stock dividend.

See Notes to Unaudited Interim Consolidated Financial Statements.

ARROW FINANCIAL CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF COMPREHENSIVE INCOME (In Thousands) (Unaudited)	ARROW FINANCIAL CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF COMPREHENSIVE INCOME (In Thousands) (Unaudited)												ARROW FINANCIAL CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF COMPREHENSIVE INCOME (In Thousands) (Unaudited)

	Three Months Ended September 30,						Nine Months Ended September 30,						Three Months Ended September 30,					Nine Months Ended September 30,
	2018			2017			2018			2017			2019		2018			2019		2018
Net Income	$	9,260		$	7,416		$	27,521		$	21,255		$	10,067	$	9,260		$	27,735	$	27,521
Other Comprehensive Income, Net of Tax:
Other Comprehensive Income (Loss), Net of Tax:
Net Unrealized Securities Holding Gains (Losses) Arising During the Period	(897		)	9			(4,017		)	465			499		(897		)	4,323		(4,017		)
Reclassification Adjustments for Securities Gains Included in Net Income	—			(6		)	—			(6		)
Amortization of Net Retirement Plan Actuarial Loss	60			64			181			245			127		60			381		181
Accretion of Net Retirement Plan Prior Service Credit	20			(2		)	60			(5		)
Amortization of Net Retirement Plan Prior Service Cost													42		20			127		60
Other Comprehensive Income (Loss)	(817		)	65			(3,776		)	699			668		(817		)	4,831		(3,776		)
Comprehensive Income	$	8,443		$	7,481		$	23,745		$	21,954		$	10,735	$	8,443		$	32,566	$	23,745

See Notes to Unaudited Interim Consolidated Financial Statements.

ARROW FINANCIAL CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES

CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CHANGES IN ~~STOCKHOLDERS~~’STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY

(In Thousands, Except Share and Per Share Amounts)

(Unaudited)

Common
Stock

Additional
Paid-In
Capital

Retained
Earnings

Unallo-cated ESOP
Shares

Accumu-lated
Other Com-
prehensive
Loss

Treasury
Stock
Total
Balance at December 31, 2017 $ 18,481
$ 290,219
$ 28,818
$ (200 ) $ (8,514 ) $ (79,201 ) $ 249,603
Net Income —
—
27,521
—
—
—
27,521
Other Comprehensive Loss —
—
—
—
(3,776 ) —
(3,776 )
Impact of the Adoption of ASU 2014-09 —
—
(102 ) —
—
—
(102 )
Impact of the Adoption of ASU 2016-01 —
—
331
—
(331 ) —
—
3% Stock Dividend (554,264 Shares) 554
21,126
(21,680 ) —
—
—
—
Cash Dividends Paid, $.728 per Share —
—
(10,630 ) —
—
—
(10,630 )
Stock Options Exercised, Net  (91,979 Shares) —
942
—
—
—
1,035
1,977
Shares Issued Under the Directors’ Stock
  Plan (2,705 Shares)
—
72
—
—
—
31
103
Shares Issued Under the Employee Stock
  Purchase Plan (10,801 Shares)
—
247
—
—
—
121
368
Shares Issued for Dividend
  Reinvestment Plans (35,947 Shares)
—
890
—
—
—
412
1,302
Stock-Based Compensation Expense —
267
—
—
—
—
267
Purchase of Treasury Stock
  (50,697 Shares)
—
—
—
—
—
(1,823 ) (1,823 )
Balance at September 30, 2018 $ 19,035
$ 313,763
$ 24,258
$ (200 ) $ (12,621 ) $ (79,425 ) $ 264,810

Balance at December 31, 2016 $ 17,943
$ 270,880
$ 28,644
$ (400 ) $ (6,834 ) $ (77,381 ) $ 232,852
Net Income —
—
21,255
—
—
—
21,255
Other Comprehensive Income —
—
—
—
699
—
699
3% Stock Dividend (538,100 Shares) 538
16,661
(17,199 ) —
—
—
—
Cash Dividends Paid, $.707 per Share ¹
—
—
(10,119 ) —
—
—
(10,119 )
Stock Options Exercised, Net (34,489 Shares) —
335
—
—
—
399
734
Shares Issued Under the Directors’ Stock
  Plan (3,927 Shares)
—
84
—
—
—
42
126
Shares Issued Under the Employee Stock
  Purchase Plan (10,869 Shares)
—
230
—
—
—
121
351
Shares Issued for Dividend
  Reinvestment Plans (37,525 Shares)
—
843
—
—
—
413
1,256
Stock-Based Compensation Expense —
261
—
—
—
—
261
Purchase of Treasury Stock
(83,256 Shares)
—
—
—
—
—
(2,767 ) (2,767 )
Balance at September 30, 2017 $ 18,481
$ 289,294
$ 22,581
$ (400 ) $ (6,135 ) $ (79,173 ) $ 244,648



	Nine-Month Period Ended September 30, 2019
	Common Stock		Additional Paid-In Capital		Retained Earnings			Unallo-cated ESOP Shares			Accumu-lated Other Com- prehensive Loss			Treasury Stock			Total
Balance at December 31, 2018	$	19,035	$	314,533	$	29,257		$	(100	)	$	(13,810	)	$	(79,331	)	$	269,584
Net Income	—		—		27,735			—			—			—			27,735
Other Comprehensive Income	—		—		—			—			4,831			—			4,831
3% Stock Dividend (570,884 Shares)	571		17,737		(18,308		)	—			—			—			—
Cash Dividends Paid, $.757 per Share	—		—		(11,309		)	—			—			—			(11,309		)
Stock Options Exercised, Net (76,775 Shares)	—		802		—			—			—			838			1,640
Shares Issued Under the Directors’ Stock Plan (3,997 Shares)	—		86		—			—			—			44			130
Shares Issued Under the Employee Stock Purchase Plan (11,403 Shares)	—		236		—			—			—			124			360
Shares Issued for Dividend Reinvestment Plans (39,078 Shares)	—		911		—			—			—			422			1,333
Stock-Based Compensation Expense	—		292		—			—			—			—			292
Purchase of Treasury Stock (70,711 Shares)	—		—		—			—			—			(2,368		)	(2,368		)
Balance at September 30, 2019	$	19,606	$	334,597	$	27,375		$	(100	)	$	(8,979	)	$	(80,271	)	$	292,228

	Three-Month Period Ended September 30, 2019
	Common Stock		Additional Paid-In Capital		Retained Earnings			Unallo-cated ESOP Shares			Accumu-lated Other Com- prehensive Loss			Treasury Stock			Total
Balance at June 30, 2019	$	19,035	$	316,229	$	39,397		$	(100	)	$	(9,647	)	$	(80,265	)	$	284,649
Net Income	—		—		10,067			—			—			—			10,067
Other Comprehensive Income	—		—		—			—			668			—			668
3% Stock Dividend (570,884 Shares)	571		17,737		(18,308		)	—			—			—			—
Cash Dividends Paid, $.252 per Share	—		—		(3,781		)	—			—			—			(3,781		)
Stock Options Exercised, Net (14,063 Shares)	—		164		—			—			—			151			315
Shares Issued Under the Employee Stock Purchase Plan (3,455 Shares)	—		73		—			—			—			37			110
Shares Issued for Dividend Reinvestment Plans (12,380 Shares)	—		296		—			—			—			133			429
Stock-Based Compensation Expense	—		98		—			—			—			—			98
Purchase of Treasury Stock (10,151 Shares)	—		—		—			—			—			(327		)	(327		)
Balance at September 30, 2019	$	19,606	$	334,597	$	27,375		$	(100	)	$	(8,979	)	$	(80,271	)	$	292,228

See Notes to Unaudited Interim Consolidated Financial Statements.

ARROW FINANCIAL CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES

CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CHANGES IN STOCKHOLDERS’ EQUITY (Continued)

(In Thousands, Except Share and Per Share Amounts)

(Unaudited)



	Nine-Month Period Ended September 30, 2018
	Common Stock		Additional Paid-In Capital		Retained Earnings			Unallo-cated ESOP Shares			Accumu-lated Other Com- prehensive Loss			Treasury Stock			Total
Balance at December 31, 2017	$	18,481	$	290,219	$	28,818		$	(200	)	$	(8,514	)	$	(79,201	)	$	249,603
Net Income	—		—		27,521			—			—			—			27,521
Other Comprehensive Loss	—		—		—			—			(3,776		)	—			(3,776		)
Impact of the Adoption of ASU 2014-09	—		—		(102		)	—			—			—			(102		)
Impact of the Adoption of ASU 2016-01	—		—		331			—			(331		)	—			—
3% Stock Dividend (554,264 Shares)	554		21,126		(21,680		)	—			—			—			—
Cash Dividends Paid, $.716 per Share ¹	—		—		(10,630		)	—			—			—			(10,630		)
Stock Options Exercised, Net (91,979 Shares)	—		942		—			—			—			1,035			1,977
Shares Issued Under the Directors’ Stock Plan (2,705 Shares)	—		72		—			—			—			31			103
Shares Issued Under the Employee Stock Purchase Plan (10,801 Shares)	—		247		—			—			—			121			368
Shares Issued for Dividend Reinvestment Plans (35,947 Shares)	—		890		—			—			—			412			1,302
Stock-Based Compensation Expense	—		267		—			—			—			—			267
Purchase of Treasury Stock (50,697 Shares)	—		—		—			—			—			(1,823		)	(1,823		)
Balance at September 30, 2018	$	19,035	$	313,763	$	24,258		$	(200	)	$	(12,621	)	$	(79,425	)	$	264,810

	Three-Month Period Ended September 30, 2018
	Common Stock		Additional Paid-In Capital		Retained Earnings			Unallo-cated ESOP Shares			Accumu-lated Other Com- prehensive Loss			Treasury Stock			Total
Balance at June 30, 2018	$	18,481	$	292,020	$	40,326		$	(200	)	$	(11,804	)	$	(79,335	)	$	259,488
Net Income	—		—		9,260			—			—			—			9,260
Other Comprehensive Loss	—		—		—			—			(817		)	—			(817		)
3% Stock Dividend (538,100 Shares)	554		21,126		(21,680		)	—			—			—			—
Cash Dividends Paid, $.245 per Share ¹	—		—		(3,648		)	—			—			—			(3,648		)
Stock Options Exercised, Net (12,978 Shares)	—		138		—			—			—			147			285
Shares Issued Under the Employee Stock Purchase Plan (3,188 Shares)	—		80		—			—			—			36			116
Shares Issued for Dividend Reinvestment Plans (11,642 Shares)	—		310		—			—			—			136			446
Stock-Based Compensation Expense	—		89		—			—			—			—			89
Purchase of Treasury Stock (10,688 Shares)	—		—		—			—			—			(409		)	(409		)
Balance at September 30, 2018	$	19,035	$	313,763	$	24,258		$	(200	)	$	(12,621	)	$	(79,425	)	$	264,810

¹ Cash dividends paid per share have been adjusted for the September 27, ~~2018~~2019 3% stock dividend.

See Notes to Unaudited Interim Consolidated Financial Statements.

ARROW FINANCIAL CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES

CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF CASH FLOWS

(Dollars in Thousands)

~~(Unaudited)~~


	Nine Months Ended September 30,						Nine Months Ended September 30,
Cash Flows from Operating Activities:	2018			2017			2019			2018
Net Income	$	27,521		$	21,255		$	27,735		$	27,521
Adjustments to Reconcile Net Income to Net Cash Provided by Operating Activities:
Provision for Loan Losses	1,961			1,580			1,445			1,961
Depreciation and Amortization	3,576			4,247			3,994			3,576
Net Gains on the Sale of Securities Available-for-Sale	—			(10		)
Net Gain on Equity Securities	(355		)	—
Net Gain on Securities Transactions							(222		)	(355		)
Loans Originated and Held-for-Sale	(3,378		)	(14,890		)	(20,612		)	(3,378		)
Proceeds from the Sale of Loans Held-for-Sale	3,620			14,481			19,424			3,620
Net Gain on the Sale of Loans	(115		)	(431		)	(501		)	(115		)
Net Loss on the Sale of Premises and Equipment, Other Real Estate Owned and Repossessed Assets	155			197			798			155
Contributions to Retirement Benefit Plans	(524		)	(640		)	(492		)	(524		)
Deferred Income Tax Benefit	(389		)	(20		)	(644		)	(389		)
Shares Issued Under the Directors’ Stock Plan	103			126			130			103
Stock-Based Compensation Expense	267			261			292			267
Tax Benefit from Exercise of Stock Options	205			112			199			205
Net Increase in Other Assets	(1,030		)	(1,689		)	(9,302		)	(1,030		)
Net Increase in Other Liabilities	1,980			1,819			10,480			1,980
Net Cash Provided By Operating Activities	33,597			26,398			32,724			33,597
Cash Flows from Investing Activities:
Proceeds from the Sale of Securities Available-for-Sale	—			10,015
Proceeds from the Maturities and Calls of Securities Available-for-Sale	36,663			43,617			79,077			36,663
Purchases of Securities Available-for-Sale	(84,746		)	(22,503		)	(70,418		)	(84,746		)
Proceeds from the Maturities and Calls of Securities Held-to-Maturity	49,721			39,062			31,161			49,721
Purchases of Securities Held-to-Maturity	(4,506		)	(36,018		)	(3,398		)	(4,506		)
Net Increase in Loans	(176,607		)	(156,643		)	(140,360		)	(176,607		)
Proceeds from the Sales of Premises and Equipment, Other Real Estate Owned and Repossessed Assets	1,078			830			1,282			1,078
Purchase of Premises and Equipment	(2,371		)	(1,335		)	(6,698		)	(2,371		)
Proceeds from the Sale of a Subsidiary, Net	75			72			—			75
Net (Increase) Decrease in Other Investments	(917		)	4,208
Net Decrease (Increase) in Other Investments							8,879			(917		)
Net Cash Used By Investing Activities	(181,610		)	(118,695		)	(100,475		)	(181,610		)
Cash Flows from Financing Activities:
Net Increase in Deposits	162,739			190,570			268,963			162,739
Net Increase (Decrease) in Short-Term Federal Home Loan Bank Borrowings	26,000			(90,000		)
Net (Decrease) Increase in Short-Term Federal Home Loan Bank Borrowings							(186,000		)	26,000
Net Increase (Decrease) in Short-Term Borrowings	(2,463		)	25,583			18,210			(2,463		)
Finance Lease Payments							(19		)	—
Repayments of Federal Home Loan Bank Term Advances	(10,000		)	—			(15,000		)	(10,000		)
Purchase of Treasury Stock	(1,823		)	(2,767		)	(2,368		)	(1,823		)
Stock Options Exercised, Net	1,977			734			1,640			1,977
Shares Issued Under the Employee Stock Purchase Plan	368			351			360			368
Shares Issued for Dividend Reinvestment Plans	1,302			1,256			1,333			1,302
Cash Dividends Paid	(10,630		)	(10,119		)	(11,309		)	(10,630		)
Net Cash Provided By Financing Activities	167,470			115,608			75,810			167,470
Net Increase in Cash and Cash Equivalents	19,457			23,311			8,059			19,457
Cash and Cash Equivalents at Beginning of Period	72,838			57,355			84,239			72,838
Cash and Cash Equivalents at End of Period	$	92,295		$	80,666		$	92,298		$	92,295

Supplemental Disclosures to Statements of Cash Flow Information:
Interest on Deposits and Borrowings	$	7,946		$	5,168		$	15,329		$	7,946
Income Taxes	7,493			8,404			7,131			7,493
Non-cash Investing and Financing Activity:
Transfer of Loans to Other Real Estate Owned and Repossessed Assets	606			1,055			1,530			606

See Notes to Unaudited Interim Consolidated Financial Statements.

NOTES TO INTERIM CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS

(Unaudited)

Note 1. ACCOUNTING POLICIES

In the opinion of the management of Arrow Financial Corporation (Arrow, the Company, we, or us), the accompanying unaudited interim consolidated financial statements contain all of the adjustments necessary to present fairly the financial position as of September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, December 31, ~~2017~~2018 and September 30, ~~2017;~~2018; the results of operations for the ~~three- and~~three-and nine-month periods ended September 30, ~~2018~~2019 and ~~2017;~~2018; the consolidated statements of comprehensive income for the three- and nine-month periods ended September 30, ~~2018~~2019 and ~~2017;~~2018; the changes in stockholders' equity for the three-month and nine-month periods ended September 30, ~~2018~~2019 and ~~2017;~~2018; and the cash flows for the nine-month periods ended September 30, ~~2018~~2019 and ~~2017.~~2018. All such adjustments are of a normal recurring nature.

Management’s Use of Estimates -The preparation of the consolidated financial statements in conformity with accounting principles generally accepted in the United States of America requires management to make estimates and assumptions that affect the reported amounts of assets and liabilities and disclosure of contingent assets and liabilities at the date of the consolidated financial statements and the reported amounts of income and expenses during the reporting period. Our most significant estimate is the allowance for loan losses. Other estimates include the evaluation of other-than-temporary impairment of investment securities, goodwill impairment, pension and other postretirement liabilities and an analysis of a need for a valuation allowance for deferred tax assets. Actual results could differ from those estimates.

A material estimate that is particularly susceptible to significant change in the near term is the allowance for loan losses. In connection with the determination of the allowance for loan losses, management obtains appraisals for properties. The allowance for loan losses is management’s best estimate of probable loan losses incurred as of the balance sheet date. While management uses available information to recognize losses on loans, future adjustments to the allowance for loan losses may be necessary based on changes in economic conditions.

The unaudited interim consolidated financial statements should be read in conjunction with the audited annual consolidated financial statements of Arrow for the year ended December 31, ~~2017,~~2018 included in Arrow's Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, ~~2017.~~2018.

Recently Adopted and Recently Issued Accounting Standards

The following accounting standards have been adopted in the first nine months of ~~2018:~~2019:

~~ASU 2014-09 "Revenue from Contracts With Customers" (Topic 606) was adopted~~In March 2017, the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) issued Accounting Standards Update (ASU) 2017-08 "Receivables-Nonrefundable Fees and Other Costs" which amends the amortization period for certain purchased callable debt securities held at a premium. This shortens the amortization period for the premium to the earliest call date. Under United States generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), entities generally amortize the premium as an adjustment of ~~January 1, 2018. For additional information, see Revenue Recognition under Significant Accounting Policy Update in this Note.~~

~~ASU 2016-01 "Recognition and Measurement~~yield over the contractual life of ~~Financial Assets and Financial Liabilities" (Subtopic 825-10) significantly changed~~ the ~~income statement impact of equity investments.~~instrument. For Arrow, the standard became effective for the first quarter of 2018, and requires that equity investments be measured at fair value, with changes in fair value recognized in net income. The cumulative effect of the January 1, 2018 adoption was an increase to retained earnings of $331 thousand with a corresponding decrease to Accumulated Other Comprehensive Loss. For periods prior to January 1, 2018, equity securities were classified as available-for-sale and stated at fair value with unrealized gains and losses reported as a separate component of accumulated other comprehensive income, net of tax. ASU 2016-01 also emphasized the existing requirement to use exit prices to measure fair value for disclosure purposes and clarifies that entities not make use of a practicability exception in determining the fair value of loans. Accordingly, the Company refined the calculation used to determine the disclosed fair value of its loans as part of adopting this standard. See Note 9 to the unaudited interim consolidated financial statements titled Fair Value of Financial Instruments.

ASU 2016-15 "Statement of Cash Flows - Classification of Certain Cash Receipts and Cash Payments" (Topic 230) will reduce existing diversity in practice with respect to eight specific cash flow issues. Arrow adopted this ASU in the first quarter of 2018.

ASU 2017-01 "Business Combinations" (Topic 805) defines when a set of assets and activities constitutes a business for the purposes of determining whether transactions should be accounted for as acquisitions (or disposals) of assets or businesses. The amendments in this update allow for a business to consist of inputs, processes, and the ability to create output. For Arrow, the standard became effective in the first quarter of ~~2018. This update had no effect on its accounting for acquisitions~~2019 and ~~dispositions of businesses.~~

ASU 2017-07 "Compensation-Retirement Benefits" (Topic 715) improves the presentation of net periodic pension cost and net periodic post-retirement benefit cost by requiring that an employer disaggregate the service cost component from the other components of net benefit cost. For Arrow, the standard became effective in the first quarter of 2018. In accordance with the practical expedient adoption method, for all periods presented Arrow used the amounts disclosed in the retirement plans footnote for the prior period retrospective reclassification of the non-service cost components from salaries and benefits to other operating expenses. The adoption of this change in accounting for pension costs did not have a material impact on its financial position or the results of operations.

ASU 2017-09 "Compensation-Stock Compensation" (Topic 718) provides guidance about which changes to the terms and conditions of a share-based payment award require an entity to apply modification accounting in Topic 718. The guidance highlights the requirements for applying modification accounting and the exception criteria relating to changes in share-based payment terms. For Arrow, the standard became effective in the first quarter of 2018. The adoption of this change in accounting for share-based payment awards did not have a material impact on its financial position or the results of operations in ~~periods subsequent to its adoption.~~

~~The following accounting standards have been issued and will become effective for~~ the ~~Company at a~~current quarter or in future ~~date:~~periods.

In February 2016, the FASB issued ASU 2016-02, "Leases" (Topic 842) which requires lessees to recognize right-of-use assets and lease liabilities on the balance sheet for all leases with terms longer than 12 months. For a lease with a term of 12 months or less, a lessee is permitted to make an accounting policy election by class of underlying asset not to recognize a right-of-use asset and lease liability. Additionally, when measuring assets and liabilities arising from a lease, optional payments should be included only if the lessee is reasonably certain to exercise an option to extend the lease, exercise a purchase option or not exercise an option to terminate the lease. In January 2018, the FASB issued ASU 2018-01, Leases (Topic 842): "Land Easement Practical Expedient for Transition to Topic 842". In July 2018, the FASB issued ASU 2018-10 "Codification Improvements to Topic 842, Leases" which provided clarification on certain components of the original guidance, including that the rate implicit in the lease cannot be less than zero. Also in July 2018, the FASB issued ASU 2018-11 "Targeted Improvements" to Leases (Topic 842) which amends the original guidance to allow for the adoption of this standard to be applied retrospectively at the beginning of the period of adoption, which ~~will be~~was January 1, 2019 for Arrow, ~~through a cumulative-effect adjustment to the balance sheet, including retained earnings,~~without revising prior comparative periods.

The Company adopted this standard as of January 1, ~~2019.~~ 2019 using the effective date method, also known as the modified retrospective method, with the cumulative-effect adjustment recorded at the beginning of the period of adoption. As a result of this adoption, the Company's assets increased $7.9 million and the Company's liabilities increased $8.0 million with no adjustment required to retained earnings and no material impact to the consolidated statements of income.

Practical Expedients Elected At Adoption: The package of practical expedients ~~may be~~were elected that ~~would~~did not require ~~Arrow~~the Company to reassess whether an existing contract contains a lease, to reassess existing leases between operating leases and finance leases ~~and~~or to ~~not~~ reassess initial direct costs for any existing leases. ~~If elected, these~~These practical expedients ~~must be~~were applied together. ~~An entity may~~In addition, the Company also ~~elect~~elected a practical expedient, which ~~must~~was required to be applied consistently to all of its leases, to use hindsight in determining the lease term when considering lessee options to extend or terminate the lease and in assessing impairment in the right-of-use asset. ~~In addition, a lessor may make an~~

Accounting Policy Elections: The Company also made two accounting policy ~~election, by class~~elections related to the adoption of ~~underlying asset,~~this standard. The first was a determination not to ~~not~~ separate ~~nonlease components from~~ lease and non-lease components and account for ~~these components~~the resulting combined component as a single lease component. ~~Early adoption of this standard is permitted in any interim or annual period.~~ The ~~Company expects~~second election was to ~~adopt the new lease standard on January 1, 2019 through a cumulative-effect adjustment without revising prior comparative periods, and elect the practical expedients available to effectively~~ account for short-term leases, ~~commenced prior~~those leases with a "lease term" of twelve months or less, like an operating lease under current GAAP.

Determination of the Discount Rate to Calculate the ~~effective date. The~~Lease Liability: Since the Company ~~expects assets and liabilities~~was unable to ~~increase between $7 million and $9 million at~~determine the rate implicit in its leases, the secured borrowing rate from the Federal Home Loan Bank of New York as of the January 1, 2019 adoption date was utilized for existing leases for the effective lease term beginning with ~~no material impact~~the effective date of each existing lease. The expected expiration date of each lease was determined on a lease-by-lease basis based on the availability of renewal options in the lease contracts, the amount of leasehold improvements at each location, total branch deposits at each location in addition to ~~operating~~the feasibility of growth potential at each location. A similar process is followed to determine the expected lease ~~expense in its Consolidated Statements~~expiration date for all leases executed subsequent to the January 1, 2019 adoption date. The discount rate is determined for leases executed subsequent to the January 1, 2019 adoption date based on

the expected lease term using the secured borrowing rate from the Federal Home Loan Bank of ~~Income.~~New York as of the effective date of the lease.

The following accounting standards have been issued and will become effective for the Company at a future date:

In June 2016, the FASB issued ASU 2016-13 "Financial Instruments - Credit Losses" (Topic 326) which will change the way financial entities measure expected credit losses for financial assets, primarily loans. Under this ASU, the "incurred loss" model will be replaced with an "expected loss" model which will recognize losses over the life of the instrument and requires consideration of a broader range of reasonable and supportable information. Currently, credit losses on available-for-sale securities reduce the carrying value of the instrument and cannot be reversed. Under this ASU, the amount of the credit loss is carried as a valuation allowance and can be reversed. The standard also requires expanded credit quality disclosures. ~~For Arrow,~~In April 2019, the ~~standard~~FASB issued ASU 2019-04 "Codification Improvements to Topic 326, Financial Instruments-Credit Losses; Topic 815, Derivatives and Hedging; and Topic 825, Financial Instruments," which clarifies that the estimate of expected credit losses should include expected recoveries of financial assets, and that contractual extension or renewal options that are not unconditionally cancellable by the lender are considered when determining the contractual term over which expected credit losses are measured. The Company's loan terms for contractual extensions and renewal options are unconditionally cancellable by the Company (that is, ~~effective~~the Company has no obligation to extend or renew existing loans), and therefore are not considered in measuring expected credit losses. In May 2019, the FASB issued ASU 2019-05 "Targeted Transition Relief," which allows entities to irrevocably elect the fair value option for certain financial assets measured at amortized cost, not including held-to-maturity investment securities which will continue to be measured at amortized cost. This will apply to those institutions that elect the ~~first quarter~~fair value option on newly originated or purchased financial assets, to avoid the possibility of ~~2020 and~~dual measurement methodologies for identical or similar financial assets.

Although early adoption is allowed in ~~2019. The~~2019, the Company plans on adopting the standard in the first quarter of 2020, in order to maximize the accumulation of data needed to calculate the new current expected credit loss ~~("CECL")~~(CECL) methodologies. The ASU describes several acceptable methodologies for calculating expected losses on a loan or a pool of loans and requires additional disclosures. The initial adjustment will not be reported in earnings, but as the cumulative effect of a change in accounting principle. The ~~FASB’s Transition Research Group for credit losses still~~Company has ~~several outstanding unresolved questions, some of which may have a significant impact on CECL calculations. The Company continues~~continued its implementation efforts with the development and testing of various methods within its core model, ~~developing~~and has tentatively identified the discounted cash flow method for determining losses for the commercial loan portfolios and the residential real estate portfolios, and the vintage method for the consumer indirect loan portfolio. Based on further testing, these methods may change prior to adoption. As a result of analyses performed, including the availability of future economic data, the Company plans to utilize an 18-month reasonable and supportable forecast ~~scenarios, monitoring~~period, and reverting to an historic loss rate using the straight-line method over a two year reversion period. The Company has identified the economic data that best correlates with expected loan losses through the use of various regression analyses of historical economic information and loan losses. The adoption of this standard will change the way qualitative factors are determined as compared to the current methodology used under the incurred loss model. The Company has been evaluating various methodologies and data to determine the appropriate qualitative factor loss rates that are not included in the CECL total loss computation using the above-mentioned methods, losses from the reasonable and supportable forecast and reversion process. The Company continues to monitor new regulatory guidance ~~interpretations~~ and ~~consideration of~~is updating relevant internal controls and processes. This will likely have the effect of increasing the allowance for loan and lease losses and reducing shareholders' equity, the extent of which will depend upon the nature and characteristics of the Company's loan portfolio and economic conditions and forecasts at the adoption date.. The Company expects to remain a well-capitalized financial institution under current regulatory calculations.

In January 2017, the FASB issued ASU 2017-04 "Intangibles-Goodwill and Other" (Topic 350) which simplifies the procedures for evaluating impairment of goodwill. Prior to the adoption of this standard, entities were required to perform procedures to determine the fair value of the underlying assets and liabilities for determining the fair value of assets and liabilities in a business combination. This additional step to impairment testing has been eliminated. Under this ASU, entities will perform goodwill impairment testing by comparing the fair value of a reporting unit to its carrying value. For Arrow, the standard becomes effective in the first quarter of 2019, however, early adoption is permitted. This amendment will not affect the assessment of goodwill impairment since the Company currently performs the analysis of comparing carrying value to fair value of its reporting units that have goodwill and the Company has not had to perform a Step 2 Impairment Test to date.

In March 2017, the FASB issued ASU 2017-08 "Receivables-Nonrefundable Fees and Other Costs" which amends the amortization period for certain purchased callable debt securities held at a premium. This shortens the amortization period for the premium to the earliest call date. Under GAAP, entities generally amortize the premium as an adjustment of yield over the contractual life of the instrument. For Arrow, the standard becomes effective in the first quarter of 2019. The Company does not expect that the adoption of this change in accounting for certain callable debt securities will have a material impact on its financial position or the results of operations in periods subsequent to its adoption.

In August 2018, the FASB issued ASU 2018-13 "Disclosure Framework-Changes to the Disclosure Requirements for Fair Value Measurement" ~~which~~ as part of its disclosure framework, ~~the~~and pursuant to which FASB has eliminated, amended and added disclosure requirements for fair value measurements. The following disclosure requirements were eliminated: ~~Amount~~amount of and reasons for transfers between Level 1 and Level 2 of the fair value hierarchy; the policy of the timing of transfers between levels of the fair value hierarchy; and the valuation processes for Level 3 fair value measurements. For public companies such as Arrow, the following new disclosures will be required: ~~Changes~~changes in unrealized gains and losses for the period included in other comprehensive income (OCI); the range and weighted average of significant unobservable inputs ~~used;~~used or, alternatively, a company may choose to disclose other quantitative information if it determines that it is a more reasonable and rational method that reflects the distribution of unobservable inputs used. For Arrow, the standard becomes effective in the first quarter of 2020. The Company does not expect that the adoption of this change in fair value disclosure will have a material impact on its financial position or the results of operations in periods subsequent to its adoption.

In August 2018, the FASB issued ASU 2018-14 "Disclosure Framework-Changes to the Disclosure Requirements for Defined Benefit Plans" which applies to all companies that provide defined benefit pension or other postretirement benefit plans for their employees. Certain disclosure requirements have been eliminated such as reporting the amounts in accumulated other comprehensive income expected to

be recognized as components of net periodic benefit cost over the next year, and reporting the effects of a one-percentage-point change in the assumed healthcare cost trend rate on the aggregate of the service cost and interest cost components of net periodic benefit cost and on the benefit obligation for postretirement healthcare benefits. New required disclosures for reporting the weighted-average interest rate used to credit cash balance and similar plans that have a promised interest credit, the reasons for significant gains and losses affecting benefit obligations and other requirements for reporting aggregate information related to pension plans. For Arrow, the standard becomes effective at December 31, 2020. The Company does not expect that the adoption of this change affecting defined benefit plan disclosures will have a material impact on its financial position or the results of operations.

In August 2018, the FASB issued ASU 2018-15 "Customer's Accounting for Implementation Costs Incurred in a Cloud Computing Arrangement That Is a Service Contract" which will require companies to defer potentially significant, specified implementation costs incurred in a cloud computing arrangement that are currently often expensed under ~~current~~ US GAAP. For Arrow, the standard becomes effective at January 1, 2020. The Company ~~is in~~does not expect that the ~~process of assessing the impact~~adoption of this ~~new accounting~~ standard will have a material impact on its financial position ~~and~~or the results of operations in periods subsequent to its adoption.

~~Significant Accounting Policy Update:~~

~~Revenue Recognition -~~ Accounting Standard Codification ("ASC") Topic 606, "Revenue from Contracts with Customers," establishes principles for reporting information about the nature, amount, timing and uncertainty of revenue and cash flows arising from the entity's contracts to provide goods or services to customers. The core principle of Topic 606 requires an entity to recognize revenue in a way that depicts the transfer of goods or services promised to a customer in an amount that reflects the consideration the entity expects to receive in exchange for those goods or services as performance obligations are satisfied.

The Company adopted Topic 606 as of January 1, 2018 using the modified retrospective approach. The Company has determined that revenue from specific types of fiduciary activities and insurance commissions are within the scope of this guidance. Under prior GAAP, revenue from fiduciary activities was recognized from settling client estates over the time period the work was performed. With the adoption of Topic 606, revenue is now recognized when the performance obligation is completed, which is when the settlement of the client estate is closed. The impact of this change in revenue recognition was not material to the Company's consolidated financial statements. Under prior GAAP when clients elected to pay premiums on property and casualty insurance policies in installments, revenue was recognized when the premiums were billed. With the adoption of Topic 606, this type of revenue is recognized when the performance obligation is substantially completed, i.e., when the insurance policy is issued. The impact of this change in revenue recognition was not material to the Company's consolidated financial statements. The cumulative effect of the adoption of Topic 606 related to the previously described fiduciary activities and insurance commissions was a decrease in retained earnings by $102 thousand as of January 1, 2018.

The majority of the Company's revenue-generating transactions are not subject to ASC Topic 606, including revenue generated from financial instruments, such as loans and investment securities which are presented in its consolidated income statements as components of net interest income. The following is a description of principal activities from which the Company generates its revenue from noninterest income sources that are within the scope of ASC Topic 606:

Income from Fiduciary Activities: represents revenue derived mainly through the management of client investments which is based on the market value of the covered assets and the fee schedule contained in the applicable account management agreement. Since the revenue is mainly based on the market value of assets, this amount can be volatile as financial markets increase and decrease based on various economic factors. The terms of the account management agreements generally specify that the performance obligations are completed each quarter. Accordingly, the Company mainly recognizes revenue from fiduciary activities on a quarterly basis.

Fees for Other Services to Customers: represents general service fees for monthly deposit account maintenance and account activity plus fees from other deposit-based services. Revenue is recognized when the performance obligation is completed, which is generally on a monthly basis for account maintenance services, or upon the completion of a deposit-related transaction. Payment for these performance obligations is generally received at the time the performance obligations are satisfied.

Insurance Commissions: represents commissions and fees paid by insurance carriers for both property and casualty insurance policies, and for services performed for employment benefits clients. Revenue from the property and casualty insurance business is recognized when the performance obligation is satisfied, which is generally the effective date of the bound coverage since there are no significant performance obligations remaining. Revenue from the employment benefit brokerage business is recognized when the benefit servicing performance obligations are satisfied, generally on a monthly basis.

Note 2. INVESTMENT SECURITIES (In Thousands)

Management determines the appropriate classification of securities at the time of purchase. Securities reported as held-to-maturity are those debt securities which Arrow has both the positive intent and ability to hold to maturity and are stated at amortized cost. Securities available-for-sale are reported at fair value, with unrealized gains and losses reported in accumulated other comprehensive income or loss, net of taxes. Beginning January 1, 2018, upon adoption of ASU 2016-01, equity securities with readily determinable fair values are stated at fair value with realized and unrealized gains and losses reported in income. For periods prior to January 1, 2018, equity securities were classified as available-for-sale and stated at fair value with unrealized gains and losses reported as a separate component of accumulated other comprehensive income, net of tax.

The following table is the schedule of Available-For-Sale Securities at September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, December 31, ~~2017~~2018 and September 30, ~~2017:~~2018:

																							Available-For-Sale Securities
	U.S. Government & Agency Obligations		State and Municipal Obligations		Mortgage- Backed Securities		Corporate and Other Debt Securities		Mutual Funds and Equity Securities		Total Available- For-Sale Securities		U.S. Government & Agency Obligations		State and Municipal Obligations		Mortgage- Backed Securities		Corporate and Other Debt Securities		Total Available- For-Sale Securities
September 30, 2018
September 30, 2019
Available-For-Sale Securities, at Amortized Cost	$	60,135	$	2,545	$	284,236	$	1,000	$	—	$	347,916	$	5,003	$	965	$	306,374	$	1,000	$	313,342
Available-For-Sale Securities, at Fair Value	59,602		2,548		277,461		800		—		340,411		5,056		965		307,361		800		314,182
Gross Unrealized Gains	—		3		201		—		—		204		53		—		1,482		—		1,535
Gross Unrealized Losses	533		—		6,976		200		—		7,709		—		—		495		200		695
Available-For-Sale Securities, Pledged as Collateral											219,587										232,043

Maturities of Debt Securities, at Amortized Cost:
Within One Year	$	42,621	$	1,346	$	1,024	$	—			$	44,991	$	—	$	226	$	81	$	—	$	307
From 1 - 5 Years	17,514		719		164,808		—				183,041		5,003		299		184,202		—		189,504
From 5 - 10 Years	—		—		103,597		—				103,597		—		—		84,036		—		84,036
Over 10 Years	—		480		14,807		1,000				16,287		—		440		38,055		1,000		39,495

Maturities of Debt Securities, at Fair Value:
Within One Year	$	42,410	$	1,346	$	1,025	$	—			$	44,781	$	—	$	227	$	82	$	—	$	309
From 1 - 5 Years	17,192		722		158,846		—				176,760		5,056		299		185,197		—		190,552
From 5 - 10 Years	—		—		102,800		—				102,800		—		—		84,013		—		84,013
Over 10 Years	—		480		14,790		800				16,070		—		439		38,069		800		39,308

Securities in a Continuous Loss Position, at Fair Value:
Less than 12 Months	$	4,831	$	1,120	$	167,718	$	—	$	—	$	173,669	$	—	$	—	$	4,763	$	—	$	4,763
12 Months or Longer	54,771		—		71,433		800		—		127,004		—		—		114,483		800		115,283
Total	$	59,602	$	1,120	$	239,151	$	800	$	—	$	300,673	$	—	$	—	$	119,246	$	800	$	120,046
Number of Securities in a Continuous Loss Position	14		5		90		1		—		110		—		—		48		1		49

Unrealized Losses on Securities in a Continuous Loss Position:
Less than 12 Months	$	193	$	—	$	3,165	$	—	$	—	$	3,358	$	—	$	—	$	70	$	—	$	70
12 Months or Longer	340		—		3,811		200		—		4,351		—		—		425		200		625
Total	$	533	$	—	$	6,976	$	200	$	—	$	7,709	$	—	$	—	$	495	$	200	$	695

Disaggregated Details:
US Treasury Obligations, at Amortized Cost	$	—											$	—
US Treasury Obligations, at Fair Value	—												—
US Agency Obligations, at Amortized Cost	60,135												5,003
US Agency Obligations, at Fair Value	59,602												5,056
US Government Agency Securities, at Amortized Cost																	$	64,455
US Government Agency Securities, at Fair Value																	64,364
Government Sponsored Entity Securities, at Amortized Cost																	241,919
Government Sponsored Entity Securities, at Fair Value																	242,997

																							Available-For-Sale Securities
	U.S. Government & Agency Obligations		State and Municipal Obligations		Mortgage- Backed Securities		Corporate and Other Debt Securities		Mutual Funds and Equity Securities		Total Available- For-Sale Securities		U.S. Government & Agency Obligations		State and Municipal Obligations		Mortgage- Backed Securities		Corporate and Other Debt Securities		Total Available- For-Sale Securities
US Government Agency Securities, at Amortized Cost					$	74,160
US Government Agency Securities, at Fair Value					74,098
Government Sponsored Entity Securities, at Amortized Cost					210,076
Government Sponsored Entity Securities, at Fair Value					203,363

December 31, 2017
December 31, 2018
Available-For-Sale Securities, at Amortized Cost	$	60,328	$	10,351	$	229,077	$	1,000	$	1,120	$	301,876	$	47,071	$	1,193	$	273,227	$	1,000	$	322,491
Available-For-Sale Securities, at Fair Value	59,894		10,349		227,596		800		1,561		300,200		46,765		1,195		268,775		800		317,535
Gross Unrealized Gains	—		9		485		—		441		935		—		2		288		—		290
Gross Unrealized Losses	434		11		1,966		200		—		2,611		306		—		4,740		200		5,246
Available-For-Sale Securities, Pledged as Collateral, at Fair Value											183,052										236,163

Securities in a Continuous Loss Position, at Fair Value:
Less than 12 Months	$	20,348	$	8,498	$	70,930	$	—	$	—	$	99,776	$	—	$	—	$	107,550	$	—	$	107,550
12 Months or Longer	39,546		—		80,759		800		—		121,105		46,765		—		124,627		800		172,192
Total	$	59,894	$	8,498	$	151,689	$	800	$	—	$	220,881	$	46,765	$	—	$	232,177	$	800	$	279,742
Number of Securities in a Continuous Loss Position	14		36		55		1		—		106		10		—		86		1		97

Unrealized Losses on Securities in a Continuous Loss Position:
Less than 12 Months	$	172	$	11	$	363	$	—	$	—	$	546	$	—	$	—	$	841	$	—	$	841
12 Months or Longer	262		—		1,603		200		—		2,065		306		—		3,899		200		4,405
Total	$	434	$	11	$	1,966	$	200	$	—	$	2,611	$	306	$	—	$	4,740	$	200	$	5,246

Disaggregated Details:
US Treasury Obligations, at Amortized Cost	$	—											$	—
US Treasury Obligations, at Fair Value	—												—
US Agency Obligations, at Amortized Cost	60,328												47,071
US Agency Obligations, at Fair Value	59,894												46,765
US Government Agency Securities, at Amortized Cost					$	40,832											$	72,095
US Government Agency Securities, at Fair Value					40,832												71,800
Government Sponsored Entity Securities, at Amortized Cost					188,245												201,132
Government Sponsored Entity Securities, at Fair Value					186,764												196,975

																							Available-For-Sale Securities
	U.S. Government & Agency Obligations		State and Municipal Obligations		Mortgage- Backed Securities		Corporate and Other Debt Securities		Mutual Funds and Equity Securities		Total Available- For-Sale Securities		U.S. Government & Agency Obligations		State and Municipal Obligations		Mortgage- Backed Securities		Corporate and Other Debt Securities		Total Available- For-Sale Securities
September 30, 2017
September 30, 2018
Available-For-Sale Securities, at Amortized Cost	$	146,976	$	11,875	$	152,858	$	2,500	$	1,120	$	315,329	$	60,135	$	2,545	$	284,236	$	1,000	$	347,916
Available-For-Sale Securities, at Fair Value	146,978		11,902		152,806		2,299		1,474		315,459		59,602		2,548		277,461		800		340,411
Gross Unrealized Gains	152		27		964		—		354		1,497		—		3		201		—		204
Gross Unrealized Losses	150		—		1,016		201		—		1,367		533		—		6,976		200		7,709
Available-For-Sale Securities, Pledged as Collateral											206,637										219,587

Securities in a Continuous Loss Position, at Fair Value:
Less than 12 Months	$	89,563	$	—	$	85,091	$	500	$	—	$	175,154	$	4,831	$	1,120	$	167,718	$	—	$	173,669
12 Months or Longer	—		—		—		1,800		—		1,800		54,771		—		71,433		800		127,004
Total	$	89,563	$	—	$	85,091	$	2,300	$	—	$	176,954	$	59,602	$	1,120	$	239,151	$	800	$	300,673
Number of Securities in a Continuous Loss Position	23		—		31		3		—		57		14		5		90		1		110

Unrealized Losses on Securities in a Continuous Loss Position:
Less than 12 Months	$	150	$	—	$	1,016	$	—	$	—	$	1,166	$	193	$	—	$	3,165	$	—	$	3,358
12 Months or Longer	—		—		—		201		—		201		340		—		3,811		200		4,351
Total	$	150	$	—	$	1,016	$	201	$	—	$	1,367	$	533	$	—	$	6,976	$	200	$	7,709

Disaggregated Details:
US Treasury Obligations, at Amortized Cost	$	64,711											$	—
US Treasury Obligations, at Fair Value	$	64,730											—
US Agency Obligations, at Amortized Cost	$	82,265											60,135
US Agency Obligations, at Fair Value	82,248												59,602
US Government Agency Securities, at Amortized Cost					$	503											$	74,160
US Government Agency Securities, at Fair Value					505						��						74,098
Government Sponsored Entity Securities, at Amortized Cost					152,355												210,076
Government Sponsored Entity Securities, at Fair Value					152,301												203,363

The following table is the schedule of Held-To-Maturity Securities at September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, December 31, ~~2017~~2018 and September 30, ~~2017:~~2018:

															Held-To-Maturity Securities
	State and Municipal Obligations		Mortgage- Backed Securities		Corporate and Other Debt Securities		Total Held-To Maturity Securities		State and Municipal Obligations		Mortgage- Backed Securities		Total Held-To Maturity Securities
September 30, 2018
September 30, 2019
Held-To-Maturity Securities, at Amortized Cost	$	239,367	$	50,585	$	—	$	289,952	$	215,661	$	39,434	$	255,095
Held-To-Maturity Securities, at Fair Value	233,557		49,162		—		282,719		219,296		39,832		259,128
Gross Unrealized Gains	261		—		—		261		3,669		408		4,077
Gross Unrealized Losses	6,071		1,423		—		7,494		34		10		44
Held-To-Maturity Securities, Pledged as Collateral							268,229						244,373

Maturities of Debt Securities, at Amortized Cost:
Within One Year	$	19,381	$	—	$	—	$	19,381	$	21,974	$	3,691	$	25,665
From 1 - 5 Years	93,084		48,039		—		141,123		112,660		35,743		148,403
From 5 - 10 Years	124,277		2,546		—		126,823		79,378		—		79,378
Over 10 Years	2,625		—		—		2,625		1,649		—		1,649

Maturities of Debt Securities, at Fair Value:
Within One Year	$	19,396	$	—	$	—	$	19,396	$	22,007	$	3,689	$	25,696
From 1 - 5 Years	92,199		46,688		—		138,887		114,246		36,143		150,389
From 5 - 10 Years	119,356		2,474		—		121,830		81,359		—		81,359
Over 10 Years	2,606		—		—		2,606		1,684		—		1,684

Securities in a Continuous Loss Position, at Fair Value:
Less than 12 Months	$	95,944	$	46,375	$	—	$	142,319	$	763	$	3,082	$	3,845
12 Months or Longer	86,378		2,787		—		89,165		6,764		1,711		8,475
Total	$	182,322	$	49,162	$	—	$	231,484	$	7,527	$	4,793	$	12,320

Number of Securities in a Continuous Loss Position	535		47		—		582		19		19		38

Unrealized Losses on Securities in a Continuous Loss Position:
Less than 12 Months	$	1,443	$	1,303	$	—	$	2,746	$	1	$	9	$	10
12 Months or Longer	4,628		120		—		4,748		33		1		34
Total	$	6,071	$	1,423	$	—	$	7,494	$	34	$	10	$	44

Disaggregated Details:
US Government Agency Securities, at Amortized Cost			$	3,147							$	1,844
US Government Agency Securities, at Fair Value			2,222								1,854
Government Sponsored Entity Securities, at Amortized Cost			47,438								37,590
Government Sponsored Entity Securities, at Fair Value			46,940								37,978

															Held-To-Maturity Securities
	State and Municipal Obligations		Mortgage- Backed Securities		Corporate and Other Debt Securities		Total Held-To Maturity Securities		State and Municipal Obligations		Mortgage- Backed Securities		Total Held-To Maturity Securities
December 31, 2017
December 31, 2018
Held-To-Maturity Securities, at Amortized Cost	$	275,530	$	60,377	$	—	$	335,907	$	235,782	$	47,694	$	283,476
Held-To-Maturity Securities, at Fair Value	275,353		60,548		—		335,901		233,359		46,979		280,338
Gross Unrealized Gains	1,691		269		—		1,960		486		—		486
Gross Unrealized Losses	1,868		98		—		1,966		2,909		715		3,624
Held-To-Maturity Securities, Pledged as Collateral							318,622						266,341

Securities in a Continuous Loss Position, at Fair Value:
Less than 12 Months	$	55,648	$	13,764	$	—	$	69,412	$	32,093	$	33,309	$	65,402
12 Months or Longer	65,152		3,257		—		68,409		110,947		13,670		124,617
Total	$	120,800	$	17,021	$	—	$	137,821	$	143,040	$	46,979	$	190,019
Number of Securities in a Continuous Loss Position	352		14		—		366		411		47		458

Unrealized Losses on Securities in a Continuous Loss Position:
Less than 12 Months	$	442	$	56	$	—	$	498	$	162	$	456	$	618
12 Months or Longer	1,425		43		—		1,468		2,747		259		3,006
Total	$	1,867	$	99	$	—	$	1,966	$	2,909	$	715	$	3,624

Disaggregated Details:
US Government Agency Securities, at Amortized Cost			$	2,680							$	2,180
US Government Agency Securities, at Fair Value			2,661								2,143
Government Sponsored Entity Securities, at Amortized Cost			57,697								45,514
Government Sponsored Entity Securities, at Fair Value			57,887								44,836

September 30, 2017
September 30, 2018
Held-To-Maturity Securities, at Amortized Cost	$	277,738	$	63,788	$	—	$	341,526	$	239,367	$	50,585	$	289,952
Held-To-Maturity Securities, at Fair Value	279,384		64,515		—		343,899		233,557		49,162		282,719
Gross Unrealized Gains	2,977		738		—		3,715		261		—		261
Gross Unrealized Losses	1,331		11		—		1,342		6,071		1,423		7,494
Held-To-Maturity Securities, Pledged as Collateral							325,096						268,229

Securities in a Continuous Loss Position, at Fair Value:
Less than 12 Months	$	78,238	$	3,544	$	—	$	81,782	$	95,944	$	46,375	$	142,319
12 Months or Longer	13,331		—		—		13,331		86,378		2,787		89,165
Total	$	91,569	$	3,544	$	—	$	95,113	$	182,322	$	49,162	$	231,484
Number of Securities in a Continuous Loss Position	252		7		—		259		535		47		582

Unrealized Losses on Securities in a Continuous Loss Position:
Less than 12 Months	$	1,034	$	11	$	—	$	1,045	$	1,443	$	1,303	$	2,746
12 Months or Longer	297		—		—		297		4,628		120		4,748
Total	$	1,331	$	11	$	—	$	1,342	$	6,071	$	1,423	$	7,494

										Held-To-Maturity Securities
	State and Municipal Obligations	Mortgage- Backed Securities		Corporate and Other Debt Securities	Total Held-To Maturity Securities	State and Municipal Obligations	Mortgage- Backed Securities		Total Held-To Maturity Securities
September 30, 2017
September 30, 2018
Disaggregated Details:
US Government Agency Securities, at Amortized Cost		$	2,792				$	3,147
US Government Agency Securities, at Fair Value		2,799					2,222
Government Sponsored Entity Securities, at Amortized Cost		60,996					47,438
Government Sponsored Entity Securities, at Fair Value		61,716					46,940

In the tables above, maturities of mortgage-backed securities are included based on their expected average lives. Actual maturities will differ ~~from the table above~~ because issuers may have the right to call or prepay obligations with or without prepayment penalties.

Securities in a continuous loss position, in the tables above for September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, December 31, ~~2017~~2018 and September 30, ~~2017,~~2018, do not reflect any deterioration of the credit worthiness of the issuing entities.

U.S. government agency securities, including mortgage-backed securities, are all rated AAA by Moody's and AA+ by Standard and Poor's. The state and municipal obligations are general obligations supported by the general taxing authority of the issuer, and in some cases are insured. Obligations issued by school districts are supported by state aid. ~~An in-house credit~~Credit analysis is performed ~~for municipal securities~~in-house based upon data that has been submitted by the issuers to the New York State Comptroller. That analysis ~~reflects satisfactory~~shows no deterioration in the credit worthiness of the municipalities. Subsequent to September 30, ~~2018, and through the date of the filing of this Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q, Arrow held~~2019, there were no securities ~~with significant credit deterioration.~~downgraded below investment grade.

The unrealized losses on these temporarily impaired securities are primarily the result of changes in interest rates for fixed rate securities where the interest rate received is less than the current rate available for new offerings of similar securities, changes in market spreads as a result of shifts in supply and demand, and/or changes in the level of prepayments for mortgage related securities. Because ~~Arrow does not currently intend~~there is no current intention to sell any of our temporarily impaired securities, and because it is not more ~~likely-than-not~~likely than not that ~~the Company~~it would be required to sell the securities prior to recovery, the impairment is considered temporary.

Pledged securities, in the tables above, are primarily used to collateralize state and municipal deposits, as required under New York State law. A portion of the pledged securities are used to collateralize repurchase agreements and pooled deposits of our trust customers.

The following table is the schedule of Equity Securities at September 30, ~~2018. Upon the adoption of ASU 2016-01 effective January 1,~~2019, December 31, 2018 ~~Equity Securities are not included in Securities Available-For-Sale since unrealized gains~~ and ~~losses are now recorded in the Consolidated Statements of Income. Prior to January 1, 2018, Equity Securities were included in Securities Available-For-Sale.~~September 30, 2018:

						Equity Securities

September 30, 2018
			September 30, 2019	December 31, 2018	September 30, 2018
Equity Securities, at Fair Value	$	1,916	$1,996	$1,774	$1,916

The following is a summary of realized and unrealized gains and losses recognized in net income on equity securities during the three- and nine-month periods ended September 30, 2019 and 2018:


					Quarterly Period Ended:				Year-to-Date Period Ended:
	Three months ended September 30, 2018		Nine months ended September 30, 2018		September 30, 2019		September 30, 2018		September 30, 2019		September 30, 2018
Net Gain on Equity Securities	$	114	$	355	$	146	$	114	$	222	$	355
Less: Net gain (loss) recognized during the reporting period on equity securities sold during the period	—		—		—		—		—		—
Unrealized net gain recognized during the reporting period on equity securities still held at the reporting date	$	114	$	355	$	146	$	114	$	222	$	355

Note 3. LOANS (In Thousands)

Loan Categories and Past Due Loans

The following table presents loan balances outstanding as of September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, December 31, ~~2017~~2018 and September 30, ~~2017~~2018 and an analysis of the recorded investment in loans that are past due at these dates. Generally, Arrow considers ~~an amortizing~~a loan past due 30 or more days when the borrower is two payments past due. Loans held-for-sale of ~~$201, $327~~$1,905, $215 and ~~$1,323~~$201 as of September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, December 31, ~~2017~~2018 and September 30, ~~2017,~~2018, respectively, are included in the residential real estate balances for current loans.


Schedule of Past Due Loans by Loan Category											Schedule of Past Due Loans by Loan Category
													Commercial
			Commercial								Commercial		Real Estate		Consumer		Residential		Total
September 30, 2019
Loans Past Due 30-59 Days											$	99	$	—	$	5,216	$	241	$	5,556
Loans Past Due 60-89 Days											48		30		1,624		1,011		2,713
Loans Past Due 90 or more Days											—		328		415		2,387		3,130
Total Loans Past Due											147		358		7,255		3,639		11,399
Current Loans											141,988		497,725		798,542		885,937		2,324,192
Total Loans											$	142,135	$	498,083	$	805,797	$	889,576	$	2,335,591

Loans 90 or More Days Past Due and Still Accruing Interest											$	—	$	—	$	86	$	980	$	1,066
Nonaccrual Loans											28		465		564		2,408		3,465

December 31, 2018
Loans Past Due 30-59 Days											$	121	$	108	$	5,369	$	281	$	5,879
Loans Past Due 60-89 Days											49		—		2,136		1,908		4,093
Loans Past Due 90 or more Days											—		789		572		1,844		3,205
Total Loans Past Due											170		897		8,077		4,033		13,177
Current Loans											136,720		483,665		711,433		851,220		2,183,038
Total Loans											$	136,890	$	484,562	$	719,510	$	855,253	$	2,196,215

Loans 90 or More Days Past Due and Still Accruing Interest											$	—	$	—	$	144	$	1,081	$	1,225
Nonaccrual Loans											403		789		658		2,309		4,159
	Commercial		Real Estate		Consumer		Residential		Total
September 30, 2018
Loans Past Due 30-59 Days	$	198	$	—	$	5,651	$	2,896	$	8,745	$	198	$	—	$	5,651	$	2,896	$	8,745
Loans Past Due 60-89 Days	—		—		1,307		47		1,354		—		—		1,307		47		1,354
Loans Past Due 90 or more Days	76		807		494		1,523		2,900		76		807		494		1,523		2,900
Total Loans Past Due	274		807		7,452		4,466		12,999		274		807		7,452		4,466		12,999
Current Loans	126,838		469,315		686,736		830,212		2,113,101		126,838		469,315		686,736		830,212		2,113,101
Total Loans	$	127,112	$	470,122	$	694,188	$	834,678	$	2,126,100	$	127,112	$	470,122	$	694,188	$	834,678	$	2,126,100

Loans 90 or More Days Past Due and Still Accruing Interest	$	—	$	—	$	192	$	980	$	1,172	$	—	$	—	$	192	$	980	$	1,172
Nonaccrual Loans	674		807		540		2,447		4,468		674		807		540		2,447		4,468

December 31, 2017
Loans Past Due 30-59 Days	$	139	$	—	$	5,891	$	2,094	$	8,124
Loans Past Due 60-89 Days	19		—		1,215		509		1,743
Loans Past Due 90 or more Days	99		807		513		1,422		2,841
Total Loans Past Due	257		807		7,619		4,025		12,708
Current Loans	128,992		443,441		595,208		770,421		1,938,062
Total Loans	$	129,249	$	444,248	$	602,827	$	774,446	$	1,950,770

Loans 90 or More Days Past Due and Still Accruing Interest	$	—	$	—	$	6	$	313	$	319
Nonaccrual Loans	$	588	$	1,530	$	653	$	2,755	5,526

September 30, 2017
Loans Past Due 30-59 Days	$	122	$	442	$	4,781	$	1,675	$	7,020
Loans Past Due 60-89 Days	—		—		914		77		991
Loans Past Due 90 or more Days	102		807		291		1,742		2,942
Total Loans Past Due	224		1,249		5,986		3,494		10,953
Current Loans	125,136		439,467		586,043		747,200		1,897,846
Total Loans	$	125,360	$	440,716	$	592,029	$	750,694	$	1,908,799

Loans 90 or More Days Past Due and Still Accruing Interest	$	—	$	—	$	41	$	926	$	967
Nonaccrual Loans	$	609	$	1,249	$	507	$	3,117	5,482

The Company disaggregates its loan portfolio into the following four categories:

Commercial - The Company offers a variety of loan options to meet the specific needs of commercial customers including term loans, time notes and lines of credit. Such loans are made available to businesses for working capital needs such as inventory and receivables, business expansion and equipment purchases. Generally, a collateral lien is placed on equipment or other assets owned by the borrower. ~~These~~Generally, these loans carry a higher risk than commercial real estate loans, due primarily to the nature of the underlying collateral, which can be business assets such as equipment and accounts receivable and generally have a lower liquidation value than real estate. In the event of default by the borrower, the Company may be required to liquidate collateral at deeply discounted values. To reduce the risk, management usually obtains personal guarantees ofto support the ~~borrowers.~~borrowing, as permitted by applicable law.

Commercial Real Estate - The Company offers commercial real estate loans to finance real estate purchases, refinancings, expansions and improvements to commercial properties. Commercial real estate loans are often made to finance the purchases of real property which generally consists of real estate with completed structures. These commercial real estate loans are typically secured by first liens on the real estate, which may include apartments, commercial structures, housing businesses, healthcare facilities, and both owner- and non-owner-occupied facilities. These loans are typically less risky than commercial loans, since they are secured by real estate and buildings, and are generally originated in amounts of no more than 80% of the appraised value of the property. However, the Company also offers commercial construction and land development loans to finance ~~projects, primarily within the communities that we serve.~~projects. Many projects will ultimately be used by the borrowers' businesses, while others are developed for resale. These real estate loans are also typically secured by first liens on the real estate, which may include apartments, commercial structures, housing ~~business,~~businesses, healthcare facilities and both owner-occupied and non-owner-occupied facilities. There is enhanced risk during the construction period, since the loan is secured by an incomplete project.

Consumer Loans - Included in this category are automobile loans. The Company primarily finances the purchases of automobiles indirectly through dealer relationships located throughout upstate New York and Vermont. Most of these indirect consumer loans carry a fixed rate of interest with principal repayment terms typically ranging from three to seven years. Indirect consumer loans are underwritten on a secured basis using the underlying collateral being financed. The Company also offers a variety of consumer installment loans to finance personal expenditures. Most of these loans carry a fixed rate of interest with principal repayment terms typically ranging from one to five years, based upon the nature of the collateral and the size of the loan. In addition to installment loans, the Company also offers personal lines of credit and overdraft protection. Several loans are unsecured, which carry a higher risk of loss. Also included in this category are automobile loans. The Company primarily finances the purchases of automobiles indirectly through dealer relationships located throughout upstate New York and Vermont. Most of these loans carry a fixed rate of interest with principal repayment terms typically ranging from three to seven years. Indirect consumer loans are underwritten on a secured basis using the underlying collateral being financed.

Residential - Residential real estate loans consist primarily of loans secured by first or second mortgages on primary residences. The Company originates ~~adjustable-rate~~fixed-rate and ~~fixed-rate~~adjustable-rate one-to-four-family residential real estate loans for construction, the ~~construction,~~ purchase of real estate or refinancing of an existing mortgage. These loans are collateralized primarily by owner-occupied properties generally located in the Company’s market area. Loans on one-to-four-family residential real estate are generally originated in amounts of no more than 80% of the purchase price or appraised value (whichever is lower), or have private mortgage insurance. The Company’s underwriting analysis for residential mortgage loans typically includes credit verification, independent appraisals, and a review of the borrower’s financial condition. Mortgage title insurance and hazard insurance are normally required. It is the Company's general practice to underwrite residential real estate loans to secondary market standards. Construction loans have a unique risk, because they are secured by an incomplete dwelling. This risk is reduced through periodic site inspections, including one at each loan draw period. In addition, the Company offers fixed home equity loans, as well as variable rate home equity lines of credit, to consumers to finance home improvements, debt consolidation, education and other uses. The Company's policy allows for a maximum loan to value ratio of 80%, although periodically higher advances are allowed. The Company originates home equity lines of credit and second mortgage loans (loans secured by a second junior lien position on one-to-four-family residential real estate). Risk is generally reduced through underwriting criteria, which include credit verification, appraisals, a review of the borrower's financial condition, and personal cash flows. A security interest, with title insurance when necessary, is taken in the underlying real estate.

Allowance for Loan Losses

The following table presents a roll-forward of the allowance for loan losses and other information pertaining to the allowance for loan losses:

																														Allowance for Loan Losses
				Commercial															Commercial
	Commercial			Real Estate			Consumer			Residential			Total			Commercial			Real Estate		Consumer			Residential			Total
Roll-forward of the Allowance for Loan Losses for the Quarterly Periods:
June 30, 2019																$	1,231		$	5,459	$	9,654		$	4,351		$	20,695
Charge-offs																(11		)	—		(351		)	(40		)	(402		)
Recoveries																—			—		120			—			120
Provision																42			162		263			51			518
September 30, 2019																$	1,262		$	5,621	$	9,686		$	4,362		$	20,931

June 30, 2018	$	944		$	5,838		$	8,337		$	4,521		$	19,640		$	944		$	5,838	$	8,337		$	4,521		$	19,640
Charge-offs	—			—			(300		)	(25		)	(325		)	—			—		(300		)	(25		)	(325		)
Recoveries	—			—			102			—			102			—			—		102			—			102
Provision	99			81			551			(145		)	586			99			81		551			(145		)	586
September 30, 2018	$	1,043		$	5,919		$	8,690		$	4,351		$	20,003		$	1,043		$	5,919	$	8,690		$	4,351		$	20,003

June 30, 2017	$	925		$	4,983		$	7,305		$	4,229		$	17,442
Charge-offs	—			(342		)	(280		)	—			(622		)
Recoveries	1			—			74			—			75
Provision	(46		)	446			509			(109		)	800
September 30, 2017	$	880		$	5,087		$	7,608		$	4,120		$	17,695

																															Allowance for Loan Losses
				Commercial															Commercial
	Commercial			Real Estate			Consumer			Residential			Total			Commercial			Real Estate			Consumer			Residential			Total
Roll-forward of the Allowance for Loan Losses for the Year-to-Date Periods:
December 31, 2018																$	1,218		$	5,644		$	8,882		$	4,452		$	20,196
Charge-offs																(12		)	(29		)	(1,137		)	(54		)	(1,232		)
Recoveries																98			—			424			—			522
Provision																(42		)	6			1,517			(36		)	1,445
September 30, 2019																$	1,262		$	5,621		$	9,686		$	4,362		$	20,931

December 31, 2017	$	1,873		$	4,504		$	7,604		$	4,605		$	18,586		$	1,873		$	4,504		$	7,604		$	4,605		$	18,586
Charge-offs	(16		)	—			(895		)	(49		)	(960		)	(16		)	—			(895		)	(49		)	(960		)
Recoveries	1			12			403			—			416			1			12			403			—			416
Provision	(815		)	1,403			1,578			(205		)	1,961			(815		)	1,403			1,578			(205		)	1,961
September 30, 2018	$	1,043		$	5,919		$	8,690		$	4,351		$	20,003		$	1,043		$	5,919		$	8,690		$	4,351		$	20,003

December 31, 2016	$	1,017		$	5,677		$	6,120		$	4,198		$	17,012
Charge-offs	(2		)	(342		)	(847		)	(6		)	(1,197		)
Recoveries	8			—			292			—			300
Provision	(143		)	(248		)	2,043			(72		)	1,580
September 30, 2017	$	880		$	5,087		$	7,608		$	4,120		$	17,695
September 30, 2019
Allowance for loan losses - Loans Individually Evaluated for Impairment																$	5		$	—		$	—		$	—		$	5
Allowance for loan losses - Loans Collectively Evaluated for Impairment																1,257			5,621			9,686			4,362			20,926
Ending Loan Balance - Individually Evaluated for Impairment																36			—			113			575			724
Ending Loan Balance - Collectively Evaluated for Impairment																$	142,099		$	498,083		$	805,684		$	889,001		$	2,334,867

December 31, 2018
Allowance for loan losses - Loans Individually Evaluated for Impairment																$	—		$	—		$	—		$	4		$	4
Allowance for loan losses - Loans Collectively Evaluated for Impairment																1,218			5,644			8,882			4,448			20,192
Ending Loan Balance - Individually Evaluated for Impairment																430			793			101			1,899			3,223
Ending Loan Balance - Collectively Evaluated for Impairment																$	136,460		$	483,769		$	719,409		$	853,354		$	2,192,992

September 30, 2018
Allowance for loan losses - Loans Individually Evaluated for Impairment	$	84		$	45		$	—		$	48		$	177		$	84		$	45		$	—		$	48		$	177
Allowance for loan losses - Loans Collectively Evaluated for Impairment	959			5,874			8,690			4,303			19,826			959			5,874			8,690			4,303			19,826
Ending Loan Balance - Individually Evaluated for Impairment	489			812			109			2,013			3,423			489			812			109			2,013			3,423
Ending Loan Balance - Collectively Evaluated for Impairment	$	126,623		$	469,310		$	694,079		$	832,665		$	2,122,677		$	126,623		$	469,310		$	694,079		$	832,665		$	2,122,677

December 31, 2017
Allowance for loan losses - Loans Individually Evaluated for Impairment	$	94		$	2		$	—		$	10		$	106
Allowance for loan losses - Loans Collectively Evaluated for Impairment	1,779			4,502			7,604			4,595			18,480
Ending Loan Balance - Individually Evaluated for Impairment	489			1,537			95			1,562			3,683
Ending Loan Balance - Collectively Evaluated for Impairment	$	128,760		$	442,711		$	602,732		$	772,884		$	1,947,087

September 30, 2017
Allowance for loan losses - Loans Individually Evaluated for Impairment	$	104		$	—		$	—		$	34		$	138
Allowance for loan losses - Loans Collectively Evaluated for Impairment	776			5,087			7,608			4,086			17,557
Ending Loan Balance - Individually Evaluated for Impairment	489			1,543			104			1,139			3,275
Ending Loan Balance - Collectively Evaluated for Impairment	$	124,871		$	439,172		$	591,925		$	749,556		$	1,905,524

Through the provision for loan losses, an allowance for loan losses is maintained that reflects the best estimate of the incurred risk of loss in the Company’s loan portfolio as of the balance sheet date. Additions are made to the allowance for loan losses through a periodic provision for loan losses. Actual loan losses are charged against the allowance for loan losses when loans are deemed uncollectible and recoveries of amounts previously charged off are recorded as credits to the allowance for loan losses.

~~Loan~~Our loan officers and risk managers meet at least quarterly to discuss and review the conditions and risks associated with certain criticized and classified commercial-related relationships. In addition, ~~the Company's~~our independent internal loan review department performs periodic reviews of the credit quality indicators on individual loans in the commercial loan portfolio.

The Company uses a two-step process to determine the provision for loan losses and the amount of the allowance for loan losses. ~~The Company performs an~~An evaluation of impaired loans is performed on a quarterly basis. Impaired loans are generally nonaccrual loans over $250 thousand and all troubled debt restructured loans. ~~These~~Our impaired loans are generally considered to be collateral dependent with the charge-off, if any, determined based on the value of the collateral less estimated costs to sell.

The remainder of the portfolio is evaluated on a pooled basis, as described below. For each homogeneous loan pool, ~~the Company estimates~~ a total loss factor is estimated based on the historical net loss rates adjusted for applicable qualitative factors. The total loss factors assigned to each loan category are updated on a quarterly basis. For the commercial, commercial construction and commercial real estate categories, the loan categories are further segregated by credit risk profile (pools of loans graded pass, special mention and accruing substandard). Additional description of the credit risk classifications is detailed in the Credit Quality Indicators section of this note.

The ~~annualized~~ historical net loss rate is determined for each loan category using a trailing three-year net charge-off average. While historical net loss experience provides a reasonable starting point for analysis, historical net losses, or even recent trends in net losses, do not by themselves form a sufficient basis to determine the appropriate level of the allowance for loan losses. Therefore, ~~the Company also considers and adjusts~~ historical net loss factors are considered and adjusted for qualitative factors that impact the incurred risk of loss associated with the loan categories within the total loan portfolio. These include:

Changes in the volume and severity of past due, nonaccrual and adversely classified loans

Changes in the nature and volume of the portfolio and in the terms of loans

Changes in the value of the underlying collateral for collateral dependent loans

Changes in lending policies and procedures, including changes in underwriting standards and collection, charge-off, and recovery practices not considered elsewhere in estimating credit losses

Changes in the quality of the loan review system

Changes in the experience, ability, and depth of lending management and other relevant staff

Changes in international, national, regional, and local economic and business conditions and developments that affect the collectibility of the portfolio

The existence and effect of any concentrations of credit, and changes in the level of such concentrations

The effect of other external factors such as competition and legal and regulatory requirements on the level of estimated credit losses in the existing portfolio or pool

Loan Credit Quality Indicators

The following table presents the credit quality indicators by loan category at September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, December 31, ~~2017~~2018 and September 30, ~~2017:~~2018:

																					Loan Credit Quality Indicators
			Commercial										Commercial
											Commercial		Real Estate		Consumer		Residential		Total
September 30, 2019
Credit Risk Profile by Creditworthiness Category:
Satisfactory											$	135,355	$	471,637					$	606,992
Special Mention											107		2,484						2,591
Substandard											6,673		23,962						30,635
Doubtful											—		—						—
Credit Risk Profile Based on Payment Activity:
Performing															$	805,147	$	886,188	$	1,691,335
Nonperforming															650		3,388		4,038

December 31, 2018
Credit Risk Profile by Creditworthiness Category:
Satisfactory											$	129,584	$	456,868					$	586,452
Special Mention											—		—						—
Substandard											7,306		26,905						34,211
Doubtful											—		789						789
Credit Risk Profile Based on Payment Activity:
Performing															$	718,708	$	851,863	$	1,570,571
Nonperforming															802		3,390		4,192
	Commercial		Real Estate		Consumer		Residential		Total
September 30, 2018
Credit Risk Profile by Creditworthiness Category:
Satisfactory	$	119,217	$	440,114	$	—	$	—	$	559,331	$	119,217	$	440,114					$	559,331
Special Mention	5,949		—		—		—		5,949		5,949		—						5,949
Substandard	1,946		29,201		—		—		31,147		1,946		29,201						31,147
Doubtful	—		807		—		—		807		—		807						807
Credit Risk Profile Based on Payment Activity:
Performing	$	—	$	—	$	693,648	$	832,231	$	1,525,879					$	693,648	$	832,231	$	1,525,879
Nonperforming	—		—		540		2,447		2,987						540		2,447		2,987

December 31, 2017
Credit Risk Profile by Creditworthiness Category:
Satisfactory	$	124,961	$	417,362	$	—	$	—	$	542,323
Special Mention	1,341		177		—		—		1,518
Substandard	2,947		25,902		—		—		28,849
Doubtful	—		807		—		—		807
Credit Risk Profile Based on Payment Activity:
Performing	$	—	$	—	$	602,168	$	771,584	$	1,373,752
Nonperforming	—		—		659		3,068		3,727

September 30, 2017
Credit Risk Profile by Creditworthiness Category:
Satisfactory	$	120,622	$	411,685	$	—	$	—	$	532,307
Special Mention	1,394		1,401		—		—		2,795
Substandard	3,344		26,822		—		—		30,166
Doubtful	—		807		—		—		807
Credit Risk Profile Based on Payment Activity:
Performing	$	—	$	—	$	591,499	$	746,652	$	1,338,151
Nonperforming	—		—		530		4,043		4,573

For the purposes of the table above, nonperforming consumer and residential loans are those loans on nonaccrual status or are 90 days or more past due and still accruing interest.

For the allowance calculation, ~~we use~~ an internally developed system of five credit quality indicators is used to rate the credit worthiness of each commercial loan defined as follows:

1) Satisfactory - "Satisfactory" borrowers have acceptable financial condition with satisfactory record of earnings and sufficient historical and projected cash flow to service the debt. Borrowers have satisfactory repayment histories and primary and secondary sources of repayment can be clearly identified;

2) Special Mention - Loans in this category have potential weaknesses that deserve management’s close attention. If left uncorrected, these potential weaknesses may result in deterioration of the repayment prospects for the asset or in the institution’s credit position at some future date. "Special mention" assets are not adversely classified and do not expose an institution to sufficient risk to warrant adverse classification. Loans which might be assigned this credit quality indicator include loans to borrowers with deteriorating financial strength and/or earnings record and loans with potential for problems due to weakening economic or market conditions;

3) Substandard - Loans classified as “substandard” are inadequately protected by the current sound net worth or paying capacity of the borrower or the collateral pledged, if any. Loans in this category have well defined weaknesses that jeopardize the repayment.

They are characterized by the distinct possibility that the ~~bank~~Company will sustain some loss if the deficiencies are not corrected. “Substandard”

loans may include loans which are likely to require liquidation of collateral to effect repayment, and other loans where character or ability to repay has become suspect. Loss potential, while existing in the aggregate amount of substandard assets, does not have to exist in individual assets classified substandard;

4) Doubtful - Loans classified as “doubtful” have all of the weaknesses inherent in those classified as “substandard” with the added characteristic that the weaknesses make collection or liquidation in full, on the basis of current existing facts, conditions, and values, highly questionable and improbable. Although possibility of loss is extremely high, classification of these loans as “loss” has been deferred due to specific pending factors or events which may strengthen the value ~~(i.e.~~(e.g. possibility of additional collateral, injection of capital, collateral liquidation, debt restructure, economic recovery, etc). Loans classified as “doubtful” need to be placed on non-accrual; and

5) Loss - Loans classified as “loss” are considered uncollectible with collateral of such little value that their continuance as bankable assets is not warranted. As of the date of the balance sheet, all loans in this category have been charged-off to the allowance for loan losses.

Commercial loans are generally evaluated on an annual basis depending on the size and complexity of the loan relationship, unless the credit related quality indicator falls to a level of "special mention" or below, when the loan is evaluated quarterly. The credit quality indicator is one of the factors used in assessing the level of incurred risk of loss in our commercial related loan portfolios.

Impaired Loans

The following table presents information on impaired loans based on whether the impaired loan has a recorded related allowance or has no recorded related allowance:

																					Impaired Loans
			Commercial										Commercial
											Commercial		Real Estate		Consumer		Residential		Total
September 30, 2019
Recorded Investment:
With No Related Allowance											$	—	$	—	$	114	$	575	$	689
With a Related Allowance											35		—		—		—		35
Unpaid Principal Balance:
With No Related Allowance											—		—		113		575		688
With a Related Allowance											36		—		—		—		36

December 31, 2018
Recorded Investment:
With No Related Allowance											$	430	$	793	$	101	$	1,605	$	2,929
With a Related Allowance											—		—		—		294		294
Unpaid Principal Balance:
With No Related Allowance											429		793		100		1,606		2,928
With a Related Allowance											—		—		—		293		293
	Commercial		Real Estate		Consumer		Residential		Total
September 30, 2018
Recorded Investment:
With No Related Allowance	$	—	$	5	$	108	$	1,712	$	1,825	$	—	$	5	$	108	$	1,712	$	1,825
With a Related Allowance	475		801		—		346		1,622		475		801		—		346		1,622
Unpaid Principal Balance:
With No Related Allowance	—		5		109		1,733		1,847		—		5		109		1,733		$	1,847
With a Related Allowance	489		807		—		280		1,576		489		807		—		280		1,576

December 31, 2017
Recorded Investment:
For the Quarter Ended:
September 30, 2019
Average Recorded Balance:
With No Related Allowance	$	—	$	781	$	94	$	1,269	$	2,144	$	—	$	1	$	119	$	1,489	$	1,609
With a Related Allowance	485		725		—		333		1,543		36		—		—		—		36
Unpaid Principal Balance:
Interest Income Recognized:
With No Related Allowance											—		—		—		—		—
With a Related Allowance											—		—		—		—		—
Cash Basis Income:
With No Related Allowance	—		816		95		1,274		2,185		—		—		—		—		—
With a Related Allowance	489		721		—		288		1,498		—		—		—		—		—

September 30, 2017
Recorded Investment:
With No Related Allowance	$	—	$	818	$	104	$	851	$	1,773
With a Related Allowance	489		725		—		288		1,502
Unpaid Principal Balance:
With No Related Allowance	—		818		90		850		$	1,758
With a Related Allowance	489		723		—		288		1,500

For the Quarter Ended:
September 30, 2018
Average Recorded Balance:
With No Related Allowance	$	—	$	7	$	104	$	1,371	$	1,482	$	—	$	7	$	104	$	1,371	$	1,482
With a Related Allowance	478		794		—		350		1,622		478		794		—		350		1,622
Interest Income Recognized:
With No Related Allowance	—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—
With a Related Allowance	—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—
Cash Basis Income:
With No Related Allowance	—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—
With a Related Allowance	—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—

September 30, 2017
Average Recorded Balance:
With No Related Allowance	$	—	$	998	$	96	$	827	$	1,921
With a Related Allowance	496		363		—		288		1,147
Interest Income Recognized:
With No Related Allowance	—		—		1		—		1
With a Related Allowance	—		—		—		—		—
Cash Basis Income:
With No Related Allowance	—		—		—		—		—
With a Related Allowance	—		—		—		—		—

																					Impaired Loans
			Commercial										Commercial
	Commercial		Real Estate		Consumer		Residential		Total		Commercial		Real Estate		Consumer		Residential		Total
For the Year-To-Date Period Ended:
September 30, 2019
Average Recorded Balance:
With No Related Allowance											$	215	$	397	$	108	$	1,090	$	1,810
With a Related Allowance											18		—		—		147		165
Interest Income Recognized:
With No Related Allowance											—		—		—		—		—
With a Related Allowance											—		—		—		—		—
Cash Basis Income:
With No Related Allowance											—		—		—		—		—
With a Related Allowance											—		—		—		—		—

September 30, 2018
Average Recorded Balance:
With No Related Allowance	$	—	$	393	$	101	$	1,491	$	1,985	$	—	$	7	$	104	$	1,371	$	1,482
With a Related Allowance	480		763		—		340		1,583		478		794		—		350		1,622
Interest Income Recognized:
With No Related Allowance	—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—
With a Related Allowance	—		—		—		20		20		—		—		—		—		—
Cash Basis Income:
With No Related Allowance	—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—
With a Related Allowance	—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—

September 30, 2017
Average Recorded Balance:
With No Related Allowance	$	—	$	854	$	98	$	975	$	1,927
With a Related Allowance	245		363		—		144		752
Interest Income Recognized:
With No Related Allowance	—		—		3		—		3
With a Related Allowance	—		—		—		4		4
Cash Basis Income:
With No Related Allowance	—		—		—		—		—
With a Related Allowance	—		—		—		—		—

At September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, December 31, ~~2017~~2018 and September 30, ~~2017,~~2018, all impaired loans were considered to be collateral dependent and were therefore evaluated for impairment based on the fair value of collateral less estimated cost to sell. Interest income recognized in the table above represents income earned after the loans became impaired and includes restructured loans in compliance with their modified terms and nonaccrual loans where ~~we have recognized~~ interest income was recognized on a cash basis.

Loans Modified in Trouble Debt Restructurings

The following table presents information on loans modified in trouble debt restructurings during the periods indicated.

																					Loans Modified in Trouble Debt Restructurings During the Period
			Commercial										Commercial
	Commercial		Real Estate		Consumer		Residential		Total		Commercial		Real Estate		Consumer		Residential		Total
For the Quarter Ended:
September 30, 2019
Number of Loans											—		—		—		—		—
Pre-Modification Outstanding Recorded Investment											$	—	$	—	$	—	$	—	$	—
Post-Modification Outstanding Recorded Investment											—		—		—		—		—
Subsequent Default, Number of Contracts											—		—		—		—		—
Subsequent Default, Recorded Investment											—		—		—		—		—

September 30, 2018
Number of Loans	—		—		1		—		1		—		—		1		—		1
Pre-Modification Outstanding Recorded Investment	$	—	$	—	$	16	$	—	$	16	$	—	$	—	$	16	$	—	$	16
Post-Modification Outstanding Recorded Investment	—		—		16		—		16		—		—		16		—		16
Subsequent Default, Number of Contracts	—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—
Subsequent Default, Recorded Investment	—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—

September 30, 2017
For the Year-To-Date Period Ended:
September 30, 2019
Number of Loans	1		—		2		—		3		—		—		5		—		5
Pre-Modification Outstanding Recorded Investment	$	725	$	—	$	25	$	—	$	750	$	—	$	—	$	47	$	—	$	47
Post-Modification Outstanding Recorded Investment	725		—		25		—		750		—		—		47		—		47
Subsequent Default, Number of Contracts	—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—
Subsequent Default, Recorded Investment	—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—

For the Year-To-Date Period Ended:
September 30, 2018
Number of Loans	—		—		5		—		5		—		—		5		—		5
Pre-Modification Outstanding Recorded Investment	$	—	$	—	$	44	$	—	$	44	$	—	$	—	$	44	$	—	$	44
Post-Modification Outstanding Recorded Investment	—		—		44		—		44		—		—		44		—		44
Subsequent Default, Number of Contracts	—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—
Subsequent Default, Recorded Investment	—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—		—

September 30, 2017
Number of Loans	2		—		6		—		8
Pre-Modification Outstanding Recorded Investment	$	1,228	$	—	$	51	$	—	$	1,279
Post-Modification Outstanding Recorded Investment	1,228		—		51		—		1,279
Subsequent Default, Number of Contracts	—		—		—		—		—
Subsequent Default, Recorded Investment	—		—		—		—		—

In general, loans requiring modification are restructured to accommodate the projected cash-flows of the borrower. Such modifications may involve a reduction of the interest rate, a significant deferral of payments or forgiveness of a portion of the outstanding principal balance. As indicated in the table above, no loans modified during the preceding twelve months subsequently defaulted as of September 30, ~~2018.~~2019.

Note 4. ~~GUARANTEES~~COMMITMENTS AND CONTINGENCIES (In Thousands)

The following table presents the notional amount and fair value of Arrow's off-balance sheet commitments to extend credit and commitments under standby letters of credit as of September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, December 31, ~~2017~~2018 and September 30, ~~2017:~~2018:

													Commitments to Extend Credit and Letters of Credit
	September 30, 2018		December 31, 2017		September 30, 2017		September 30, 2019		December 31, 2018		September 30, 2018
Notional Amount:
Commitments to Extend Credit	$	335,587	$	315,256	$	316,449	$	340,976	$	321,143	$	335,587
Standby Letters of Credit	4,016		3,526		3,672		3,164		4,466		4,016
Fair Value:
Commitments to Extend Credit	$	—	$	—	$	—	$	—	$	—	$	—
Standby Letters of Credit	4		23		18		26		12		4

Arrow is party to financial instruments with off-balance sheet risk in the normal course of business to meet the financing needs of its customers. These financial instruments include commitments to extend credit and standby letters of credit. Commitments to extend credit include home equity lines of credit, commitments for residential and commercial construction loans and other personal and commercial lines of credit. ~~These~~Those instruments involve, to varying degrees, elements of credit and interest rate risk in excess of the amount recognized in the consolidated balance sheets. The contract or notional amounts of those instruments reflect the extent of the involvement Arrow has in particular classes of financial instruments.

Arrow's exposure to credit loss in the event of nonperformance by the other party to the financial instrument for commitments to extend credit and standby letters of credit is represented by the contractual notional amount of those instruments. Arrow uses the same credit policies in making commitments and conditional obligations as it does for on-balance sheet instruments.

Commitments to extend credit are agreements to lend to a customer as long as there is no violation of any condition established in the contract. Commitments generally have fixed expiration dates or other termination clauses and may require payment of a fee. Since many of the commitments are not expected to ~~expire without being~~be fully drawn upon, the total commitment amounts do not necessarily represent future cash requirements. Arrow evaluates each customer's creditworthiness on a case-by-case basis. Home equity lines of credit are secured by residential real estate. Construction ~~commitments~~lines of credit are secured by underlying real estate. For other lines of credit, the amount of collateral obtained, if deemed necessary by Arrow upon extension of credit, is based on management's credit evaluation of the counterparty. Collateral held varies, but may include accounts receivable, inventory, property, plant and equipment, and income-producing commercial properties. Most of the commitments are variable rate instruments.

Arrow does not issue any guarantees that would require liability-recognition or disclosure, other than its standby letters of credit.

Arrow has issued conditional commitments in the form of standby letters of credit to guarantee payment on behalf of a customer and guarantee the performance of a customer to a third party. Standby letters of credit generally arise in connection with commercial lending relationships. The credit risk involved in issuing these instruments is essentially the same as that involved in extending loans to customers. Contingent obligations under standby letters of credit at September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, December 31, ~~2017~~2018 and September 30, ~~2017~~2018 represent the maximum potential future payments Arrow could be required to make. Typically, these instruments have terms of 12 months or less and expire unused; therefore, the total amounts do not necessarily represent future cash requirements. Each customer is evaluated individually for creditworthiness under the same underwriting standards used for commitments to extend credit and on-balance sheet instruments. Company policies governing loan collateral apply to standby letters of credit at the time of credit extension. Loan-to-value ratios will generally range from 50% for movable assets, such as inventory, to 100% for liquid assets, such as bank CD's. Fees for standby letters of credit ~~typically~~ range from 1% to 3% of the notional amount. Fees are collected upfront and ~~are~~ amortized over the life of the commitment. The carrying amount and fair ~~values~~value of Arrow's standby letters of credit at September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, December 31, ~~2017~~2018 and September 30, ~~2017,~~2018, were insignificant. The fair value of standby letters of credit is based on the fees currently charged for similar agreements or the cost to terminate the arrangement with the counterparties.

The fair value of commitments to extend credit is determined by estimating the fees to enter into similar agreements, taking into account the remaining terms and present creditworthiness of the counterparties, and for fixed rate loan commitments, the difference between the current and committed interest rates. Arrow provides several types of commercial lines of credit and standby letters of credit to its commercial customers. The pricing of these services is not isolated as Arrow considers the customer's complete deposit and borrowing relationship in pricing individual products and services. The commitments to extend credit also include commitments under home equity lines of credit, for which Arrow charges no fee. The carrying value and fair value of commitments to extend credit are not material and Arrow does not expect to incur any material loss as a result of these commitments.

In the normal course of business, Arrow and its subsidiary banks become involved in a variety of routine legal proceedings. At present, there are no legal proceedings pending or threatened, which in the opinion of management and counsel, would result in a material loss to Arrow.

In the third quarter of 2019, Arrow entered into interest rate swap agreements with its commercial customers to provide them with a long-term fixed rate, while simultaneously Arrow entered into offsetting interest rate swap agreements with a counterparty to swap the fixed rate to a variable rate to manage interest rate exposure.

The Company's interest rate swap agreements are not designated as a hedge for accounting purposes. As the interest rate swap agreements have substantially equivalent and offsetting terms, they do not present any material exposure to the Company's consolidated statements of income. The Company records its interest rate swap agreements at fair value and is presented on a gross basis within other assets and other liabilities on the consolidated balance sheets. Changes in the fair value of assets and liabilities arising from these derivatives are included, net, in other income in the consolidated statement of income.

The following table depicts the fair value adjustment recorded related to the notional amount of derivatives outstanding as well as the notional amount of the interest rate swap agreements.



Derivatives Not Designated as Hedging Instruments - Interest Rate Swap Agreements
	September 30, 2019	December 31, 2018	September 30, 2018
Fair value adjustment included in other assets and other liabilities	498	—	—
Notional amount	39,577	—	—

Note 5. COMPREHENSIVE INCOME (In Thousands)

The following table presents the components of other comprehensive income for the three- and nine-month periods ended September 30, ~~2018~~2019 and ~~2017:~~2018:

																																					Schedule of Comprehensive Income
	Three Months Ended September 30,									Nine Months Ended September 30,									Three Months Ended September 30,									Nine Months Ended September 30,
				Tax									Tax									Tax									Tax
	Before-Tax			(Expense)			Net-of-Tax			Before-Tax			(Expense)			Net-of-Tax			Before-Tax			(Expense)			Net-of-Tax			Before-Tax			(Expense)			Net-of-Tax
	Amount			Benefit			Amount			Amount			Benefit			Amount			Amount			Benefit			Amount			Amount			Benefit			Amount
2019
Net Unrealized Securities Holding Gains on Securities Available-for-Sale Arising During the Period																			668			$	(169	)	499			5,796			$	(1,473	)	4,323
Amortization of Net Retirement Plan Actuarial Loss																			172			(45		)	127			514			(133		)	381
Amortization of Net Retirement Plan Prior Service Cost																			56			(14		)	42			169			(42		)	127
Other Comprehensive Income																			$	896		$	(228	)	$	668		$	6,479		$	(1,648	)	$	4,831

2018
Net Unrealized Securities Holding Losses on Securities Available-for-Sale Arising During the Period	(1,203		)	$	306		(897		)	(5,388		)	$	1,371		(4,017		)	(1,203		)	$	306		(897		)	(5,388		)	$	1,371		(4,017		)
Amortization of Net Retirement Plan Actuarial Loss	81			(21		)	60			244			(63		)	181			81			(21		)	60			244			(63		)	181
Accretion of Net Retirement Plan Prior Service Credit	27			(7		)	20			81			(21		)	60
Accretion of Net Retirement Plan Prior Service Cost																			27			(7		)	20			81			(21		)	60
Other Comprehensive Loss	$	(1,095	)	$	278		$	(817	)	$	(5,063	)	$	1,287		$	(3,776	)	$	(1,095	)	$	278		$	(817	)	$	(5,063	)	$	1,287		$	(3,776	)

2017
Net Unrealized Securities Holding Gains on Securities Available-for-Sale Arising During the Period	6			$	3		9			749			$	(284	)	465
Reclassification Adjustment for Securities Gains Included in Net Income	(10		)	4			(6		)	(10		)	4			(6		)
Amortization of Net Retirement Plan Actuarial Loss	179			(115		)	64			537			(292		)	245
Accretion of Net Retirement Plan Prior Service Credit	(3		)	1			(2		)	(8		)	3			(5		)
Other Comprehensive Income	$	172		$	(107	)	$	65		$	1,268		$	(569	)	$	699

The following table presents the changes in accumulated other comprehensive income by component:


Changes in Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income (Loss) by Component ⁽¹⁾	Changes in Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income (Loss) by Component ⁽¹⁾												Changes in Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income (Loss) by Component ⁽¹⁾

	Unrealized			Defined Benefit Plan Items									Unrealized			Defined Benefit Plan Items
	Gains and												Gains and
	Losses on						Net Prior						Losses on			Net			Net Prior
	Available-for-			Net Gain			Service						Available-for-			Actuarial			Service
	Sale Securities			(Loss)			(Cost ) Credit			Total			Sale Securities			Gain (Loss)			(Cost) Credit			Total
For the Quarter-To-Date periods ended:

June 30, 2019													$	127		$	(8,717	)	$	(1,057	)	$	(9,647	)
Other comprehensive income before reclassifications													499			—			—			499
Amounts reclassified from accumulated other comprehensive income																127			42			169
Net current-period other comprehensive income													499			127			42			668
September 30, 2019													$	626		$	(8,590	)	$	(1,015	)	$	(8,979	)

June 30, 2018	$	(4,701	)	$	(6,259	)	$	(844	)	$	(11,804	)	$	(4,701	)	$	(6,259	)	$	(844	)	$	(11,804	)
Other comprehensive income or loss before reclassifications	(897		)	—			—			(897		)
Amounts reclassified from accumulated other comprehensive income				60			20			80
Other comprehensive loss before reclassifications													(897		)	—			—			(897		)
Amounts reclassified from accumulated other comprehensive loss													—			60			20			80
Net current-period other comprehensive income (loss)	(897		)	60			20			(817		)	(897		)	60			20			(817		)
September 30, 2018	$	(5,598	)	$	(6,199	)	$	(824	)	$	(12,621	)	$	(5,598	)	$	(6,199	)	$	(824	)	$	(12,621	)

June 30, 2017	$	74		$	(5,556	)	$	(718	)	$	(6,200	)

For the Year-To-Date periods ended:

December 31, 2018													$	(3,697	)	$	(8,971	)	$	(1,142	)	$	(13,810	)
Other comprehensive income or loss before reclassifications	9			—			—			9			4,323			—			—			4,323
Amounts reclassified from accumulated other comprehensive income	(6		)	64			(2		)	56			—			381			127			508
Net current-period other comprehensive income (loss)	3			64			(2		)	65
September 30, 2017	$	77		$	(5,492	)	$	(720	)	$	(6,135	)


For the Year-To-Date periods ended:
Net current-period other comprehensive income													4,323			381			127			4,831
September 30, 2019													$	626		$	(8,590	)	$	(1,015	)	$	(8,979	)

December 31, 2017	$	(1,250	)	$	(6,380	)	$	(884	)	$	(8,514	)	$	(1,250	)	$	(6,380	)	$	(884	)	$	(8,514	)
Other comprehensive income or loss before reclassifications	(4,017		)	—			—			(4,017		)	(4,017		)	—			—			(4,017		)
Amounts reclassified from accumulated other comprehensive income	—			181			60			241			—			181			60			241
Net current-period other comprehensive income	(4,017		)	181			60			(3,776		)	(4,017		)	181			60			(3,776		)
Amounts reclassified from accumulated other comprehensive income	$	(331	)							$	(331	)	$	(331	)							$	(331	)
September 30, 2018	$	(5,598	)	$	(6,199	)	$	(824	)	$	(12,621	)	$	(5,598	)	$	(6,199	)	$	(824	)	$	(12,621	)

December 31, 2016	$	(382	)	$	(5,737	)	$	(715	)	$	(6,834	)
Other comprehensive income or loss before reclassifications	465			—			—			465
Amounts reclassified from accumulated other comprehensive income	(6		)	245			(5		)	234
Net current-period other comprehensive income	459			245			(5		)	699
September 30, 2017	$	77		$	(5,492	)	$	(720	)	$	(6,135	)

(1) All amounts are net of tax.

The following table presents the reclassifications out of accumulated other comprehensive income:

											Reclassifications Out of Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income
	Amounts Reclassified					Amounts Reclassified
Details about Accumulated Other	from Accumulated Other				Affected Line Item in the Statement	from Accumulated Other				Affected Line Item in the Statement
Comprehensive Income (Loss) Components	Comprehensive Income				Where Net Income Is Presented	Comprehensive Income				Where Net Income Is Presented

For the Quarter-to-date periods ended:

September 30, 2018
Unrealized gains and losses on available-for-sale securities	$	—			Gain on Securities Transactions
	—				Total before Tax
	—				Provision for Income Taxes
	$	—			Net of Tax

September 30, 2019
Amortization of defined benefit pension items:
Prior-service costs	$	(27	)	⁽¹⁾	Salaries and Employee Benefits	$	(56	)	⁽¹⁾	Salaries and Employee Benefits
Actuarial gains/(losses)	(81		)	⁽¹⁾	Salaries and Employee Benefits	(172		)	⁽¹⁾	Salaries and Employee Benefits
	(108		)		Total before Tax	(228		)		Total before Tax
	28				Provision for Income Taxes	59				Provision for Income Taxes
	$	(80	)		Net of Tax	$	(169	)		Net of Tax

Total reclassifications for the period	$	(80	)		Net of Tax	$	(169	)		Net of Tax

September 30, 2017
Unrealized gains and losses on available-for-sale securities	$	10			Gain on Securities Transactions
	10				Total before Tax
	(4		)		Provision for Income Taxes
	$	6			Net of Tax

September 30, 2018
Amortization of defined benefit pension items:
Prior-service costs	$	3		⁽¹⁾	Salaries and Employee Benefits	$	(27	)	⁽¹⁾	Salaries and Employee Benefits
Actuarial gains/(losses)	(179		)	⁽¹⁾	Salaries and Employee Benefits	(81		)	⁽¹⁾	Salaries and Employee Benefits
	(176		)		Total before Tax	(108		)		Total before Tax
	114				Provision for Income Taxes	28				Provision for Income Taxes
	$	(62	)		Net of Tax	$	(80	)		Net of Tax

Total reclassifications for the period	$	(56	)		Net of Tax	$	(80	)		Net of Tax

For the Year-to-date periods ended:

September 30, 2018
Unrealized gains and losses on available-for-sale securities	$	—			Gain on Securities Transactions
	—				Total before Tax
	—				Provision for Income Taxes
	$	—			Net of Tax

September 30, 2019
Amortization of defined benefit pension items:
Prior-service costs	$	(81	)	⁽¹⁾	Salaries and Employee Benefits	$	(169	)	⁽¹⁾	Salaries and Employee Benefits
Actuarial gains/(losses)	(244		)	⁽¹⁾	Salaries and Employee Benefits	(514		)	⁽¹⁾	Salaries and Employee Benefits
	(325		)		Total before Tax	(683		)		Total before Tax
	84				Provision for Income Taxes	175				Provision for Income Taxes
	$	(241	)		Net of Tax	$	(508	)		Net of Tax

Total reclassifications for the period	$	(241	)		Net of Tax	$	(508	)		Net of Tax

September 30, 2018
Amortization of defined benefit pension items:
Prior-service costs						(81		)	⁽¹⁾	Salaries and Employee Benefits
Actuarial gains/(losses)						$	(244	)	⁽¹⁾	Salaries and Employee Benefits
						(325		)		Total before Tax

Reclassifications Out of Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income

Amounts Reclassified
Details about Accumulated Other from Accumulated Other Affected Line Item in the Statement
Comprehensive Income (Loss) Components Comprehensive Income Where Net Income Is Presented

September 30, 2017
Unrealized gains and losses on available-for-sale securities $ 10
Gain on Securities Transactions
10
Total before Tax
(4 ) Provision for Income Taxes
$ 6
Net of Tax

Amortization of defined benefit pension items:
Prior-service costs 8
⁽¹⁾
Salaries and Employee Benefits
Actuarial gains/(losses) $ (537 )
⁽¹⁾
Salaries and Employee Benefits
(529 ) Total before Tax
289
Provision for Income Taxes
$ (240 ) Net of Tax

Total reclassifications for the period $ (234 ) Net of Tax



Reclassifications Out of Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income

	Amounts Reclassified
Details about Accumulated Other	from Accumulated Other			Affected Line Item in the Statement
Comprehensive Income (Loss) Components	Comprehensive Income			Where Net Income Is Presented

	84			Provision for Income Taxes
	$	(241	)	Net of Tax

Total reclassifications for the period	$	(241	)	Net of Tax

(1) These accumulated other comprehensive income components are included in the computation of net periodic pension cost.

Note 6. STOCK-BASED COMPENSATION (Dollars In Thousands, Except Share and Per Share Amounts)

Arrow has established three stock-based compensation plans: ~~an Incentive and Non-qualified Stock Option Plan (Long~~a Long Term Incentive ~~Plan)~~Plan,, an Employee Stock Purchase Plan (ESPP) and an Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP). All share and per share data have been adjusted for the September 27, ~~2018~~ 3%2019 3% stock dividend.

Long Term Incentive Plan

The Long Term Incentive Plan provides for the grant of incentive stock options, non-qualified stock options, restricted stock, restricted stock units, performance units and performance shares. The Compensation Committee of the Board of Directors administers the Long Term Incentive Plan.

Stock Options - Options may be granted at a price no less than the greater of the par value or fair market value of such shares on the date on which such option is granted, and generally expire ten years from the date of grant. The options usually vest over a four-year period.

The following table summarizes information about stock option activity for the year to date period ended September 30, 2019.



	Shares			Weighted Average Exercise Price

Outstanding at January 1, 2019	293,058			$	24.92
Granted	53,560			30.79
Exercised	(79,069		)	20.72
Forfeited	(12,078		)	24.39
Outstanding at September 30, 2019	255,471			27.40
Vested at Period-End	135,002			24.43
Expected to Vest	120,469			30.72

Stock Options Granted
Weighted Average Grant Date Information:
Fair Value of Options Granted	$	5.58
Fair Value Assumptions:
Dividend Yield	3.26		%
Expected Volatility	22.58		%
Risk Free Interest Rate	2.63		%
Expected Lives (in years)	8.68

The following table presents information on the ~~roll forward of~~amounts expensed related to stock options ~~issued pursuant to~~for the ~~Long Term Incentive Plan by Shares~~periods ended September 30, 2019 and ~~Weighted Average Exercise Prices.~~2018:

Roll-Forward of Shares Outstanding:
Outstanding at January 1, 2018 356,540
Granted 56,843
Exercised (94,742 )
Forfeited (14,953 )
Outstanding at September 30, 2018 303,688
Exercisable at Period-End 185,547
Vested and Expected to Vest 118,141

Roll-Forward of Shares Outstanding - Weighted Average Exercise Price:
Outstanding at January 1, 2018 $ 23.42
Granted 29.95
Exercised 20.85
Forfeited 26.61
Outstanding at September 30, 2018 25.24
Exercisable at Period-End 22.47
Vested and Expected to Vest 29.59

Schedule of Other Long Term Incentive Plan Information
Grants Issued During 2018 - Weighted Average Information:
Fair Value $ 5.59
Fair Value Assumptions:
Dividend Yield 2.98 %
Expected Volatility 21.55 %
Risk Free Interest Rate 2.68 %
Expected Lives (in years) 6.98



	For the Three Months Ended September 30,				For the Nine Months Ended September 30,
	2019		2018		2019		2018
Amount expensed	$	79	$	80	$	237	$	243

Restricted Stock Units - The Company grants restricted stock units which gives the recipient the right to receive shares of Company stock upon vesting. The fair value of each restricted stock unit is the market value of Company stock on the date of grant. 100% of the restricted stock unit awards vest three years from the grant date. Once vested, the restricted stock units become vested ~~units.~~units and are no longer forfeitable. Vested units settle upon retirement of the recipient. Unvested restricted stock unit awards will generally be forfeited if the recipient ceases to be employed by the Company, with limited exceptions.

The following table ~~presents the roll forward of~~summarizes information about restricted stock ~~units by units and weighted average grant-date fair value.~~unit activity for the period ended September 30, 2019.




~~Roll-Forward of Restricted Stock Units~~
~~Non-vested at January 1, 2018~~	—
~~Granted~~	~~3,377~~
~~Vested~~	—
~~Canceled~~	—
~~Non-vested at September 30, 2018~~	~~3,377~~

~~Roll-Forward of Non-vested Restricted Stock Units - Weighted Average Fair Value:~~
~~Non-vested at January 1, 2018~~	$	—
~~Granted~~	~~32.57~~
~~Vested~~	—
~~Canceled~~	—
~~Non-vested at September 30, 2018~~	~~32.57~~




	Restricted Stock Units	Weighted Average Grant Date Fair Value
Non-vested at January 1, 2019	3,478	$	31.62
Granted	4,018	30.79
Non-vested at September 30, 2019	7,496	31.17

The following table presents information on the amounts expensed related to restricted stock units for the periods ended September 30, ~~2018~~2019 and ~~2017:~~2018:

Share-Based Compensation Expense
For the Three Months Ended September 30, For the Nine Months Ended September 30,
2018 2017 2018 2017
Share-Based Compensation Expense $ 89
$ 90
$ 267
$ 262



	For the Three Months Ended September 30,				For the Nine Months Ended September 30,
	2019		2018		2019		2018
Amount expensed	$	19	$	9	$	55	$	24

Employee Stock Purchase Plan

Arrow sponsors an ESPP under which employees may purchase Arrow's common stock at a 5% discount below market price. Under current accounting guidance, a stock purchase plan with a discount of 5% or less is not considered a compensatory plan.

Employee Stock Ownership Plan

Arrow maintains an ~~ESOP. Substantially~~ESOP, pursuant to which substantially all employees of Arrow and its subsidiaries are eligible to participate upon satisfaction of applicable service requirements. The ESOP borrowed funds from one of Arrow’s subsidiary banks to purchase outstanding shares of Arrow’s common stock. The notes require annual payments of principal and interest through ~~2018.~~2019. As the debt is repaid, shares are released from collateral based on the proportion of debt paid to total debt outstanding for the year and allocated to active employees. In addition, the Company makes additional cash contributions to the Plan each year.

Shares pledged as collateral are reported as unallocated ESOP shares in stockholders' equity. As shares are released from collateral, Arrow reports compensation expense equal to the current average market price of the shares, and the shares become outstanding for earnings per share computations.

Note 7. RETIREMENT BENEFIT PLANS (Dollars in Thousands)

Arrow sponsors qualified and ~~nonqualified~~non-qualified defined benefit pension plans and other postretirement benefit plans for its employees. Arrow maintains a non-contributory pension plan, which covers substantially all employees. Effective December 1, 2002, all active participants in the qualified defined benefit pension plan were given a one-time irrevocable election to continue participating in the traditional plan design, for which benefits were based on years of service and the participant’s final compensation (as defined), or to begin participating in the new cash balance plan design. All employees who participate in the plan after December 1, 2002 automatically participate in the cash balance plan design. The interest credits under the cash balance plan are based on the 30-year U.S. Treasury rate in effect for November of the prior year. The service credits under the cash balance plan are equal to 6.0% of eligible salaries for employees who become participants on or after January 1, 2003. For employees in the plan prior to January 1, 2003, the service credits are scaled based on the age of the participant, and range from 6.0% to 12.0%. The funding policy is to contribute up to the maximum amount that can be deducted for federal income tax purposes and to make all payments required under ERISA. Arrow also maintains a supplemental non-qualified unfunded retirement plan to provide eligible employees of Arrow and its subsidiaries with benefits in excess of qualified plan limits imposed by federal tax law.

Arrow has multiple non-pension postretirement benefit plans. The health care, dental and life insurance plans are contributory, with participants’ contributions adjusted annually. Arrow’s policy is to fund the cost of postretirement benefits based on the current cost of the underlying policies. However, the health care plan provision for automatic increases of Company contributions each year is based on the increase in inflation and is limited to a maximum of 5%.

As of December 31, ~~2017,~~2018, Arrow ~~utilized the~~updated its mortality assumption ~~from~~to the RP-2014 Mortality Table for annuitants and non-annuitants ~~but updated the~~with projected generational mortality improvements by using Scale ~~MP-2017. Revision of this assumption effective December 31, 2016~~MP-2018 for the pension plans and the RPH-2014 Mortality Table for annuitants and non-annuitants with projected generational mortality improvements using Scale MP-2018 for the retiree health plan. The revised assumptions resulted in a decrease in ~~the Company's pension and~~ postretirement liabilities. As of December 31, 2018, Arrow also updated its mortality assumption for annuity/lump sum conversions for the pension plans to the 2019 IRC Section 417(e)(3)B) applicable mortality table. The revised assumption results in an increase in postretirement liabilities for the pension plans.

The interest rates used in determining the present value of a lump sum payment/annuitizing cash balance accounts were changed to the segment rates in effect for the January 1, 2019 plan year (3.43%, 4.46%, 4.88%) as of December 31, 2018. This change was made to more accurately reflect current expected long-term interest rates and resulted in an increase in liability for the Arrow Financial Corporation Employees' Pension Plan and Trust and the Arrow Financial Corporation Select Executive Retirement Plan.

The following tables provide the components of net periodic benefit costs for the three- and nine-month periods ended September 30, ~~2018~~2019 and ~~2017.~~2018.


				Select								Select
	Employees'			Executive		Postretirement			Employees'			Executive		Postretirement
	Pension			Retirement		Benefit			Pension			Retirement		Benefit
	Plan			Plan		Plans			Plan			Plan		Plans
Net Periodic Benefit Cost
For the Three Months Ended September 30, 2019:
Service Cost ¹									$	382		$	81	$	30
Interest Cost ²									513			54		91
Expected Return on Plan Assets ²									(765		)	—		—
Amortization of Prior Service Cost ²									17			14		25
Amortization of Net Loss ²									153			29		(10		)
Net Periodic Cost									$	300		$	178	$	136

Plan Contributions During the Period									$	—		$	117	$	51

For the Three Months Ended September 30, 2018:
Service Cost ¹	$	389		$	104	$	34		$	389		$	104	$	34
Interest Cost ²	400			48		81			400			48		81
Expected Return on Plan Assets ²	(841		)	—		—			(841		)	—		—
Amortization of Prior Service (Credit) Cost ²	(12		)	14		25			(12		)	14		25
Amortization of Net Loss ²	48			33		—			48			33		—
Net Periodic (Benefit) Cost	$	(16	)	$	199	$	140		$	(16	)	$	199	$	140

Plan Contributions During the Period	$	—		$	116	$	56		$	—		$	116	$	56

For the Three Months Ended September 30, 2017:
Service Cost ¹	$	350		$	10	$	37
Interest Cost ²	362			55		75
Expected Return on Plan Assets ²	(800		)	—		—
Amortization of Prior Service (Credit) Cost ²	(14		)	14		(3		)
Amortization of Net Loss ²	148			31		—
Net Periodic (Benefit) Cost	$	46		$	110	$	109

Plan Contributions During the Period	$	—		$	116	$	65

Net Periodic Benefit Cost
For the Nine Months Ended September 30, 2018:
Service Cost ¹	$	1,168		$	311	$	102
Interest Cost ²	1,199			152		248
Expected Return on Plan Assets ²	(2,522		)	—		—
Amortization of Prior Service (Credit) Cost ²	(37		)	43		75
Amortization of Net Loss ²	145			99		—
Net Periodic (Benefit) Cost	$	(47	)	$	605	$	425

Plan Contributions During the Period	$	—		$	349	$	175

Estimated Future Contributions in the Current Fiscal Year	$	—		$	—	$	—


For the Nine Months Ended September 30, 2017:
Net Periodic Benefit Cost
For the Nine Months Ended September 30, 2019:
Service Cost ¹	$	1,050		$	30	$	110		$	1,146		$	243	$	91
Interest Cost ²	1,085			164		224			1,253			162		273
Expected Return on Plan Assets ²	(2,399		)	—		—			(2,296		)	—		—
Amortization of Prior Service (Credit) Cost ²	(43		)	43		(8		)	52			41		76
Amortization of Net Loss ²	443			94		—			460			86		(32		)
Net Periodic (Benefit) Cost	$	136		$	331	$	326		$	615		$	532	$	408

Plan Contributions During the Period	$	—		$	345	$	295		$	—		$	350	$	142

Estimated Future Contributions in the Current Fiscal Year									$	—		$	—	$	—

For the Nine Months Ended September 30, 2018:
Service Cost ¹									$	1,168		$	311	$	102
Interest Cost ²									1,199			152		248
Expected Return on Plan Assets ²									(2,522		)	—		—
Amortization of Prior Service (Credit) Cost ²									(37		)	43		75
Amortization of Net Loss ²									145			99		—
Net Periodic (Benefit) Cost									$	(47	)	$	605	$	425

Plan Contributions During the Period									$	—		$	349	$	175

Footnotes:

1. Included in Salaries and Employee Benefits on the Consolidated Statements of Income

2. Included in Other Operating Expense on the Consolidated Statements of Income

~~We are not required to make a~~A contribution to the qualified pension plan in ~~2018,~~2019 was not required, and currently, ~~we do not expect to make~~ additional contributions in ~~2018.~~2019 are not expected. Arrow makes contributions to its other post-retirement benefit plans in an amount equal to benefit payments for the year.

Note 8. EARNINGS PER COMMON SHARE (In Thousands, Except Per Share Amounts)

The following table presents a reconciliation of the numerator and denominator used in the calculation of basic and diluted earnings per common share (“EPS”) for periods ended September 30, ~~2018~~2019 and ~~2017.~~2018. All share and per share amounts have been adjusted for the September 27, ~~2018~~2019, 3% stock dividend.

																	Earnings Per Share
	Quarterly Period Ended:				Year-to-Date Period Ended:				Quarterly Period Ended:				Year-to-Date Period Ended:
	September 30, 2018		September 30, 2017		September 30, 2018		September 30, 2017		September 30, 2019		September 30, 2018		September 30, 2019		September 30, 2018
Earnings Per Share - Basic:
Net Income	$	9,260	$	7,416	$	27,521	$	21,255	$	10,067	$	9,260	$	27,735	$	27,521
Weighted Average Shares - Basic	14,431		14,305		14,393		14,306		14,955		14,864		14,927		14,825
Earnings Per Share - Basic	$	0.64	$	0.52	$	1.91	$	1.49	$	0.67	$	0.62	$	1.86	$	1.85

Earnings Per Share - Diluted:
Net Income	$	9,260	$	7,416	$	27,521	$	21,255	$	10,067	$	9,260	$	27,735	$	27,521
Weighted Average Shares - Basic	14,431		14,305		14,393		14,306		14,955		14,864		14,927		14,825
Dilutive Average Shares Attributable to Stock Options	89		80		86		95		36		92		41		89
Weighted Average Shares - Diluted	14,520		14,385		14,479		14,401		14,991		14,956		14,968		14,914
Earnings Per Share - Diluted	$	0.64	$	0.52	$	1.90	$	1.48	$	0.67	$	0.62	$	1.85	$	1.84

Note 9. FAIR ~~VALUE OF FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS (In~~VALUES (Dollars In Thousands)

FASB ASC Subtopic 820-10 defines fair value, establishes a framework for measuring fair value in GAAP and requires certain disclosures about fair value measurements. ~~We do not have any~~There are no nonfinancial assets or liabilities measured at fair value on a recurring basis. The only assets or liabilities that Arrow measured at fair value on a recurring basis at September 30, 2019, December 31, 2018 and September 30, 2018 were securities available-for-sale, ~~and~~ equity securities and ~~for December 31, 2017 and September 30, 2017 securities available-for-sale.~~derivatives. Arrow held no securities or liabilities for trading on such dates.

The table below presents the financial instrument's fair value and the amounts within the fair value hierarchy based on the lowest level of input that is significant to the fair value measurement:

																				Fair Value of Assets and Liabilities Measured on a Recurring and Nonrecurring Basis
			Fair Value Measurements at Reporting Date Using:											Fair Value Measurements at Reporting Date Using:
	Fair Value		Quoted Prices In Active Markets for Identical Assets (Level 1)		Significant Other Observable Inputs (Level 2)		Significant Unobservable Inputs (Level 3)		Life-to-Date Gains (Losses)			Fair Value		Quoted Prices In Active Markets for Identical Assets (Level 1)		Significant Other Observable Inputs (Level 2)		Significant Unobservable Inputs (Level 3)
Fair Value of Assets and Liabilities Measured on a Recurring Basis:
September 30, 2018
September 30, 2019
Assets:
Securities Available-for Sale:
U.S. Government & Agency Obligations	$	59,602	$	—	$	59,602	$	—				$	5,056	$	—	$	5,056	$	—
State and Municipal Obligations	2,548		—		2,548		—					965		—		965		—
Mortgage-Backed Securities	277,461		—		277,461		—					307,361		—		307,361		—
Corporate and Other Debt Securities	800		—		800		—					800		—		800		—
Total Securities Available-for-Sale	340,411		—		340,411		—					314,182		—		314,182		—
Equity Securities	1,916		—		1,916		—					1,996		—		1,996		—
Total Securities Measured on a Recurring Basis	$	342,327	$	—	$	342,327	$	—				$	316,178	$	—	$	316,178	$	—
December 31, 2017
Derivatives, included in other assets												498		—		498		—
Total Measured on a Recurring Basis												$	316,676	$	—	$	316,676	$	—
Liabilities:
Derivatives, included in other liabilities												498		—		498		—
Total Measured on a Recurring Basis												$	498	$	—	$	498	$	—
December 31, 2018
Assets:
Securities Available-for Sale:
U.S. Government & Agency Obligations	$	59,894	$	—	$	59,894	$	—				$	46,765	$	—	$	46,765	$	—
State and Municipal Obligations	10,349		—		10,349		—					1,195		—		1,195		—
Mortgage-Backed Securities	227,596		—		227,596		—					268,775		—		268,775		—
Corporate and Other Debt Securities	800		—		800		—					800		—		800		—
Total Securities Available-for-Sale												317,535				317,535
Equity Securities	1,561		—		1,561		—					1,774		—		1,774		—
Total Securities Available-for Sale	$	300,200	$	—	$	300,200	$	—
September 30, 2017
Securities Available-for Sale:
U.S. Government & Agency Obligations	$	146,978	$	64,730	$	82,248	$	—
State and Municipal Obligations	11,902		—		11,902		—
Mortgage-Backed Securities	152,806		—		152,806		—
Corporate and Other Debt Securities	2,299		—		2,299		—
Equity Securities	1,474		—		1,474		—
Total Securities Available-for Sale	$	315,459	$	64,730	$	250,729	$	—

Fair Value of Assets and Liabilities Measured on a Nonrecurring Basis:
September 30, 2018
Collateral Dependent Impaired Loans	$	857	$	—	$	—	$	857	$	(58	)
Other Real Estate Owned and Repossessed Assets, Net	1,220		—		—		1,220		(559		)
December 31, 2017
Collateral Dependent Impaired Loans	$	—	$	—	$	—	$	—	$	—
Other Real Estate Owned and Repossessed Assets, Net	$	1,847	$	—	—		1,847		$	(569	)
September 30, 2017
Collateral Dependent Impaired Loans	$	1,502	$	—	$	—	$	1,502	$	(138	)
Other Real Estate Owned and Repossessed Assets, Net	1,713		—		—		1,713		(655		)
Total Securities Measured on a Recurring Basis												$	319,309	$	—	$	319,309	$	—



Fair Value of Assets and Liabilities Measured on a Recurring and Nonrecurring Basis
			Fair Value Measurements at Reporting Date Using:
	Fair Value		Quoted Prices In Active Markets for Identical Assets (Level 1)		Significant Other Observable Inputs (Level 2)		Significant Unobservable Inputs (Level 3)
September 30, 2018
Assets:
Securities Available-for Sale:
U.S. Government & Agency Obligations	$	59,602	$	—	$	59,602	$	—
State and Municipal Obligations	2,548		—		2,548		—
Mortgage-Backed Securities	277,461		—		277,461		—
Corporate and Other Debt Securities	800		—		800		—
Total Securities Available-for-Sale	340,411				340,411
Equity Securities	1,916		—		1,916		—
Total Securities Measured on a Recurring Basis	$	342,327	$	—	$	342,327	$	—

~~We determine the~~



	Fair Value		Quoted Prices In Active Markets for Identical Assets (Level 1)		Significant Other Observable Inputs (Level 2)		Significant Unobservable Inputs (Level 3)		Gains (Losses) Recognized in Earnings
Fair Value of Assets and Liabilities Measured on a Nonrecurring Basis:
September 30, 2019
Collateral Dependent Impaired Loans	$	324	$	—	$	—	$	324
Other Real Estate Owned and Repossessed Assets, Net	1,274		—		—		1,274		(111	)
December 31, 2018
Collateral Dependent Impaired Loans	$	—	$	—	$	—	$	—
Other Real Estate Owned and Repossessed Assets, Net	1,260		—		—		1,260		(132	)
September 30, 2018
Collateral Dependent Impaired Loans	$	857	$	—	$	—	$	857
Other Real Estate Owned and Repossessed Assets, Net	1,220		—		—		1,220		(43	)

The fair value of financial instruments is determined under the following hierarchy:

Level 1 - Unadjusted quoted prices in active markets that are accessible at the measurement date for identical, unrestricted assets or liabilities;

Level 2 - Quoted prices for similar assets or liabilities in active markets, quoted prices for identical or similar assets or liabilities in markets that are not active, or inputs that are observable, either directly or indirectly, for substantially the full term of the asset or liability;

Level 3 - Prices or valuation techniques that require inputs that are both significant to the fair value measurement and unobservable (i.e., supported by little or no market activity).

The Company determined that the previously reported U.S. Government & Agency Obligations of $59,894 were incorrectly classified as Level 1 securities, instead of the correct classification as Level 2 securities. The Company corrected the fair value leveling disclosure the year ended December 31, 2017 to reflect the correction of this classification. This error had no impact on the fair value of U.S. Government & Agency Obligations or the total securities available-for-sale.

There were no transfers between Levels 1, 2 and 3 for the three months ended September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, December 31, ~~2017~~2018 and September 30, ~~2017.~~2018.

Fair Value Methodology for Assets and Liabilities Measured on a Recurring Basis

The fair value of Level 1 securities available-for-sale are based on unadjusted, quoted market prices from exchanges in active markets. The fair value of Level 2 securities available-for-sale are based on an independent bond and equity pricing service for identical assets or significantly similar securities and an independent equity pricing service for equity securities not actively traded. The pricing services use a variety of techniques to arrive at fair value including market maker bids, quotes and pricing models. Inputs to the pricing models include recent trades, benchmark interest rates, spreads and actual and projected cash flows. The fair value of Level 2 derivatives is determined using inputs that are observable in the market place obtained from third parties including yield curves, publicly available volatilities, and floating indexes.

Fair Value Methodology for Assets and Liabilities Measured on a Nonrecurring Basis

The fair value of collateral dependent impaired loans and other real estate owned was based on third-party appraisals less estimated cost to sell. The appraisals may be adjusted by management for qualitative factors such as economic conditions and estimated liquidation expenses. Other assets which might have been included in this table include mortgage servicing rights, goodwill and other intangible assets. Arrow evaluates each of these assets for impairment on an annual basis, with no impairment recognized for these assets at September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, December 31, ~~2017~~2018 and September 30, ~~2017.~~2018.

Fair Value Methodology for Financial Instruments Not Measured on a Recurring or Nonrecurring Basis

The fair value for securities held-to-maturity is determined utilizing an independent bond pricing service for identical assets or significantly similar securities. The pricing service uses a variety of techniques to arrive at fair value including market maker bids, quotes and pricing models. Inputs to the pricing models include recent trades, benchmark interest rates, spreads and actual and projected cash flows.

ASU 2016-01 "Recognition and Measurement of Financial Assets and Financial Liabilities" requires that ~~effective for the first quarter of 2018,~~ the fair value for loans must be disclosed using the "exit price" notion which is a reasonable estimate of what another party might pay in an orderly transaction. Fair values for loans are calculated for portfolios of loans with similar financial characteristics. Loans are segregated by type such as commercial, commercial real estate, residential mortgage, indirect auto and other consumer loans. Each loan category is further segmented into fixed and adjustable interest rate terms and by performing and nonperforming categories. The fair value of performing loans is calculated by determining the estimated future cash flow, which is the contractual cash flow adjusted for estimated prepayments. The discount rate is determined by starting with current market yields, and first adjusting for a liquidity premium. This premium is separately determined for residential real estate loans vs. other loans. Then a credit loss component is determined utilizing the credit loss assumptions used in the allowance for loan and lease loss model. Finally, a discount spread is applied separately for consumer loans vs. commercial loans based on market information and utilization of the Swap Curve. Fair value for nonperforming loans is generally based on recent external appraisals. If appraisals are not available, estimated cash flows are discounted using a rate commensurate with the risk associated with the estimated cash flows. Assumptions regarding credit risk, cash flows and discount rates are judgmentally determined using available market information and specific borrower information.

The fair value of time deposits is based on the discounted value of contractual cash flows, except that the fair value is limited to the extent that the customer could redeem the certificate after imposition of a premature withdrawal penalty. The discount rates are estimated using the Federal Home Loan Bank of New York ("FHLBNY") yield curve, which is considered representative of Arrow’s time deposit rates. The fair value of all other deposits is equal to the carrying value.

The fair value of FHLBNY advances is estimated based on the discounted value of contractual cash flows. The discount rate is estimated using current rates on FHLBNY advances with similar maturities and call features.

The book value of the outstanding trust preferred securities (Junior Subordinated Obligations Issued to Unconsolidated Subsidiary Trusts) are considered to approximate fair value since the interest rates are variable (indexed to LIBOR) and Arrow is well-capitalized.

Fair Value by Balance Sheet Grouping

The following table presents a summary of the carrying amount, the fair value or an amount approximating fair value and the fair value hierarchy of Arrow’s financial instruments:

Schedule of Fair Values by Balance Sheet Grouping
Fair Value Hierarchy
Book Value Fair Value Level 1 Level 2 Level 3
September 30, 2018
Cash and Cash Equivalents $ 92,295
$ 92,295
$ 92,295
$ —
$ —
Securities Available-for-Sale 340,411
340,411
—
340,411
—
Securities Held-to-Maturity 289,952
282,719
—
282,719
—
Equity Securities 1,916
1,916
—
1,916
—
Federal Home Loan Bank and Federal
  Reserve Bank Stock
10,866
10,866
—
10,866
—
Net Loans 2,106,097
2,030,278
—
—
2,030,278
Accrued Interest Receivable 8,028
8,028
—
8,028
—
Deposits 2,407,855
2,398,987
—
2,398,987
—
Federal Funds Purchased and Securities
  Sold Under Agreements to Repurchase
62,503
62,503
—
62,503
—
Federal Home Loan Bank Overnight Advances 131,000
131,000
—
131,000
—
Federal Home Loan Bank Term Advances 45,000
44,488
—
44,488
—
Junior Subordinated Obligations Issued
  to Unconsolidated Subsidiary Trusts
20,000
20,000
—
20,000
—
Accrued Interest Payable 485
485
—
485
—

December 31, 2017
Cash and Cash Equivalents $ 72,838
$ 72,838
$ 72,838
$ —
$ —
Securities Available-for-Sale 300,200
300,200
—
300,200
—
Securities Held-to-Maturity 335,907
335,901
—
335,901
—
Federal Home Loan Bank and Federal
  Reserve Bank Stock
9,949
9,949
—
9,949
—
Net Loans 1,932,184
1,901,046
—
—
1,901,046
Accrued Interest Receivable 6,753
6,753
—
6,753
—
Deposits 2,245,116
2,236,548
—
2,236,548
—
Federal Funds Purchased and Securities
  Sold Under Agreements to Repurchase
64,966
64,966
—
64,966
—
Federal Home Loan Bank Overnight Advances 105,000
105,000
—
105,000
—
Federal Home Loan Bank Term Advances 55,000
54,781
—
54,781
—
Junior Subordinated Obligations Issued
  to Unconsolidated Subsidiary Trusts
20,000
20,000
—
20,000
—
Accrued Interest Payable 410
410
—
410
—

September 30, 2017
Cash and Cash Equivalents $ 80,666
$ 80,666
$ 80,666
$ —
$ —
Securities Available-for-Sale 315,459
315,459
64,730
250,729
—
Securities Held-to-Maturity 341,526
343,899
—
343,899
—
Federal Home Loan Bank and Federal
  Reserve Bank Stock
6,704
6,704
—
6,704
—
Net Loans 1,891,104
1,870,379
—
—
1,870,379
Accrued Interest Receivable 6,563
7,692
—
7,692
—
Deposits 2,307,116
2,299,011
—
2,299,011
—
Federal Funds Purchased and Securities
  Sold Under Agreements to Repurchase
61,419
61,419
—
61,419
—
Federal Home Loan Bank Overnight Advances 33,000
33,000
—
33,000
—
Federal Home Loan Bank Term Advances 55,000
55,110
—
55,110
—
Junior Subordinated Obligations Issued
  to Unconsolidated Subsidiary Trusts
20,000
20,000
—
20,000
—
Accrued Interest Payable 260
260
—
260
—



Schedule of Fair Values by Balance Sheet Grouping
					Fair Value Hierarchy
	Carrying Value		Fair Value		Level 1		Level 2		Level 3
September 30, 2019
Cash and Cash Equivalents	$	92,298	$	92,298	$	92,298	$	—	$	—
Securities Available-for-Sale	314,182		314,182		—		314,182		—
Securities Held-to-Maturity	255,095		259,128		—		259,128		—
Equity Securities	1,996		1,996		—		1,996		—
Federal Home Loan Bank and Federal Reserve Bank Stock	6,627		6,627		—		6,627		—
Net Loans	2,314,660		2,274,701		—		—		2,274,701



Schedule of Fair Values by Balance Sheet Grouping
					Fair Value Hierarchy
	Carrying Value		Fair Value		Level 1		Level 2		Level 3
Accrued Interest Receivable	8,097		8,097		—		8,097		—
Derivatives, included in Other Assets	498		498				498
Deposits	2,614,547		2,610,404		—		2,610,404		—
Federal Funds Purchased and Securities Sold Under Agreements to Repurchase	72,869		72,869		—		72,869		—
Federal Home Loan Bank Overnight Advances	48,000		48,000		—		48,000		—
Federal Home Loan Bank Term Advances	30,000		29,988		—		29,988		—
Junior Subordinated Obligations Issued to Unconsolidated Subsidiary Trusts	20,000		20,000		—		20,000		—
Accrued Interest Payable	1,500		1,500		—		1,500		—
Derivatives, included in Other Liabilities	498		498		—		498		—

December 31, 2018
Cash and Cash Equivalents	$	84,239	$	84,239	$	84,239	$	—	$	—
Securities Available-for-Sale	317,535		317,535		—		317,535		—
Securities Held-to-Maturity	283,476		280,338		—		280,338		—
Equity Securities	1,774		1,774				1,774
Federal Home Loan Bank and Federal Reserve Bank Stock	15,506		15,506		—		15,506		—
Net Loans	2,176,019		2,114,372		—		—		2,114,372
Accrued Interest Receivable	7,035		7,035		—		7,035		—
Deposits	2,345,584		2,338,410		—		2,338,410		—
Federal Funds Purchased and Securities Sold Under Agreements to Repurchase	54,659		54,659		—		54,659		—
Federal Home Loan Bank Overnight Advances	234,000		234,000		—		234,000		—
Federal Home Loan Bank Term Advances	45,000		44,652		—		44,652		—
Junior Subordinated Obligations Issued to Unconsolidated Subsidiary Trusts	20,000		20,000		—		20,000		—
Accrued Interest Payable	570		570		—		570		—

September 30, 2018
Cash and Cash Equivalents	$	92,295	$	92,295	$	92,295	$	—	$	—
Securities Available-for-Sale	340,411		340,411		—		340,411		—
Securities Held-to-Maturity	289,952		282,719		—		282,719		—
Equity Securities	1,916		1,916		—		1,916
Federal Home Loan Bank and Federal Reserve Bank Stock	10,866		10,866		—		10,866		—
Net Loans	2,106,097		2,030,278		—		—		2,030,278
Accrued Interest Receivable	8,028		8,028		—		8,028		—
Deposits	2,407,855		2,398,987		—		2,398,987		—
Federal Funds Purchased and Securities Sold Under Agreements to Repurchase	62,503		62,503		—		62,503		—
Federal Home Loan Bank Overnight Advances	131,000		131,000		—		131,000		—
Federal Home Loan Bank Term Advances	45,000		44,488		—		44,488		—
Junior Subordinated Obligations Issued to Unconsolidated Subsidiary Trusts	20,000		20,000		—		20,000		—
Accrued Interest Payable	485		485		—		485		—

Note 10. LEASES (Dollars In Thousands)

The Company is a lessee in its leases, which are mainly for financial services locations in addition to leases for corporate vehicles. These leases generally require the Company to pay third-party expenses on behalf of the Lessor, which are referred to as variable payments. Under some leases, the Company pays the variable payments to the lessor, and in other leases, the Company pays the variable payments directly to the applicable third party. None of the Company's current leases include any residual value guarantees or any subleases, and there are no significant rights and obligations of the Company for leases that have not commenced as of the reporting date.

Arrow leases five of its branch offices, at market rates, from Stewart’s Shops Corp. Mr. Gary C. Dake, President of Stewart’s Shops Corp., serves as a director on the board of directors of each of Arrow and Saratoga National Bank and Trust Company.

The following includes quantitative data related to the Company's leases as of and for the nine months ended September 30, 2019:



Finance Lease Amounts:	Classification
Right-of-use Assets	Premises and Equipment, Net	$	5,199
Lease Liabilities	Finance Leases	5,263

Operating Lease Amounts:
Right-of-use Assets	Other Assets	$	5,815
Lease Liabilities	Other Liabilities	5,876


Other Information:
Cash Paid For Amounts Included In The Measurement Of Lease Liabilities:
Operating Outgoing Cash Flows From Finance Leases		$	71
Operating Outgoing Cash Flows From Operating Leases		563
Financing Outgoing Cash Flows From Finance Leases		19
Right-of-use Assets Obtained In Exchange For New Finance Lease Liabilities		5,271
Right-of-use Assets Obtained In Exchange For New Operating Lease Liabilities		6,266
Weighted-average Remaining Lease Term—Finance Leases (Yrs.)		31.05
Weighted-average Remaining Lease Term—Operating Leases (Yrs.)		13.75
Weighted-average Discount Rate—Finance Leases %		3.75		%
Weighted-average Discount Rate—Operating Leases %		3.35		%



Lease cost information for the Company's leases is as follows:
	Three Months Ended		Nine Months Ended
	9/30/2019		9/30/2019
Lease Cost:
Finance Lease Cost:
Amortization of Right-of-use assets	$	28	$	72
Interest on Lease Liabilities	28		71
Operating Lease Cost	211		577
Short-term Lease Cost	17		73
Variable Lease Cost	45		140
Total Lease Cost	$	329	$	933



Future Lease Payments at September 30, 2019 are as follows:

	Operating Leases		Financing Leases
Twelve Months Ended:
9/30/2020	$	805	$	207
9/30/2021	709		236
9/30/2022	597		206
9/30/2023	541		243
9/30/2024	531		247
Thereafter	4,240		8,297
Total Undiscounted Cash Flows	$	7,423	$	9,436
Less: Net Present Value Adjustment	1,547		4,173
Lease Liability	$	5,876	$	5,263

Arrow adopted ASU 2016-02 using a modified retrospective adoption at January 1, 2019 as discussed in Note 1. The following disclosure is provided for the period prior to the adoption.

Future minimum lease payments on operating leases at December 31, 2018 were as follows:



	Operating Leases
2019	$	857
2020	626
2021	497
2022	357
2023	286
2024 and beyond	2,776
Total Minimum Lease Payments	$	5,399

Report of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm

To the Stockholders and Board of Directors

Arrow Financial Corporation:

Results of Review of Interim Financial Information

We have reviewed the consolidated balance sheet of Arrow Financial Corporation and subsidiaries (the Company) as of September 30, ~~2018~~2019 and ~~2017,~~2018, the related consolidated statements of income, ~~and~~ comprehensive income and changes in stockholders’ equity for the three-month and nine-month periods ended September 30, ~~2018~~2019 and ~~2017, and~~2018, the related consolidated statements of ~~changes in stockholders’ equity and~~ cash flows for the nine-month periods ended September 30, ~~2018~~2019 and ~~2017,~~2018, and the related notes (collectively, the consolidated interim financial information). Based on our reviews, we are not aware of any material modifications that should be made to the consolidated interim financial information for it to be in conformity with U.S. generally accepted accounting principles.

We have previously audited, in accordance with the standards of the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (United States) (PCAOB), the consolidated balance sheet of the Company as of December 31, ~~2017,~~2018, and the related consolidated statements of income and comprehensive income, changes in stockholders’ equity, and cash flows for the year then ended (not presented herein); and in our report dated March ~~12, 2018,~~8, 2019, we expressed an unqualified opinion on those consolidated financial statements. In our opinion, the information set forth in the accompanying consolidated balance sheet as of December 31, ~~2017,~~2018, is fairly stated, in all material respects, in relation to the consolidated balance sheet from which it has been derived.

Basis for Review Results

This consolidated interim financial information is the responsibility of the Company’s management. We are a public accounting firm registered with the PCAOB and are required to be independent with respect to the Company in accordance with the U.S. federal securities laws and the applicable rules and regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission and the PCAOB.

We conducted our reviews in accordance with the standards of the PCAOB. A review of consolidated interim financial information consists principally of applying analytical procedures and making inquiries of persons responsible for financial and accounting matters. It is substantially less in scope than an audit conducted in accordance with the standards of the PCAOB, the objective of which is the expression of an opinion regarding the financial statements taken as a whole. Accordingly, we do not express such an opinion.

/s/ KPMG LLP

Albany, New York

November ~~8, 2018~~5, 2019

Item 2.

ARROW FINANCIAL CORPORATION AND SUBSIDIARIES

MANAGEMENT'S DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS OF

FINANCIAL CONDITION AND RESULTS OF OPERATIONS

September 30, ~~2018~~2019

~~Note on Terminology -~~NOTE ON TERMINOLOGY

In this Quarterly Report on Form 10-Q (this Report), the terms "Arrow," "the registrant," "the ~~company,~~Company," "we," "us," and "our" generally refer to Arrow Financial Corporation and its subsidiaries as a group, except where the context indicates otherwise. At certain points in this Form 10-Q, our performance is compared with that of our "peer group" of financial institutions. Unless otherwise specifically stated, the peer group for the purposes of this Form 10-Q is comprised of the group of ~~329~~146 domestic bank holding companies with $1$3 to $3$10 billion in total consolidated assets as identified in the Federal Reserve Board’s "Bank Holding Company Performance Report" for June 30, ~~2018~~2019 (the most recent such ~~Report~~report currently available), and peer group data contained herein has been derived from such ~~Report.~~report.

~~The Company and Its Subsidiaries -~~ THE COMPANY AND ITS SUBSIDIARIES

Arrow is a two-bank holding company headquartered in Glens Falls, New York. Our banking subsidiaries are Glens Falls National Bank and Trust Company (Glens Falls National) whose main office is located in Glens Falls, New York, and Saratoga National Bank and Trust Company (Saratoga National) whose main office is located in Saratoga Springs, New York. ~~Our non-bank~~Active subsidiaries of Glens Falls National include Upstate Agency, LLC (an insurance agency ~~specializing in~~that sells property ~~insurance,~~and casualty insurance policies and also specializes in selling and servicing group health care ~~policies);~~policies and life insurance), North Country Investment Advisers, Inc. (a registered investment adviser that provides investment advice to our proprietary mutual funds)~~; Glens Falls National Community Development Corporation (which invests in qualifying community development projects);~~ and Arrow Properties, Inc. (a real estate investment trust, or REIT). ~~Our holding company~~Arrow also owns directly two subsidiary business trusts, organized in 2003 and 2004 to issue trust preferred securities (TRUPs), which are still outstanding.

~~Forward Looking Statements -~~FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS

This ~~Quarterly~~ Report on Form 10-Q contains statements that are not historical in nature but rather are based on our beliefs, assumptions, expectations, estimates and projections about the future. These statements are "forward-looking statements" within the meaning of Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended, and involve a degree of uncertainty and attendant risk. Words such as "may," "will," "expect," "believe," "anticipate," "estimate," "continue," and variations of such words and similar expressions are intended to identify such forward-looking statements. Examples of forward-looking statements include statements regarding the Company's asset quality, the level of allowance for loan losses, the sufficiency of liquidity sources, interest rate change exposure, changes in accounting standards, and the Company's tax plans and strategies. Some of these statements, such as those included in the interest rate sensitivity analysis in Part I, Item 3, entitled "Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk," are merely presentations of what future performance or changes in future performance would look like based on hypothetical assumptions and on simulation models. Other forward-looking statements are based on our general perceptions of market conditions and trends in business activity, both our own and in the banking industry generally, as well as current management strategies for future operations and development.

These forward-looking statements may not be exhaustive, are not guarantees of future performance and involve certain risks and uncertainties that are difficult to quantify or, in some cases, to identify. You should not place undue reliance on any such forward-looking statements. In the case of all forward-looking statements, actual outcomes and results may differ materially from what the statements predict or forecast. Factors that could cause or contribute to such differences include, but are not limited to:


a.	~~rapid and dramatic changes in economic and market conditions~~

b.rapid and dramatic changes in economic and market conditions;

sharp fluctuations in interest rates, economic activity, or consumer spending patterns;

c.sudden changes in the market for products ~~we provide,~~provided, such as real estate loans;

significant changes in banking or other laws and regulations, including both enactment of new legal or regulatory measures (e.g., the Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief, and Consumer Protection Act ("EGRRCPA"), the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act ("Dodd-Frank") and the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 (the "Tax Act")) or the modification or elimination of pre-existing measures;


e.	significant changes in U.S. monetary or fiscal policy, including new or revised monetary programs or targets adopted or announced by the Federal Reserve ("monetary tightening or easing") or significant new federal legislation materially affecting the federal budget ("fiscal tightening or expansion");


f.	~~cyber and physical security breaches;~~


g.	~~competition from other sources (e.g., so-called Fintech enterprises);~~


h.	~~similar uncertainties inherent in banking operations or business generally, including technological developments and changes; and~~


i.	~~other risks detailed from time to time within our filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission ("SEC").~~

significant changes in banking or other laws and regulations, including both enactment of new legal or regulatory measures (e.g., the Economic Growth, Regulatory Relief, and Consumer Protection Act ("Economic Growth Act") and the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act ("Dodd-Frank")) or the modification or elimination of pre-existing measures;

significant changes in U.S. monetary or fiscal policy, including new or revised monetary programs or targets adopted or announced by the Federal Reserve ("monetary tightening or easing") or significant new federal legislation materially affecting the federal budget ("fiscal tightening or expansion");

competition from other sources (e.g., non-bank entities);

similar uncertainties inherent in banking operations or business generally, including technological developments and changes; and

other risks detailed from time to time within our filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission ("SEC").

~~Readers are cautioned not~~The Company is under no duty to ~~place undue reliance on~~update any of the forward-looking statements after the date of this Report to conform such statements to actual results. All forward-looking statements, express or implied, included in this Report ~~which speak only as of~~and the ~~date hereof.~~ ~~We undertake no general obligation~~documents incorporated by reference and that are attributable to ~~revise~~the Company are expressly qualified in their entirety by this cautionary statement. This cautionary statement should also be considered in connection with any subsequent written or ~~update the~~oral forward-looking statements ~~contained in this Report to reflect~~that the ~~occurrence of unanticipated events at~~Company or any ~~point in the future.~~persons acting on our behalf may issue. This ~~Quarterly~~ Report should be read in conjunction with our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, ~~2017~~2018 (the 2018 Annual Report) and our other filings with the SEC.

USE OF NON-GAAP FINANCIAL MEASURES

The SEC has adopted Regulation G, which applies to all public disclosures, including earnings releases, made by registered companies that contain "non-GAAP financial measures." GAAP is generally accepted accounting principles in the United States of America. Under Regulation G, companies making public disclosures containing non-GAAP financial measures must also disclose, along with each non-GAAP financial measure, certain additional information, including a reconciliation of the non-GAAP financial measure to the closest comparable GAAP financial measure and a statement of the Company’s reasons for utilizing the non-GAAP financial measure as part of its financial disclosures. The SEC has exempted from the definition of "non-GAAP financial measures" certain commonly used financial measures that are not based on GAAP. When these exempted measures are included in public disclosures, supplemental information is not required. The following measures used in this Report, which are commonly utilized by financial institutions, have not been specifically exempted by the SEC and may constitute "non-GAAP financial measures" within the meaning of the SEC's rules, although ~~we are~~the Company is unable to state with certainty that the SEC would so regard them.

Tax-Equivalent Net Interest Income and Net Interest Margin: Net interest income, as a component of the tabular presentation by financial institutions of Selected Financial Information regarding their recently completed operations, as well as disclosures based on that tabular presentation, is commonly presented on a tax-equivalent basis. That is, to the extent that some component of the institution's net interest income, which is presented on a before-tax basis, is exempt from taxation (e.g., is received by the institution as a result of its holdings of state or municipal obligations), an amount equal to the tax benefit derived from that component is added to the actual before-tax net interest income total. ~~Historically, this~~This adjustment ~~has been~~is considered helpful in comparing ~~the~~one financial institution's net interest income ~~(before tax)~~ to that of another institution or in analyzing ~~the~~any institution’s net interest income trend line over time, to correct any analytical distortion that might otherwise arise from the fact that financial institutions vary widely in the proportions of their portfolios that are invested in tax-exempt securities, orand from the fact that even a single institution may significantly alter over time the proportion of its own portfolio that is invested in tax-exempt obligations. Moreover, net interest income is itself a component of a second financial measure commonly used by financial institutions, net interest margin, which is the ratio of net interest income ~~(before tax)~~ to average earning assets. For purposes of this measure as well, tax-equivalent net interest income is generally used by financial institutions, again to provide a better basis of comparison from institution to institution ~~and/or~~and to better demonstrate a single institution’s performance over time. ~~Arrow~~The Company follows these practices. As a result of the reduced federal corporate tax rates enacted by the Tax Act, tax-equivalent net interest income and the resulting net interest margin on a tax-equivalent basis have become less comparable to prior period levels when analyzing a financial institution’s performance over time. While Arrow continues to calculate, publish, and monitor these tax-equivalent financial performance measures, all users of this information should be aware of the non-comparative nature of post-Tax Act period results. Arrow presents net interest income and net interest margin on a GAAP basis in the relative sections of this Report in order to provide a consistently comparable performance measure over time as these measures are not effected by federal income tax rates.

The Efficiency Ratio: Financial institutions often use an "efficiency ratio" as a measure of expense control. The efficiency ratio typically is defined as the ratio of noninterest expense to net interest income and noninterest income. Net interest income as utilized in calculating the efficiency ratio is typically the same as the net interest income presented in Selected Financial Information table discussed in the preceding paragraph, i.e., it is expressed on a tax-equivalent basis. Moreover, many financial institutions, in calculating the efficiency ratio, also adjust both noninterest expense and noninterest income to exclude from these items (as calculated under GAAP) certain recurring component elements of income and expense, such as intangible asset amortization (which is included in noninterest expense under GAAP but may be excluded therefrom for purposes of calculating the efficiency ratio) and securities gains or losses (which are reflected in the calculation of noninterest income under GAAP but may be excluded therefrom for purposes of calculating the efficiency ratio). ~~We make~~The Company makes these adjustments.

Tangible Book Value per Share: Tangible equity is total stockholders’ equity less intangible assets. Tangible book value per share is tangible equity divided by total shares issued and outstanding. Tangible book value per share is often regarded as a more meaningful comparative ratio than book value per share as calculated under GAAP, that is, total stockholders’ equity including intangible assets divided by total shares issued and outstanding. Intangible assets includes many items, but in our case, essentially represents goodwill.

Adjustments for Certain Items of Income or Expense: In addition to our regular utilization in our public filings and disclosures of the various non-GAAP measures commonly utilized by financial institutions discussed above, wethe Company also may elect from time to time, in connection with our presentation of various financial measures prepared in accordance with GAAP, such as net income, earnings per share (i.e. EPS), return on average assets (i.e. ROA), and return on average equity (i.e. ROE), to provide as well certain comparative disclosures that adjust these GAAP financial measures, typically by removing ~~therefrom~~them from the impact of certain transactions or other material items of income or expense that are unusual or unlikely to be repeated. WeThe Company will do so only if ~~we believe~~it believes that provision of the resulting non-GAAP financial measures may improve the average investor's understanding of our results of operations by separating out items that have a disproportional positive or negative impact on the particular period in question or by otherwise permitting a better comparison from period-to-period in our results of operations with respect to our fundamental lines of business, including the commercial banking business.

~~We believe~~

The Company believes that the non-GAAP financial measures disclosed ~~by us~~ from time-to-time are useful in evaluating our performance and that such information should be considered as supplemental in nature, and not as a substitute for or superior to, the related financial information prepared in accordance with GAAP. ~~Our non-GAAP~~Non-GAAP financial measures may differ from similar measures presented by other companies.

Arrow Financial Corporation Selected Quarterly Information (Dollars In Thousands, Except Per Share Amounts - Unaudited)	Arrow Financial Corporation Selected Quarterly Information (Dollars In Thousands, Except Per Share Amounts - Unaudited)															Arrow Financial Corporation Selected Quarterly Information (Dollars In Thousands, Except Per Share Amounts - Unaudited)

Quarter Ended	9/30/2018			6/30/2018			3/31/2018			12/31/2017			9/30/2017			9/30/2019			6/30/2019			3/31/2019			12/31/2018			9/30/2018
Net Income	$	9,260		$	9,730		$	8,531		$	8,071		$	7,416		$	10,067		$	8,934		$	8,734		$	8,758		$	9,260
Transactions Recorded in Net Income (Net of Tax):
Net Realized Gain (Loss) on Available-for-Sale Securities	—			—			—			(278		)	6
Net Unrealized Gain on Equity Securities	85			166			13			—			—
Tax Benefit from Net Deferred Tax Liability Revaluation	—			—			—			1,116			—
Transactions in Net Income (Net of Tax):
Net Changes in Fair Value of Equity Investments																109			—			57			(106		)	85

Share and Per Share Data:⁽¹⁾
Share and Per Share Data:¹
Period End Shares Outstanding	14,441			14,424			14,368			14,348			14,308			14,969			14,949			14,909			14,907			14,875
Basic Average Shares Outstanding	14,431			14,394			14,354			14,322			14,305			14,955			14,922			14,903			14,885			14,864
Diluted Average Shares Outstanding	14,520			14,480			14,436			14,426			14,385			14,991			14,963			14,956			14,949			14,956
Basic Earnings Per Share	$	0.64		$	0.68		$	0.59		$	0.56		$	0.52		$	0.67		$	0.60		$	0.59		$	0.59		$	0.62
Diluted Earnings Per Share	0.64			0.67			0.59			0.56			0.52			0.67			0.60			0.58			0.59			0.62
Cash Dividend Per Share	0.252			0.243			0.243			0.243			0.236			0.252			0.252			0.252			0.252			0.245

Selected Quarterly Average Balances:
Interest-Bearing Deposits at Banks	30,522			28,543			27,978			27,047			27,143			$	27,083		$	25,107		$	26,163		$	34,782		$	30,522
Investment Securities	636,847			647,913			642,442			660,043			677,368			545,073			584,679			611,161			637,341			636,847
Loans	2,089,651			2,026,598			1,971,240			1,930,590			1,892,766			2,308,879			2,255,299			2,210,642			2,160,435			2,089,651
Deposits	2,279,709			2,325,202			2,305,736			2,284,206			2,193,778			2,472,528			2,436,290			2,347,985			2,347,231			2,279,709
Other Borrowed Funds	314,304			219,737			184,613			187,366			262,864			231,291			253,302			330,086			315,172			314,304
Stockholders’ Equity	263,139			256,358			251,109			247,253			243,801			289,016			280,247			272,864			268,503			263,139
Total Assets	2,879,854			2,823,061			2,763,706			2,744,180			2,725,653			3,023,043			2,997,458			2,977,056			2,954,029			2,879,854
Return on Average Assets, annualized	1.28		%	1.38		%	1.25		%	1.17		%	1.08		%	1.32		%	1.20		%	1.19		%	1.18		%	1.28		%
Return on Average Equity, annualized	13.96		%	15.22		%	13.78		%	12.95		%	12.07		%	13.82		%	12.79		%	12.98		%	12.94		%	13.96		%
Return on Average Tangible Equity, annualized ⁽²⁾	15.36		%	16.80		%	15.24		%	14.36		%	13.40		%
Return on Average Tangible Equity, annualized ²																15.05		%	13.96		%	14.22		%	14.20		%	15.36		%
Average Earning Assets	2,757,020			2,703,054			2,641,660			2,617,680			2,597,277			$	2,881,035		$	2,865,085		$	2,847,966		$	2,832,558		$	2,757,020
Average Paying Liabilities	2,110,924			2,100,085			2,050,661			2,029,811			2,012,802			2,213,642			2,235,462			2,224,403			2,189,233			2,110,924
Interest Income	24,495			23,590			22,418			22,135			21,599			27,952			27,227			26,213			26,000			24,495
Tax-Equivalent Adjustment ⁽³⁾	376			468			491			980			966
Interest Income, Tax-Equivalent ⁽³⁾	24,871			24,058			22,909			23,115			22,565
Tax-Equivalent Adjustment ³																344			376			373			376			376
Interest Income, Tax-Equivalent ³																28,296			27,603			26,586			26,376			24,871
Interest Expense	3,498			2,628			2,016			1,821			1,949			5,649			5,520			5,092			4,343			3,498
Net Interest Income	20,997			20,962			20,402			20,314			19,650			22,303			21,707			21,121			21,657			20,997
Net Interest Income, Tax-Equivalent ⁽³⁾	21,373			21,430			20,893			21,294			20,616
Net Interest Income, Tax-Equivalent ³																22,647			22,083			21,494			22,033			21,373
Net Interest Margin, annualized	3.02		%	3.11		%	3.13		%	3.08		%	3.00		%	3.07		%	3.04		%	3.01		%	3.03		%	3.02		%
Net Interest Margin, Tax Equivalent, annualized ⁽³⁾	3.08		%	3.18		%	3.21		%	3.23		%	3.15		%
Net Interest Margin, Tax Equivalent, annualized ³																3.12		%	3.09		%	3.06		%	3.09		%	3.08		%

Efficiency Ratio Calculation: ⁽⁴⁾
Efficiency Ratio Calculation: ⁴
Noninterest Expense	$	16,026		$	16,192		$	15,955		$	16,045		$	15,548		$	16,791		$	16,908		$	16,652		$	16,881		$	16,026
Less: Intangible Asset Amortization	65			66			67			69			69			61			44			79			65			65
Net Noninterest Expense	15,961			16,126			15,888			15,976			15,479			$	16,730		$	16,864		$	16,573		$	16,816		$	15,961
Net Interest Income, Tax-Equivalent ⁽³⁾	21,373			21,430			20,893			21,294			20,616
Net Interest Income, Tax-Equivalent ³																$	22,647		$	22,083		$	21,494		$	22,033		$	21,373
Noninterest Income	7,350			7,911			6,888			6,752			7,141			7,691			6,896			6,887			6,799			7,350
Less: Net Securities Gain (Loss)	—			—			—			(458		)	10
Less: Net Gain on Equity Securities	114			223			18			—			—
Less: Net Changes in Fair Value of Equity Invest.																146			—			76			(142		)	114
Net Gross Income	28,609			29,118			27,763			28,504			27,747			$	30,192		$	28,979		$	28,305		$	28,974		$	28,609
Efficiency Ratio ⁽⁴⁾	55.79		%	55.38		%	57.23		%	56.05		%	55.79		%
Efficiency Ratio ⁴																55.41		%	58.19		%	58.55		%	58.04		%	55.79		%

Period-End Capital Information:
Total Stockholders’ Equity (i.e. Book Value)	$	264,810		$	259,488		$	252,734		$	249,603		$	244,648		$	292,228		$	284,649		$	276,609		$	269,584		$	264,810
Book Value per Share ⁽¹⁾	18.34			17.99			17.59			17.40			17.10
Book Value per Share ¹																19.52			19.04			18.55			18.08			17.80
Goodwill and Other Intangible Assets, net	23,827			23,933			24,045			24,162			24,268			23,586			23,603			23,650			23,725			23,827
Tangible Book Value per Share ^(1,2)	16.69			16.33			15.92			15.71			15.40
Tangible Book Value per Share ^1,2																17.95			17.46			16.97			16.49			16.20

Capital Ratios:⁽⁵⁾
Capital Ratios:⁵
Tier 1 Leverage Ratio	9.67		%	9.65		%	9.62		%	9.49		%	9.30		%	10.04		%	9.88		%	9.73		%	9.61		%	9.67		%
Common Equity Tier 1 Capital Ratio	12.89		%	13.01		%	12.97		%	12.89		%	12.70		%	12.93		%	12.99		%	12.98		%	12.89		%	12.89		%
Tier 1 Risk-Based Capital Ratio	13.90		%	14.04		%	14.03		%	13.97		%	13.79		%	13.85		%	13.93		%	13.95		%	13.87		%	13.90		%
Total Risk-Based Capital Ratio	14.90		%	15.06		%	15.04		%	14.99		%	14.77		%	14.81		%	14.91		%	14.93		%	14.86		%	14.90		%
Assets Under Trust Administration & Investment Mgmt	$	1,551,289		$	1,479,753		$	1,470,191		$	1,452,994		$	1,411,608
Assets Under Trust Admin. & Investment Mgmt.																$	1,485,116		$	1,496,966		$	1,483,259		$	1,385,752		$	1,551,289

Arrow Financial Corporation

Selected Quarterly Information - Continued

(Dollars In Thousands, Except Per Share Amounts - Unaudited)


Footnotes:	Footnotes:																Footnotes:

1.	Share and Per Share Data have been restated for the September 27, 2018, 3% stock dividend.																Share and Per Share Data have been restated for the September 27, 2019, 3% stock dividend.

2.	Non-GAAP Financial Measures Reconciliation: Tangible Book Value, Tangible Equity and Return on Tangible Equity exclude goodwill and other intangible assets, net from total equity. These are non-GAAP financial measures which we believe provide investors with information that is useful in understanding our financial performance. See "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" on page 40.																Non-GAAP Financial Measures Reconciliation: Tangible Book Value, Tangible Equity and Return on Tangible Equity exclude goodwill and other intangible assets, net from total equity. These are non-GAAP financial measures which the Company believes provide investors with information that is useful in understanding our financial performance. See "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" on page 45.
																		9/30/2019			6/30/2019			3/31/2019			12/31/2018			9/30/2018
																	Total Stockholders' Equity (GAAP)	$	292,228		$	284,649		$	276,609		$	269,584		$	264,810
		9/30/2018			6/30/2018			3/31/2018			12/31/2017			9/30/2017			Less: Goodwill and Other Intangible assets, net	23,586			23,603			23,650			23,725			23,827
	Total Stockholders' Equity (GAAP)	$	264,810		$	259,488		$	252,734		$	249,603		$	244,648		Tangible Equity (Non-GAAP)	$	268,642		$	261,046		$	252,959		$	245,859		$	240,983
	Less: Goodwill and Other Intangible assets, net	23,827			23,933			24,045			24,162			24,268
	Tangible Equity (Non-GAAP)	$	240,983		$	235,555		$	228,689		$	225,441		$	220,380		Period End Shares Outstanding	14,969			14,949			14,909			14,907			14,875
																	Tangible Book Value per Share (Non-GAAP)	$	17.95		$	17.46		$	16.97		$	16.49		$	16.20
	Period End Shares Outstanding	14,441			14,424			14,368			14,348			14,308			Net Income	10,067			8,934			8,734			8,758			9,260
	Tangible Book Value per Share (Non-GAAP)	$	16.69		$	16.33		$	15.92		$	15.71		$	15.40		Return on Average Tangible Equity (Net Income/Tangible Equity - Annualized)	15.05		%	13.96		%	14.22		%	14.20		%	15.36		%

3.	Non-GAAP Financial Measures Reconciliation: Net Interest Margin is the ratio of our annualized tax-equivalent net interest income to average earning assets. This is also a non-GAAP financial measure which we believe provides investors with information that is useful in understanding our financial performance. See "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" on page 40.																Non-GAAP Financial Measures Reconciliation: Net Interest Margin is the ratio of our annualized tax-equivalent net interest income to average earning assets. This is also a non-GAAP financial measure which the Company believes provides investors with information that is useful in understanding our financial performance. See "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" on page 45.
		9/30/2018			6/30/2018			3/31/2018			12/31/2017			9/30/2017				9/30/2019			6/30/2019			3/31/2019			12/31/2018			9/30/2018
	Net Interest Income (GAAP)	$	20,997		$	20,962		$	20,402		$	20,314		$	19,650		Interest Income (GAAP)	$	27,952		$	27,227		$	26,213		$	26,000		$	24,495
	Add: Tax-Equivalent adjustment (Non-GAAP)	376			468			491			980			966			Add: Tax-Equivalent adjustment (Non-GAAP)	344			376			373			376			376
	Net Interest Income - Tax Equivalent (Non-GAAP)	$	21,373		$	21,430		$	20,893		$	21,294		$	20,616		Interest Income - Tax Equivalent (Non-GAAP)	$	28,296		$	27,603		$	26,586		$	26,376		$	24,871
	Average Earning Assets	$	2,757,020		$	2,703,054		$	2,641,660		$	2,617,680		$	2,597,277		Net Interest Income (GAAP)	$	22,303		$	21,707		$	21,121		$	21,657		$	20,997
	Net Interest Margin (Non-GAAP)*	3.08		%	3.18		%	3.21		%	3.23		%	3.15		%	Add: Tax-Equivalent adjustment (Non-GAAP)	344			376			373			376			376
																	Net Interest Income - Tax Equivalent (Non-GAAP)	$	22,647		$	22,083		$	21,494		$	22,033		$	21,373
																	Average Earning Assets	$	2,881,035		$	2,865,085		$	2,847,966		$	2,832,558		$	2,757,020
																	Net Interest Margin (Non-GAAP)*	3.12		%	3.09		%	3.06		%	3.09		%	3.08		%

4.	Non-GAAP Financial Measures: Financial Institutions often use the "efficiency ratio", a non-GAAP ratio, as a measure of expense control. We believe the efficiency ratio provides investors with information that is useful in understanding our financial performance. We define our efficiency ratio as the ratio of our noninterest expense to our net gross income (which equals our tax-equivalent net interest income plus noninterest income, as adjusted). There is no GAAP financial measure that is closely comparable to the efficiency ratio. See "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" on page 40.																Non-GAAP Financial Measures: Financial Institutions often use the "efficiency ratio", a non-GAAP ratio, as a measure of expense control. The Company believes the efficiency ratio provides investors with information that is useful in understanding our financial performance. The Company defines efficiency ratio as the ratio of our noninterest expense to our net gross income (which equals tax-equivalent net interest income plus noninterest income, as adjusted). There is no GAAP financial measure that is closely comparable to the efficiency ratio. See "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" on page 45.

5.	For the current quarter, all of the regulatory capital ratios in the table on page 40 and the table in this Note 5, below, as well as the Total Risk-Weighted Assets and Common Equity Tier 1 Capital amounts listed in the table below, are estimates based on, and calculated in accordance with, bank regulatory capital rules. The Common Equity Tier 1 Capital Ratio (CET1 Ratio) of Arrow as of September 30, 2018 that is listed in the tables (i.e., 12.89%) not only exceeds the currently required minimum CET1 Ratio (including Conservation Buffer) of 6.375%, but also exceeds the minimum CET1 Ratio that will be required when the Conservation Buffer is fully phased-in, on January 1, 2019, of 7.00% (including the ultimate required Conservation Buffer of 2.50%).																For the current quarter, all of the regulatory capital ratios in the table above, as well as the Total Risk-Weighted Assets and Common Equity Tier 1 Capital amounts listed in the table below, are estimates based on, and calculated in accordance with, bank regulatory capital rules. All prior quarters reflect actual results. The September 30, 2019 CET1 ratio listed in the tables (i.e., 12.93%) exceeds the sum of the required minimum CET1 ratio plus the fully phased-in Capital Conservation Buffer (i.e., 7.00%).
		9/30/2018			6/30/2018			3/31/2018			12/31/2017			9/30/2017				9/30/2019			6/30/2019			3/31/2019			12/31/2018			9/30/2018
	Total Risk Weighted Assets	$	1,999,849		$	1,934,890		$	1,889,719		$	1,856,242		$	1,830,730		Total Risk Weighted Assets	$	2,184,214		$	2,121,541		$	2,075,115		$	2,046,495		$	1,999,849
	Common Equity Tier 1 Capital	257,852			259,488			265,066			259,378			232,473			Common Equity Tier 1 Capital	282,485			275,528			269,363			263,863			257,852
	Common Equity Tier 1 Capital Ratio	12.89		%	13.01		%	12.97		%	12.89		%	12.70		%	Common Equity Tier 1 Capital Ratio	12.93		%	12.99		%	12.98		%	12.89		%	12.89		%

* Quarterly ratios have been annualized.

Arrow Financial Corporation
Selected Year-to-Date Information
(Dollars In Thousands, Except Per Share Amounts - Unaudited)
Nine Months Ended 9/30/2018
9/30/2017
Net Income $ 27,521
$ 21,255
Transactions Recorded in Net Income (Net of Tax):
Net Gain on Securities Transactions —
6

Share and Per Share Data:⁽¹⁾

Period End Shares Outstanding 14,441
14,308
Basic Average Shares Outstanding 14,393
14,306
Diluted Average Shares Outstanding 14,479
14,401
Basic Earnings Per Share $ 1.91
$ 1.49
Diluted Earnings Per Share 1.90
1.48
Cash Dividend Per Share 0.74
0.71

Selected Year-to-Date Average Balances:
  Interest-Bearing Deposits at Banks $ 29,024
$ 25,076
  Investment Securities 642,380
685,784
  Loans 2,029,597
1,839,216
  Deposits 2,303,454
2,187,431
  Other Borrowed Funds 240,027
225,400
  Stockholders’ Equity 256,913
239,516
  Total Assets 2,822,635
2,677,018
Return on Average Assets, annualized 1.30 % 1.06 %
Return on Average Equity, annualized 14.32 % 11.86 %
Return on Average Tangible Equity, annualized ⁽²⁾
15.80 % 13.21 %
Average Earning Assets 2,701,001
2,550,076
Average Paying Liabilities 2,087,445
1,998,746
Interest Income 70,503
62,522
Tax-Equivalent Adjustment ⁽³⁾
1,335
2,863
Interest Income, Tax-Equivalent ⁽³⁾
71,838
65,385
Interest Expense 8,142
5,184
Net Interest Income 62,361
57,338
Net Interest Income, Tax-Equivalent ⁽³⁾
63,696
60,201
Net Interest Margin, annualized 3.09 % 3.01 %
Net Interest Margin, Tax Equivalent, annualized ⁽³⁾
3.15 % 3.16 %

Efficiency Ratio Calculation: ⁽⁴⁾

Noninterest Expense $ 48,174
$ 46,661
Less: Intangible Asset Amortization 197
210
Net Noninterest Expense 47,977
46,451
Net Interest Income, Tax-Equivalent ⁽³⁾
63,696
60,201
Noninterest Income 22,150
20,893
Less: Net Securities Gain —
10
Less: Net Gain on Equity Securities 355
—
Net Gross Income 85,491
81,084
Efficiency Ratio ⁽⁴⁾
56.12 % 57.29 %

Arrow Financial Corporation Selected Year-to-Date Information (Dollars In Thousands, Except Per Share Amounts - Unaudited)

Nine Months Ended	9/30/2019			9/30/2018
Net Income	$	27,735		$	27,521
Transactions Recorded in Net Income (Net of Tax):
Net Changes in Fair Value of Equity Investments	166			264

Share and Per Share Data:¹
Period End Shares Outstanding	14,969			14,875
Basic Average Shares Outstanding	14,927			14,825
Diluted Average Shares Outstanding	14,968			14,914
Basic Earnings Per Share	$	1.86		$	1.85
Diluted Earnings Per Share	1.85			1.84
Cash Dividend Per Share	0.76			0.72

Selected Year-to-Date Average Balances:
Interest-Bearing Deposits at Banks	$	26,121		$	29,024
Investment Securities	580,062			642,380
Loans	2,258,633			2,029,597
Deposits	2,419,390			2,303,454
Other Borrowed Funds	271,198			240,027
Stockholders’ Equity	280,769			256,913
Total Assets	2,999,354			2,822,635
Return on Average Assets, annualized	1.24		%	1.30		%
Return on Average Equity, annualized	13.21		%	14.32		%
Return on Average Tangible Equity, annualized ²	14.42		%	15.80		%
Average Earning Assets	2,864,816			2,701,001
Average Paying Liabilities	2,224,463			2,087,445
Interest Income	81,392			70,503
Tax-Equivalent Adjustment ³	1,093			1,335
Interest Income, Tax-Equivalent ³	82,485			71,838
Interest Expense	16,261			8,142
Net Interest Income	65,131			62,361
Net Interest Income, Tax-Equivalent ³	66,224			63,696
Net Interest Margin, annualized	3.04		%	3.09		%
Net Interest Margin, Tax Equivalent, annualized ³	3.09		%	3.15		%

Efficiency Ratio Calculation: ⁴
Noninterest Expense	$	50,351		$	48,174
Less: Intangible Asset Amortization	184			197
Net Noninterest Expense	50,167			47,977
Net Interest Income, Tax-Equivalent ³	66,224			63,696
Noninterest Income	21,474			22,150
Less: Net Changes in Fair Value of Equity Securities	222			355
Net Gross Income	87,476			85,491
Efficiency Ratio ⁴	57.35		%	56.12		%

Arrow Financial Corporation

Selected Year-to-Date Information - Continued

(Dollars In Thousands, Except Per Share Amounts - Unaudited)


Footnotes:	Footnotes:							Footnotes:

1.	Share and Per Share Data have been restated for the September 27, 2018, 3% stock dividend.							Share and Per Share Data have been restated for the September 27, 2019, 3% stock dividend.

2.	Tangible Book Value, Tangible Equity and Return on Tangible Equity exclude goodwill and other intangible assets, net from total equity. These are non-GAAP financial measures which we believe provide investors with information that is useful in understanding our financial performance. See "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" on page 40.							Tangible Book Value, Tangible Equity and Return on Tangible Equity exclude goodwill and other intangible assets, net from total equity. These are non-GAAP financial measures which the Company believes provide investors with information that is useful in understanding our financial performance. See "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" on page 45.
		9/30/2018			9/30/2017				9/30/2019			9/30/2018
	Total Stockholders' Equity (GAAP)	$	264,810		$	244,648		Total Stockholders' Equity (GAAP)	$	292,228		$	264,810
	Less: Goodwill and Other Intangible assets, net	23,827			24,268			Less: Goodwill and Other Intangible assets, net	23,586			23,827
	Tangible Equity (Non-GAAP)	$	240,983		$	220,380		Tangible Equity (Non-GAAP)	$	268,642		$	240,983

	Period End Shares Outstanding	14,441			14,308			Period End Shares Outstanding	14,969			14,875
	Tangible Book Value per Share (Non-GAAP)	$	16.69		$	15.40		Tangible Book Value per Share (Non-GAAP)	$	17.95		$	16.20
	Net Income	27,521			21,255			Net Income	27,735			27,521
	Return on Tangible Equity (Net Income/Tangible Equity - Annualized)	15.80		%	13.21		%	Return on Tangible Equity (Net Income/Tangible Equity - Annualized)	14.42		%	15.80		%

3.	Net Interest Margin is the ratio of our annualized tax-equivalent net interest income to average earning assets. This is also a non-GAAP financial measure which we believe provides investors with information that is useful in understanding our financial performance. See "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" on page 40.							Net Interest Margin is the ratio of our annualized tax-equivalent net interest income to average earning assets. This is also a non-GAAP financial measure which the Company believes provides investors with information that is useful in understanding our financial performance. See "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" on page 45.
		9/30/2018			9/30/2017				9/30/2019			9/30/2018
	Interest Income (GAAP)	$	70,503		$	62,522		Interest Income (GAAP)	$	81,392		$	70,503
	Add: Tax-Equivalent adjustment (Non-GAAP)	$	1,335		$	2,863		Add: Tax-Equivalent adjustment (Non-GAAP)	$	1,093		$	1,335
	Net Interest Income - Tax Equivalent (Non-GAAP)	$	71,838		$	65,385		Net Interest Income - Tax Equivalent (Non-GAAP)	$	82,485		$	71,838
	Net Interest Income (GAAP)	$	62,361		$	57,338		Net Interest Income (GAAP)	$	65,131		$	62,361
	Add: Tax-Equivalent adjustment (Non-GAAP)	1,335			2,863			Add: Tax-Equivalent adjustment (Non-GAAP)	1,093			1,335
	Net Interest Income - Tax Equivalent (Non-GAAP)	$	63,696		$	60,201		Net Interest Income - Tax Equivalent (Non-GAAP)	$	66,224		$	63,696
	Average Earning Assets	$	2,701,001		$	2,550,076		Average Earning Assets	$	2,864,816		$	2,701,001
	Net Interest Margin (Non-GAAP)*	3.15		%	3.16		%	Net Interest Margin (Non-GAAP)*	3.09		%	3.15		%

4.	Financial Institutions often use the "efficiency ratio", a non-GAAP ratio, as a measure of expense control. We believe the efficiency ratio provides investors with information that is useful in understanding our financial performance. We define our efficiency ratio as the ratio of our noninterest expense to our net gross income (which equals our tax-equivalent net interest income plus noninterest income, as adjusted). See "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" on page 40.							Financial Institutions often use the "efficiency ratio", a non-GAAP ratio, as a measure of expense control. The Company believes efficiency ratio provides investors with information that is useful in understanding financial performance. Efficiency ratio is defined as the ratio of our noninterest expense to our net gross income (which equals our tax-equivalent net interest income plus noninterest income, as adjusted). See "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" on page 45.

* Year-to-date ratios have been annualized.

Average Consolidated Balance Sheets and Net Interest Income Analysis
(see "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" on page 40)

(Dollars In Thousands)

Quarter Ended September 30: 2018 2017
Interest Rate Interest Rate
Average Income/ Earned/ Average Income/ Earned/
Balance Expense Paid Balance Expense Paid
Interest-Bearing Deposits at Banks $ 30,522
$ 182
2.37 % $ 27,143
$ 104
1.52 %
Investment Securities:
Fully Taxable 394,072
2,189
2.20
389,092
1,928
1.97
Exempt from Federal Taxes ⁽²⁾
242,775
1,583
2.59
288,276
2,404
3.31
Loans ⁽²⁾
2,089,651
20,917
3.97
1,892,766
18,129
3.80
Total Earning Assets 2,757,020
24,871
3.58
2,597,277
22,565
3.45
Allowance for Loan Losses (19,596 ) (17,393 )
Cash and Due From Banks 38,344
37,592

Other Assets 104,086
108,177

Total Assets $ 2,879,854
$ 2,725,653

Deposits:
Interest-Bearing Checking Accounts $ 801,193
390
0.19
$ 869,748
376
0.17
Savings Deposits 744,808
901
0.48
682,347
356
0.21
Time Deposits of $250,000 or More 75,888
301
1.57
31,067
66
0.84
Other Time Deposits 174,731
370
0.84
166,776
241
0.57
Total Interest-Bearing Deposits 1,796,620
1,962
0.43
1,749,938
1,039
0.24
Short-Term Borrowings 249,304
1,075
1.71
187,864
465
0.98
FHLBNY Term Advances and Other Long-Term Debt 65,000
461
2.81
75,000
445
2.35
Total Interest-Bearing Liabilities 2,110,924
3,498
0.66
2,012,802
1,949
0.38
Noninterest-bearing deposits 483,089
443,840

Other Liabilities 22,702
25,210

Total Liabilities 2,616,715
2,481,852

Stockholders’ Equity 263,139
243,801

Total Liabilities and Stockholders’ Equity $ 2,879,854
$ 2,725,653

Net Interest Income (Tax-equivalent Basis)
(Non-GAAP) ^{(1) (2)}
21,373
20,616

Reversal of Tax Equivalent Adjustment (376 ) (0.05 )% (966 ) (0.15 )%
Net Interest Income $ 20,997
$ 19,650

Net Interest Spread (Non-GAAP) ^{(1) (2)}
2.92 % 3.07 %
Net Interest Margin (Non-GAAP) ^{(1) (2)}
3.08 % 3.15 %

¹~~See Note 3 on p. 44.~~

²~~Fully taxable basis using a marginal federal tax rate of 35% for 2017, 21% for 2018.~~



Average Consolidated Balance Sheets and Net Interest Income Analysis
(GAAP Basis)
(Dollars In Thousands)

Quarter Ended September 30:	2019							2018
				Interest		Rate					Interest		Rate
	Average			Income/		Earned/		Average			Income/		Earned/
	Balance			Expense		Paid		Balance			Expense		Paid
Interest-Bearing Deposits at Banks	$	27,083		$	182	2.67	%	$	30,522		$	182	2.37	%
Investment Securities:
Fully Taxable	328,328			2,018		2.44		394,072			2,187		2.20
Exempt from Federal Taxes	216,745			1,132		2.07		242,775			1,287		2.10
Loans	2,308,879			24,620		4.23		2,089,651			20,839		3.96
Total Earning Assets	2,881,035			27,952		3.85		2,757,020			24,495		3.52
Allowance for Loan Losses	(20,617		)					(19,596		)
Cash and Due From Banks	36,423							38,344
Other Assets	126,202							104,086
Total Assets	$	3,023,043						$	2,879,854
Deposits:
Interest-Bearing Checking Accounts	$	686,017		500		0.29		$	801,193		390		0.19
Savings Deposits	924,868			2,317		0.99		744,808			901		0.48
Time Deposits of $250,000 or More	86,018			451		2.08		75,888			301		1.57
Other Time Deposits	285,448			1,255		1.74		174,731			370		0.84
Total Interest-Bearing Deposits	1,982,351			4,523		0.91		1,796,620			1,962		0.43
Short-Term Borrowings	176,028			703		1.58		249,304			1,075		1.71
FHLBNY Term Advances & Other Long-Term Debt	50,000			395		3.13		65,000			461		2.81
Finance Leases	5,263			28		2.11		—			—		—
Total Interest-Bearing Liabilities	2,213,642			5,649		1.01		2,110,924			3,498		0.66
Noninterest-bearing deposits	490,177							483,089
Other Liabilities	30,208							22,702
Total Liabilities	2,734,027							2,616,715
Stockholders’ Equity	289,016							263,139
Total Liabilities and Stockholders’ Equity	$	3,023,043						$	2,879,854
Net Interest Income				$	22,303						$	20,997
Net Interest Spread						2.84	%						2.86	%
Net Interest Margin						3.07	%						3.02	%



Average Consolidated Balance Sheets and Net Interest Income Analysis
(see "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" on page 40)
(GAAP Basis)																	(GAAP Basis)
(Dollars In Thousands)																	(Dollars In Thousands)

(Dollars In Thousands)
Nine Months Ended September 30:	2018								2017								2019							2018
				Interest			Rate					Interest			Rate					Interest		Rate					Interest		Rate
	Average			Income/			Earned/		Average			Income/			Earned/		Average			Income/		Earned/		Average			Income/		Earned/
	Balance			Expense			Paid		Balance			Expense			Paid		Balance			Expense		Paid		Balance			Expense		Paid
Interest-Bearing Deposits at Banks	$	29,024		$	474		2.18	%	$	25,076		$	242		1.29	%	$	26,121		$	572	2.93	%	$	29,024		$	474	2.18	%
Investment Securities:
Fully Taxable	376,869			6,134			2.18		398,231			5,940			1.99		353,428			6,671		2.52		376,869			6,128		2.17
Exempt from Federal Taxes ⁽²⁾	265,511			5,389			2.71		287,553			7,116			3.31
Loans ⁽²⁾	2,029,597			59,841			3.94		1,839,216			52,087			3.79
Exempt from Federal Taxes																	226,634			3,606		2.13		265,511			4,295		2.16
Loans																	2,258,633			70,543		4.18		2,029,597			59,606		3.93
Total Earning Assets	2,701,001			71,838			3.56		2,550,076			65,385			3.43		2,864,816			81,392		3.80		2,701,001			70,503		3.49
Allowance for Loan Losses	(19,065		)						(17,172		)						(20,352		)					(19,065		)
Cash and Due From Banks	36,306								36,056								34,907							36,306
Other Assets	104,392								108,058								119,983							104,392
Total Assets	$	2,822,634							$	2,677,018							$	2,999,354						$	2,822,634
Deposits:
Interest-Bearing Checking Accounts	$	860,355		1,165			0.18		$	894,206		1,088			0.16		$	728,931		1,435		0.26		$	860,355		1,165		0.18
Savings Deposits	739,684			2,134			0.39		680,419			963			0.19		879,576			5,926		0.90		739,684			2,134		0.39
Time Deposits of $250,000 or More	78,671			833			1.42		31,974			187			0.78		87,714			1,362		2.08		78,671			833		1.42
Other Time Deposits	168,708			911			0.72		166,747			702			0.56		257,044			3,099		1.61		168,708			911		0.72
Total Interest-Bearing Deposits	1,847,418			5,043			0.36		1,773,346			2,940			0.22		1,953,265			11,822		0.81		1,847,418			5,043		0.36
Short-Term Borrowings	172,463			1,736			1.35		150,400			946			0.84		212,977			3,102		1.95		172,463			1,736		1.35
FHLBNY Term Advances and Other Long-Term Debt	67,564			1,363			2.70		75,000			1,298			2.31		54,469			1,266		3.11		67,564			1,363		2.70
Finance Leases																	3,752			71		3.72		—			—		—
Total Interest-Bearing Liabilities	2,087,445			8,142			0.52		1,998,746			5,184			0.35		2,224,463			16,261		0.98		2,087,445			8,142		0.52
Noninterest-bearing deposits	456,036								414,085								466,125							456,036
Other Liabilities	22,240								24,671								27,998							22,240
Total Liabilities	2,565,721								2,437,502								2,718,586							2,565,721
Stockholders’ Equity	256,913								239,516								280,769							256,913
Total Liabilities and Stockholders’ Equity	$	2,822,634							$	2,677,018							$	2,999,354						$	2,822,634
Net Interest Income (Tax-equivalent Basis) (Non-GAAP) ^{(1) (2)}				63,696								60,201
Reversal of Tax Equivalent Adjustment				(1,335		)	(0.07	)%				(2,863		)	(0.15	)%
Net Interest Income				$	62,361							$	57,338							$	65,131						$	62,361
Net Interest Spread (Non-GAAP) ^{(1) (2)}							3.04	%							3.08	%
Net Interest Margin (Non-GAAP) ^{(1) (2)}							3.15	%							3.16	%
Net Interest Spread																						2.82	%						2.97	%
Net Interest Margin																						3.04	%						3.09	%

¹~~See Note 3 on p. 44.~~

²~~Fully taxable basis using a marginal federal tax rate of 35% for 2017, 21% for 2018.~~

OVERVIEW

The following discussion and analysis focuses on and reviews the results of operations for the three-month period ended September 30, 2019 and the financial condition as of September 30, 2019 and 2018. The discussion below should be read in conjunction with the selected quarterly and annual information set forth above and the Consolidated Financial Statements and other financial data presented elsewhere in this Report. When necessary, prior-year financial information has been reclassified to conform to the current-year presentation.

Summary of Q3 2019 Financial Results: Net income ~~of $9.3~~was $10.1 million ~~continued the favorable trend~~ for the third quarter of ~~2018,~~2019, an increase of ~~$1.8 million,~~$807 thousand, or ~~24.9%~~8.7%, over net income for the third quarter of ~~2017.~~2018. Diluted earnings per share (EPS) for the quarter was ~~$0.64,~~$0.67, an increase of ~~23.1%~~8.1% from the EPS of ~~$0.52~~$0.62 reported for the third quarter of ~~2017.~~2018. Return on average equity (ROE) for the third quarter of ~~2018 continued~~2019 decreased to ~~be strong at 13.96%~~13.82%, ~~up from an~~as compared to a ROE of ~~12.07%~~13.96% for the ~~third~~ quarter ended September 30, ~~2017.~~2018. Return on average assets (ROA) for the ~~2018~~2019 third quarter was ~~1.28%~~1.32%, an increase from an ROA of ~~1.08%~~1.28% for the ~~third~~ quarter ended September 30, ~~2017.~~

2018.

Factors contributing to the ~~positive~~ results for the current quarter compared to the ~~comparable~~ prior year comparable quarter are as follows:

Net interest income increased 6.2% to $22.3 million, driven by the $3.8 million increase in interest and fees on ~~a GAAP basis increased 6.9%~~loans resulting from continued strong loan growth. The net interest margin was 3.07% for the quarter, compared to ~~$21.0 million~~3.02%for the third quarter of 2018. The increase in net interest margin from the third quarter of 2018 was primarily due to ~~the increase in total interest and dividend income of $2.9 million. Net interest margin~~an improved ~~slightly~~balance sheet mix. Loans increased $209.5 million as compared to ~~3.02%~~September 30, 2018. Yield on loans improved from 3.96% for the third quarter of 2018 ~~from 3.00%~~to 4.23% for the third quarter of ~~2017. Interest~~2019. Funding of loans came from a reduction of investments as well as an increase in deposits versus short and ~~fees on loans increased $2.8~~long-term borrowing. Third quarter average interest-bearing liabilities were $2.2 billion as of September 30, 2019 as compared to $2.1 billion as of September 30, 2018. Total combined Federal Home Loan Bank Overnight and Term Advances as of September 30, 2019, declined $98.0 million from September 30, 2018.

Noninterest income for the ~~2018 quarter mainly due~~three months ended September 30, 2019, was $7.7 million, compared to ~~strong loan growth and higher market rates. Interest expense increased $1.5~~$7.4 million ~~as a result of 4.4% deposit growth, higher market rates and some shifting~~ in the ~~overall funding mix toward higher costing sources. Consistent with prior years, seasonal municipal deposits increased late in~~comparable 2018 quarter. For the ~~quarter. Total noninterest income increased $209 thousand mainly due to a $146 thousand increase in~~third quarter of 2019, income from fiduciary activities and ~~an increase~~insurance combined to generate 13.8% of ~~$152 thousand in service fee~~total revenue ~~while~~of the quarter. For the third quarter of 2018, income from fiduciary activities and insurance combined to generate 15.1% of total ~~noninterest~~revenue for the quarter.

Noninterest expense for the third quarter of 2019 increased 4.8% to $16.8 million, from $16.0 million for the third quarter of 2018. Technology and equipment expense increased ~~$478~~$546 thousand, and other operating expense increased $481 thousand from the comparable quarter in 2018. FDIC Small Bank Assessment Credits of $687 thousand were fully recorded in the ~~current year quarter. In addition to the above, the~~third quarter of 2019.

The provision for income taxes ~~decreased $552 thousand, or 18%, due~~was $2.6 million for the third quarter of 2019 compared to $2.5 million for the ~~reduction~~same quarter of 2018. The effective income tax rates ~~as a result of~~for the ~~Tax Act.~~

three-month periods ended September 30, 2019 and 2018 were 20.6% and 21.1%, respectively.

The changes in net income, net interest income and net interest margin between the ~~three month~~three-month periods are discussed in detail under the heading "RESULTS OF OPERATIONS," beginning on page ~~61.~~65.

2018 Regulatory Reform:The ~~first bipartisan financial regulatory reform bill to be enacted in nearly a decade, the~~ Economic Growth ~~Regulatory Relief, and Consumer Protection~~ Act, ~~(EGRRCPA),~~ was signed into law May 24, 2018. Some of its provisions were written to take effect immediately; others have later specified effective dates and still others are open-ended, to be implemented by rule-making.

~~This legislation includes a variety~~ See the discussion of ~~provisions that are likely to affect community banking institutions such as Arrow, including~~this item under C. SUPERVISION AND REGULATION, "2018 Regulatory Reform" within the ~~following:~~

The federal bank regulatory agencies are directed to establish a "community bank leverage ratio" of between 8% and 10%, calculated by dividing tangible equity capital by average total consolidated assets of "qualifying community banks" that meet certain requirements to be set by those regulatory agencies. A qualifying community bank is a depository institution or bank holding company with less than $10 billion in total assets, such as Arrow. If a qualifying community bank exceeds the community bank leverage ratio, it will be deemed to have met all applicable capital and leverage requirements, including the generally applicable leverage capital requirements and risk-based capital requirements and the "well capitalized" requirement under the federal "prompt corrective action" capital standards. This new community bank leverage ratio is expected to reduce the burden of compliance with regard to regulatory capital adequacy.

~~The definition of "high volatility commercial real estate" loans that trigger heightened risk-based capital requirements, has been modified and limited to ease the burden of those requirements.~~

~~The total asset threshold~~2018 Annual Report for ~~qualifying insured financial institutions eligible for an 18-month examination cycle has been increased from $1 billion to $3 billion.~~

~~The new law provides that reciprocal deposits of certain institutions shall not be considered "brokered deposits," subject to certain limitations.~~

Some community banks will be exempt from mortgage escrow requirements, and an expanded "qualified mortgage" exemption for community banks has been implemented to ease the burden of the "ability to repay" requirements in the Truth in Lending Act.

~~Financial institutions with less than $10 billion in total assets that meet certain requirements will be exempt from the Volcker Rule proprietary trading requirements implemented under Dodd Frank.~~further details.

Regulatory Capital and Increase in Stockholders' Equity: At September 30, ~~2018, we~~2019, the Company continued to exceed ~~by a substantial amount~~ all required minimum capital ratios under the current bank regulatory capital rules as implemented under Dodd-Frank (the "Capital Rules") at both the holding company and bank levels. At that date, both ~~of our~~subsidiary banks, as well as ~~our~~the holding company, continued to qualify as "well-capitalized" under the capital classification guidelines as defined by the ~~current bank regulatory capital rules.~~Capital Rules. Because of ~~our~~ continued profitability and strong asset quality, ~~our~~the regulatory capital levels throughout recent years have consistently remained well in excess of the various required regulatory minimums in effect from time to time, as they do at present. Pursuant to the ~~Dodd-Frank Act,~~Capital Rules, required minimum regulatory capital levels for insured banks and their parent holding companies ~~were scheduled to increase~~increased in 2019. ~~As explained above, pursuant~~Pursuant to ~~EGRRCPA,~~Economic Growth Act, the federal bank regulators ~~are~~were required to implement a simplified community bank leverage ratio capital standard that may be applicable to Arrow and its subsidiary banks to allow them to satisfy all applicable capital and leverage requirements, including the currently applicable risk-based capital ratio requirements. The ~~implementation~~federal bank regulators have issued a final rule to implement the “community bank leverage ratio”, introducing an optional simplified measure of ~~the new~~capital adequacy for qualifying community banking organizations (the community bank leverage ratio ~~standards~~(CBLR) framework). To qualify for the CBLR framework, a community banking organization must satisfy certain requirements, including having a tier 1 leverage ratio of greater than 9%, less than $10 billion in total consolidated assets, and limited amounts of off-balance-sheet exposures and trading assets and liabilities. A qualifying community banking organizational that opts into the CBLR framework and meets all requirements under the CBLR framework will be ~~subject~~considered to have met the ~~notice~~well-capitalized ratio requirements under the “prompt corrective action” regulations and ~~comment procedures of rulemaking. EGRRCPA does~~will not ~~impose a deadline for this rulemaking. The federal bank regulators have announced their intention~~be required to ~~initiate this rulemaking process to define and implement~~report or calculate risk-based capital. Based on preliminary estimates, the ~~"community bank~~Company’s leverage ~~ratio"~~ratio computed in ~~the near future. The Company anticipates that, when~~compliance with this new standard is ~~implemented, it~~expected to exceed this new 9% threshold. This final rule will ~~simplify capital adequacy compliance requirements~~be effective as of January 1, 2020, and qualifying community banking organizations can utilize the CBLR framework for ~~community banks and holding companies such~~purposes of filing their call reports or Form FR Y-9C, as ~~Arrow~~applicable, for the first quarter of 2020 (i.e., as of March 31, 2020).

Stockholders’ equity was ~~$264.8~~$292.2 million at September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, an increase of ~~$15.2~~$22.6 million, or ~~6.1%~~8.4%, from the December 31, ~~2017~~2018 level of ~~$249.6~~$269.6 million, and an increase of ~~$20.2~~$27.4 million, or ~~8.2%~~10.4%, from the prior-year level. The increase in stockholders' equity over the first nine months of 2019 principally reflected the following factors: (i) $27.74 million of net income for the period, plus (ii) other comprehensive income of $4.83 million, plus (iii) issuance of $3.76 million of common stock through employee benefit and dividend reinvestment plans; reduced by (iv) cash dividends of $11.31 million; and (v) repurchases of common stock of $2.37 million. The

components of the change in stockholders’ equity since year-end ~~2017~~2018 are presented in the Consolidated Statement of Changes in Stockholders’ Equity on page 6,7, and are discussed in more detail in the next section.

At September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, book value per share was ~~$18.34,~~$19.52, up by ~~7.3%~~9.7% over the prior-year level. Tangible book value per share (a non-GAAP measure that deducts intangible assets from stockholders' equity) was ~~$16.69,~~$17.95, an increase of ~~$1.29,~~$1.75, or ~~8.4%~~10.8%, over the level as of September 30, ~~2017.~~2018. See the disclosure on page 4045 related to ~~our~~the use of non-GAAP financial measures including tangible book value. In the first nine months of 2018, total stockholders' equity increased by 6.1% and total book value per share increased by 9.4%. The increase in stockholders' equity over the first nine months of 2018 principally reflected the following factors: (i) $27.5 million of net income for the period and (ii) issuance of $4.0 million of common stock through employee benefit and dividend reinvestment plans; reduced by (iii) cash dividends of $10.6 million; and (iv) repurchases of the Company's own common stock, primarily in connection with the approved treasury stock repurchase plan of $1.8 million.

On September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, the Company's closing stock price was ~~$37.00,~~$33.39, representing a trading multiple of ~~2.22~~1.86 to tangible book value. As adjusted for ~~a 3.0%~~the 3% stock dividend distributed September 27, ~~2018,~~2019, in the third quarter of 2019, the Company paid a quarterly cash dividend of ~~$0.236 per share for each~~$0.25. Further discussion of dividends is included in the ~~first three quarters of 2017, a cash dividend of $0.243 per share for the last quarter of 2017 and the first and second quarters of 2018, and a cash dividend of $0.252 for the third quarter of 2018.~~Capital Components; Stock Repurchases; Dividends section located on page 63.

Loan Quality: Net charge-offs for the third quarter of ~~2018~~2019 were ~~$223~~$282 thousand as compared to ~~$547~~$223 thousand for the comparable ~~2017~~2018 quarter. The ratio of net charge-offs to average loans (annualized) was 0.05% for the third quarter of 2019 compared to 0.04% for the third quarter of ~~2018 compared to 0.11% for the third quarter of 2017.~~2018. At September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, the allowance for loan losses was ~~$20.0~~$20.9 million representing ~~0.94%~~0.90% of total loans, which is a ~~1 basis point increase~~decrease from the September 30, ~~2017~~2018 ratio of ~~0.93%~~0.94%. The ~~Company believes this~~ allowance iswas determined to be appropriate and reflects the continuing strong credit quality in the loan portfolio.

Nonperforming loans were ~~$5.8~~$4.7 million at September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, representing ~~0.27%~~0.20% of period-end loans, a decrease ~~of 11 basis points~~ from the ~~prior year comparable quarter~~September 30, 2018 ratio ~~which compares~~of 0.27%. The ratio continues to compare favorably with the weighted average ratio of ~~our~~the peer group of ~~0.64%~~0.53% at June 30, ~~2018.~~2019.

Loan Segments: During the quarter ended September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, total loans grew by ~~$68.2~~$55.3 million, or ~~3.3%~~2.4% as compared to the balance at June 30, ~~2018.~~2019. The largest increase was in consumer loans, which increased during the quarter by ~~$32.3~~$26.8 million, or ~~4.9%~~3.4%. In addition, residential real estate loans expanded by ~~$22.0~~$16.9 million, or ~~2.7%~~1.9% and the total commercial loan portfolio increased by ~~$14.0~~$11.6 million, or ~~2.4%~~1.8%.

Commercial Loans: These loans comprised ~~6.0%~~6.1% of the total loan portfolio at period-end. The business sector, ~~in the Company's service area,~~ including small- and mid-sized businesses with headquarters in the Company's service area, continued to be in reasonably good financial condition at period-end.

Commercial Real Estate Loans: These loans comprised ~~22.1%~~21.3% of the total loan portfolio at period-end. Commercial property values in the Company's region have remained stable in recent periods. Appraisals on ~~our~~ nonperforming and watched CRE loan properties are updated as deemed necessary, usually when the loan is downgraded or when there has been significant market deterioration since the last appraisal.

Consumer Loans: These loans (primarily automobile loans) comprised ~~32.7%~~34.5% of the total loan portfolio at period-end. Consumer automobile loans at September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, were ~~$687~~$799 million, or ~~99.0%~~99.2% of this portfolio segment. In the first nine months of ~~2018,~~2019, the Company did not experience any significant increase in the delinquency rate or in the percentage of nonperforming loans in this segment.

Residential Real Estate Loans: These loans, including home equity loans, made up ~~39.3%~~38.1% of the total loan portfolio at period-end. The residential real estate market in the Company's service area has been stable in recent periods. The Company originated nearly all of the residential real estate loans currently held in the loan portfolio and ~~apply~~applies conservative underwriting standards to loan originations. The Company typically sells a portion of residential real estate mortgage originations into the secondary market. The ratio of the sales of originations to total originations tends to fluctuate from period to period ~~although this ratio has generally declined somewhat in recent periods.~~based on market conditions.

Liquidity and Access to Credit Markets: The Company has not experienced any liquidity problems or special concerns thus far in ~~2018,~~2019, or at any time in ~~any prior years back to and during the financial crisis.~~recent history. The terms of the Company's ~~line~~lines of credit with a correspondent ~~bank,~~banks, the FHLBNY and the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, have not changed significantly in recent periods (see the general liquidity discussion on page ~~60)~~63). Historically, the Company has principally relied on asset-based liquidity (i.e., funds in overnight investments and cash flow from maturing investments and loans) with liability-based liquidity as a secondary source of funds (the main liability-based sources are an overnight borrowing arrangement with a correspondent ~~bank,~~banks, an arrangement for overnight borrowing and term credit advances from the FHLBNY, and an additional arrangement for short-term advances at the Federal Reserve Bank discount window). Regular liquidity stress tests and tests of the contingent liquidity plan are performed to ensure that an adequate amount of available funds can be generated to meet a wide variety of potential liquidity crises, including a severe crisis.

Visa Class B Common Stock: Arrow's subsidiary bank, Glens Falls National, ~~Bank,~~ like other Visa member banks, bears some indirect contingent liability for Visa's direct liability arising out of certain antitrust claims involving merchant discounts to the extent that Visa's liability might exceed the amount funded in ~~their~~its litigation escrow account. On September 18, 2018, Visa issued a press release announcing that ~~they~~it and other defendants entered into a settlement agreement with class plaintiffs in the related litigation case, and ~~they expect~~it expects the damage class plaintiffs to file a motion for preliminary approval of the settlement with the court. If the settlement is approved and the balance in the litigation escrow account is sufficient to cover the litigation claims and related expenses, Arrow could

potentially realize a gain on the receipt of Visa Class A common stock. On September 27, 2019, Visa deposited $300 million into the litigation escrow account that was established pursuant to Visa’s U.S. retrospective responsibility plan, which reduces the conversion rate of Class B shares to Class A shares. This did not have a significant effect on the number of Class B shares currently convertible to Class A shares by Glens Falls National. At September 30, ~~2018, Arrow~~2019, Glens Falls National held 27,771 shares of Visa Class B common stock, and utilizing the conversion ratio to Class A common stock at that time, these Class B shares would convert to 45,000 shares of Visa Class A common stock. Since the litigation settlement is not certain, the Company does not recognize any economic value for these shares.

CHANGE IN FINANCIAL CONDITION

Summary of Selected Consolidated Balance Sheet Data

(Dollars in Thousands)


	September 30, 2018		At Period-End December 31, 2017		September 30, 2017		$ Change From December			$ Change From September			% Change From December (not annualized)		% Change From September		September 30, 2019		At Period-End December 31, 2018		September 30, 2018		$ Change From December			$ Change From September			% Change From December (not annualized)		% Change From September
Interest-Bearing Bank Balances	$	34,910	$	30,276	$	24,983	$	4,634		$	9,927		15.3	%	39.7	%	$	26,416	$	27,710	$	34,910	$	(1,294	)	$	(8,494	)	(4.7	)%	(24.3	)%
Securities Available-for-Sale	340,411		300,200		315,459		40,211			24,952			13.4	%	7.9	%	314,182		317,535		340,411		(3,353		)	(26,229		)	(1.1	)%	(7.7	)%
Securities Held-to-Maturity	289,952		335,907		341,526		(45,955		)	(51,574		)	(13.7	)%	(15.1	)%	255,095		283,476		289,952		(28,381		)	(34,857		)	(10.0	)%	(12.0	)%
Equity Securities ⁽¹⁾	1,916		—		—		1,916			1,916							1,996		1,774		1,916		222			80			12.5	%	4.2	%
Loans⁽²⁾⁽¹⁾	2,126,100		1,950,770		1,908,799		175,330			217,301			9.0	%	11.4	%	2,335,591		2,196,215		2,126,100		139,376			209,491			6.3	%	9.9	%
Allowance for Loan Losses	20,003		18,586		17,695		1,417			2,308			7.6	%	13.0	%	20,931		20,196		20,003		735			928			3.6	%	4.6	%
Earning Assets⁽²⁾⁽¹⁾	2,804,155		2,627,102		2,597,471		177,053			206,684			6.7	%	8.0	%	2,939,907		2,842,216		2,804,155		97,691			135,752			3.4	%	4.8	%
Total Assets	$	2,953,220	$	2,760,465	$	2,744,462	$	192,755		$	208,758		7.0	%	7.6	%	$	3,112,822	$	2,988,334	$	2,953,220	$	124,488		$	159,602		4.2	%	5.4	%
Noninterest-Bearing Deposits	$	490,469	$	441,945	$	448,515	$	48,524		$	41,954		11.0	%	9.4	%	$	516,876	$	472,768	$	490,469	$	44,108		$	26,407		9.3	%	5.4	%
Interest-Bearing Checking Accounts	899,547		907,315		967,250		(7,768		)	(67,703		)	(0.9	)%	(7.0	)%	801,446		790,781		899,547		10,665			(98,101		)	1.3	%	(10.9	)%
Savings Deposits	758,727		694,573		696,805		64,154			61,922			9.2	%	8.9	%	929,691		818,048		758,727		111,643			170,964			13.6	%	22.5	%
Time Deposits over $250,000	76,226		38,147		28,464		38,079			47,762			99.8	%	167.8	%	96,770		73,583		76,226		23,187			20,544			31.5	%	27.0	%
Other Time Deposits	182,886		163,136		166,082		19,750			16,804			12.1	%	10.1	%	269,764		190,404		182,886		79,360			86,878			41.7	%	47.5	%
Total Deposits	$	2,407,855	$	2,245,116	$	2,307,116	$	162,739		$	100,739		7.2	%	4.4	%	$	2,614,547	$	2,345,584	$	2,407,855	$	268,963		$	206,692		11.5	%	8.6	%
Federal Funds Purchased and Securities Sold Under Agreements to Repurchase	$	62,503	$	64,966	$	61,419	$	(2,463	)	$	1,084		(3.8	)%	1.8	%	$	72,869	$	54,659	$	62,503	$	18,210		$	10,366		33.3	%	16.6	%
FHLBNY Advances - Overnight	131,000		105,000		33,000		26,000			98,000			24.8	%	297.0	%	48,000		234,000		131,000		(186,000		)	(83,000		)	(79.5	)%	(63.4	)%
FHLBNY Advances - Term	45,000		55,000		55,000		(10,000		)	(10,000		)	(18.2	)%	(18.2	)%	30,000		45,000		45,000		(15,000		)	(15,000		)	(33.3	)%	(33.3	)%
Junior Subordinated Obligations Issued to Unconsolidated Subsidiary Trusts	20,000		20,000		20,000		—			—			—	%	—	%	20,000		20,000		20,000		—			—			—	%	—	%
Stockholders' Equity	264,810		249,603		244,648		15,207			20,162			6.1	%	8.2	%	292,228		269,584		264,810		22,644			27,418			8.4	%	10.4	%

(1) ~~Equity Securities were included in Securities Available-for-Sale prior to the January 1, 2018 adoption of ASU 2016-01.~~

~~(2)~~ Includes Nonaccrual Loans.

Changes in Earning Assets: The loan portfolio at September 30, 2019, was $2.3 billion, an increase of $139.4 million, or 6.3%, from the December 31, 2018 level and up by $209.5 million, or 9.9%, from the September 30, 2018 level. The following trends were experienced in our largest segments:

Commercial and commercial real estate loans: This segment of the loan portfolio increased by $18.8 million, or 3.0%, during the first nine months of 2019, representing the continued demand for such loans.

Consumer loans (primarily automobile loans through indirect lending):As of September 30, 2019, these loans, primarily auto loans, increased by $86.3 million, or 12.0%, from the December 31, 2018 balance, reflecting a continuation of strong demand for new and used vehicles throughout our region-wide dealer network.

Residential real estate loans:This segment increased during the first nine months of 2019 by $34.3 million, or 4.0%. The growth in this segment was less than that in the nine-month period ending September 30, 2018. Factors contributing to the lower increase in growth compared to the prior year include increases in both loan prepayments and loan sales, as well as higher mortgage rates earlier in the year.

Municipal Deposits: Fluctuations in balances of interest-bearing checking accounts are largely the result of timing and behavior of municipal ~~deposit fluctuations.~~deposits. Municipal deposits on average represent ~~22%~~20% to ~~32%~~25% of total deposits. Municipal deposits are typically placed in interest-bearing checking, ~~and~~ savings ~~accounts, as well as~~and various time ~~deposits.~~deposit accounts.

In general, there is a seasonal pattern to municipal deposits which dip to a low point in August each year. Account balances tend to increase throughout the fall and into early winter from tax deposits, flatten out after the beginning of the ensuing calendar year, and increase again at the end of March from the electronic deposit of NYS Aid payments to school districts. In addition to these seasonal fluctuations within types of accounts, the overall level of municipal deposit balances fluctuates from year-to-year as ~~some municipalities move their accounts in~~a result of local economic factors as well as competition from other banks and ~~out of the Company's banks due to competitive factors. Often, the balances of municipal deposits at the end of a quarter are not representative of the average balances for that quarter.~~non-bank entities.

If in the future, interest rates begin to rise significantly or the competition for municipal deposits otherwise becomes more intense, the Company may be forced to pay higher rates on such deposits above its normal rates or municipal deposit levels may decrease if competitive rates exceed what the Company offers.

Changes in Sources of Funds: Total deposits increased ~~$162.7~~$269.0 million, or ~~7.2%~~11.5%, from December 31, ~~2017~~2018 to September 30, ~~2018~~2019 mainly due to the following: ~~the $48.5~~Other time deposits increased $79.4 million ~~increase~~ in ~~Non-Interest Bearing Deposits was from personal and business deposits; the $64.2 million increase in Savings Deposits, which was mainly~~2019 mostly due to the ~~use~~net acquisition of $70 million in brokered deposits ~~beginning~~as Arrow's subsidiary banks diversified funding with more favorable rates as compared to wholesale borrowings. Savings deposits increased $111.6 million from December 31, 2018 to September 30, 2019. Noninterest-bearing deposits increased $44.1 million and $26.4 million from December 31, 2018 and September 30, 2018, respectively. Total combined Federal Home Loan Bank Overnight and Term Advances declined $201.0 million and $98.0 million from December 31, 2018 and September 30, 2018, respectively.

FINANCIAL CONDITION

Investment Portfolio Trends

The table below presents the changes in the period-end balances for available-for-sale, held-to-maturity and equity securities from December 31, 2018 to September 30, 2019 (in thousands).

The reduction in the portfolios on a combined basis during the period reflected the Company's continued strategy in recent years to reallocate earning assets from investment securities to higher yielding loans to maximize earning asset yields.



	(Dollars in Thousands)
	Fair Value at Period-End							Net Unrealized Gains (Losses) For Period Ended
	9/30/2019		12/31/2018		Change			9/30/2019			12/31/2018			Change
Securities Available-for-Sale:
U.S. Agency Securities	$	5,056	$	46,765	$	(41,709	)	$	53		$	(306	)	$	359
State and Municipal Obligations	965		1,195		(230		)	—			2			(2		)
Mortgage-Backed Securities	307,361		268,775		38,586			987			(4,452		)	5,439
Corporate and Other Debt Securities	800		800		—			(200		)	(200		)	—
Total	$	314,182	$	317,535	$	(3,353	)	$	840		$	(4,956	)	$	5,796

Securities Held-to-Maturity:
State and Municipal Obligations	$	219,296	$	233,359	$	(14,063	)	$	3,635		$	(2,423	)	$	6,058
Mortgage-Backed Securities	39,832		46,979		(7,147		)	398			(715		)	1,113
Total	$	259,128	$	280,338	$	(21,210	)	$	4,033		$	(3,138	)	$	7,171

Equity Securities	$	1,996	$	1,774	$	222		$	—		$	—		$	—

At September 30, 2019, the Company held no investment securities in the securities portfolios that consisted of or included, directly or indirectly, obligations of foreign governments or governmental agencies of foreign issuers.

In the periods referenced above, Mortgage-Backed Securities consisted solely of mortgage pass-through securities and Collateralized Mortgage Obligations ("CMOs") issued or guaranteed by U.S. federal agencies. Mortgage pass-through securities provide to the investor monthly portions of principal and interest pursuant to the contractual obligations of the underlying mortgages. CMOs are pools of mortgage-backed securities, the repayments on which have generally been separated into two or more components (tranches), where each tranche has a separate estimated life and yield. The Company's practice has been to purchase pass-through securities and CMOs that are issued or guaranteed by U.S. federal agencies, and the tranches of CMOs purchased are generally those having shorter average lives and/or durations.

Other-Than-Temporary Impairment

Each quarter all investment securities with a fair value less than amortized cost are evaluated in the available-for-sale portfolio, the held-to-maturity portfolio and the equity securities portfolio, to determine if there exists other-than-temporary impairment for any such security as defined under generally accepted accounting principles. There were no other-than-temporary impairment losses in the first ~~quarter~~nine months of ~~2018~~2019.

Change in Net Unrealized Securities Gains (Losses): Nearly all of the change in net unrealized gains or losses during recent periods has been attributable to ~~diversify balance sheet funding~~changes in the market yields during the periods in question, with no change in the credit-worthiness of the issuers.

Investment Sales, Purchases and ~~an increase~~Maturities

There were no sales of investment securities within the nine-month periods ended September 30, 2019 or 2018.

Investment yields in ~~business money market savings balances;~~the debt markets experienced some volatility in 2018 and the ~~$38.1 million increase~~first nine months of 2019. The Company regularly reviews its interest rate risk position along with security holdings to evaluate if market opportunities have arisen that may present an opportunity to reposition certain securities as available-for-sale to enhance portfolio performance.



(In Thousands)	Three Months Ended				Nine Months Ended
Purchases:	9/30/2019		9/30/2018		9/30/2019		9/30/2018
Available-for-Sale Portfolio
Mortgage-Backed Securities	$	55,028	$	28,148	$	70,418	$	84,746

Maturities & Calls	$	27,391	$	27,283	$	79,077	$	36.663



	Three Months Ended				Nine Months Ended
Purchases:	9/30/2019		9/30/2018		9/30/2019		9/30/2018
Held-to-Maturity Portfolio
State and Municipal Obligations	$	1,302	$	2,401	$	3,398	$	4,506

Maturities & Calls	$	8,553	$	10,105	$	31,161	$	49.721

Loan Trends

The following two tables present, for each of the last five quarters, the quarterly average balances by loan type and the percentage of total loans represented by each loan type. For purposes of the following tables only, Home Equity loans have been separately disclosed from Residential Real Estate loans (they are otherwise included in ~~Time Deposits over $250,000 which was due~~a single category in this Report). Commercial and Commercial Real Estate loans have been combined into a single category (they are treated as separate categories in other sections of this Report). Over the last five quarters, the average balances for Commercial and Commercial Real Estate, Residential Real Estate and Consumer Loans have steadily increased, although at different rates. Average balances for Home Equity loans have shown a slight contraction in recent quarters.

Quarterly Average Loan Balances

(Dollars in Thousands)



	Quarter Ended
	9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Commercial and Commercial Real Estate	$	634,412	$	627,634	$	624,058	$	609,343	$	590,254
Consumer Loans	793,340		762,911		733,154		706,849		678,048
Residential Real Estate	758,523		739,667		725,274		712,274		686,705
Home Equity	122,604		125,087		128,156		131,969		134,644
Total Loans	$	2,308,879	$	2,255,299	$	2,210,642	$	2,160,435	$	2,089,651

Percentage of Total Quarterly Average Loans



	Quarter Ended
	9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Commercial and Commercial Real Estate	27.5	%	27.9	%	28.2	%	28.2	%	28.2	%
Consumer Loans	34.3		33.8		33.2		32.7		32.5
Residential Real Estate	32.9		32.8		32.8		33.0		32.9
Home Equity	5.3		5.5		5.8		6.1		6.4
Total Loans	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%

Maintenance of High Quality in the Loan Portfolio: In the first nine months of 2019, there were no significant fluctuations in the quality of the loan portfolio or any segment thereof. In general, residential real estate loans have historically been underwritten to ~~certain municipal~~secondary market standards for prime loans and ~~non-municipal customers seeking~~the Company has not engaged in subprime mortgage lending as a ~~higher return on their deposit balances~~business line. Similarly, high underwriting standards have generally been applied to commercial and commercial real estate lending operations and generally in the indirect lending program as ~~compared~~well.

Commercial Loans and Commercial Real Estate Loans: For the first nine months of 2019, combined commercial and commercial real estate loan originations continued to grow.

Substantially all commercial and commercial real estate loans in the loan portfolio were extended to businesses or borrowers located in the Company's regional markets. A portion of the loans in the commercial portfolio have variable rates ~~on non-maturity deposits.~~tied to prime or FHLBNY rates.

Although demand has been steady, it is possible that demand for commercial and commercial real estate loans may generally weaken in upcoming periods and/or that the quality of this segment of the portfolio may experience stress in upcoming periods. Generally, the business sector in the Company's service area, appeared to be in reasonably good financial condition at period-end.

Consumer Loans: At September 30, ~~2018, term advances~~2019, consumer loans (primarily automobile loans originated through dealerships located primarily in upstate New York and Vermont) continues to be a significant component of business, comprising more than a third of this total loan portfolio.

New consumer loan volume for the first nine months of 2019 remained strong, at $319.6 million, up from the ~~FHLBNY were $45~~$291.8 million ~~reflecting the non-renewal of a $10 million advance that matured during~~originated in the first ~~quarter~~nine months of 2018.

~~Changes in Earning Assets:~~ ~~The~~ As a result of these originations, the quarterly average balance of the consumer loan portfolio at September 30, ~~2018, was $2.1 billion, an increase of $175.3~~2019 grew by $115.3 million, or ~~9.0%~~17.0%, from the ~~December 31, 2017 level and up by $217.3 million, or 11.4%, from the~~quarterly average balance at September 30, ~~2017 level.~~2018.

For credit quality purposes, the Company assigns potential automobile loan customers into one of four tiers, ranging from lower to higher quality in terms of anticipated credit risk. The ~~following trends~~Company's experienced lending staff not only utilizes credit evaluation software tools but also reviews and evaluates each loan individually prior to the loan being funded. The Company believes that this disciplined approach to evaluating risk has contributed to maintaining the strong loan quality in this portfolio. However, if weakness in auto demand returns, the portfolio is likely to experience limited, if any, overall growth regardless of whether the auto company affiliates are offering highly-subsidized loans. If demand levels off or declines, the financial performance in this important loan category may be negatively impacted. In addition, the Company may sell a portion of the indirect loan portfolio if market conditions are favorable. Also, if the local economy in the consumer lending areas were ~~experienced in our four largest segments:~~


1.	~~Commercial loans. This segment of the loan portfolio decreased by $2.1 million, or 1.7%, during the first nine months of 2018, which was due to loan prepayments.~~

to experience a significant downturn, the quality of the consumer loan portfolio may also be negatively impacted.

2. Residential Real Estate Loans:~~Commercial~~ In recent years, residential real estate loans,~~. This segment~~ including home equity loans, have represented the largest category of the total loan ~~portfolio increased by $25.9~~portfolio. Gross originations for residential real estate loans (including refinancings of mortgage loans) for the first nine months of 2019 were $102.2 million. Origination totals exceeded the sum of cash flows received from borrowers in the third quarter and the Company has also sold portions of these originations in the secondary market. In the first nine months of 2019, the Company sold $19.0 million, or ~~5.8%~~18.6%, ~~during~~of originations. In the first nine months of 2018, ~~representing~~$3.5 million, or 3.4%, of originations were sold. The Company expects to continue to sell a portion of mortgage loan originations in upcoming periods if market conditions warrant. At some point, it is possible that the ~~continued strong demand for such loans.~~

~~Consumer loans (primarily automobile loans through indirect lending). As of September 30, 2018, these loans, primarily auto loans, increased by $91.4 million,~~Company may experience a decrease in outstanding loan balances in this segment of the loan portfolio. Additionally, if the local economy or ~~15.2%, from the December 31, 2017 balance, reflecting a continuation of strong demand for new and used vehicles region-wide and an expansion of our dealer network for indirect lending.~~

4. ~~Residential~~ real estate ~~loans~~market should suffer a major downturn, the quality of the real estate portfolio may also be negatively impacted.

The following table indicates the annualized tax-equivalent yield of each loan category for the past five quarters.

~~. This segment increased~~Quarterly Taxable Equivalent Yield on Loans



	Quarter Ended
	9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Commercial and Commercial Real Estate	4.61	%	4.57	%	4.46	%	4.50	%	4.42	%
Consumer Loans	4.20		3.89		3.68		3.64		3.52
Residential Real Estate	3.87		4.12		4.09		4.09		4.05
Home Equity	5.00		4.92		4.70		4.43		4.13
Total Loans	4.25		4.20		4.08		4.05		3.97

The average yield of the overall total loan portfolio during the ~~first nine months~~third quarter of ~~2018 by $60.2 million, or 7.8%. Fewer residential mortgage loans originated~~2019 increased compared to the average yield during the ~~2018 period were sold~~previous four quarters. In the third quarter, with the exception of residential real estate, yields on all other loan types increased in comparison to the ~~secondary market than~~comparable quarter in 2018 with the largest increase being in the ~~2017 period due~~home equity portfolio mainly because many of these loans have a variable rate tied to ~~rising residential mortgage interest rates experienced thus far in 2018.~~the prime rate.

Deposit Trends

The following tables provide information on trends in the balance and mix of ~~our~~the deposit portfolio by presenting, for each of the last five quarters, the quarterly average balances by deposit type and the percentage of total deposits represented by each deposit type. ~~Noninterest-bearing~~Savings deposits have increased each quarter from the third quarter of 2018 through the third quarter of 2019, as a result of the migration to higher yielding deposit ~~balances remained consistent for the quarters ended September 30, 2017 through June 30, 2018, and increased in the quarter ended September 30, 2018~~accounts due to ~~increases~~the previous rise in ~~business customer deposits.~~short-term market rates. The volatility in interest-bearing checking account balances was amainly the result of the ~~seasonality~~decline in municipal deposits. The increase in savings deposits in the quarters ended March 31 and June 30, 2018 were mainly due to the $45 million of brokered deposits obtained in the first quarter of 2018. The increase in Time Deposits over $250,000 and in Other Time Deposits ~~beginning~~ in 2019 from the ~~first quarter of 2018~~prior year was largely due to brokered deposits the ~~increase in the market~~Company acquired to diversify its source of funds at more favorable rates ~~of time deposits~~ as compared to non-maturity deposits. The increase in Time Deposits over $250,000 in the quarter ended June 30, 2018 was from municipal deposits, which decreased in the next quarter. If and to the extent that interest rates and corresponding deposit rates across all maturities continue to increase in future periods, we would expect to see further growth in time deposits.FHLBNY overnight advances.

Quarterly Average Deposit Balances

(Dollars in Thousands)


	Quarter Ended										Quarter Ended
	9/30/2018		6/30/2018		3/31/2018		12/31/2017		9/30/2017		9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Noninterest-bearing deposits	$	483,089	$	444,854	$	439,688	$	441,761	$	443,840	$	490,177	$	454,130	$	453,668	$	473,170	$	483,089
Interest-Bearing Checking Accounts	801,193		866,996		914,116		945,414		869,748		686,017		733,327		768,354		817,788		801,193
Savings Deposits	744,808		750,352		723,660		701,694		682,347		924,868		879,026		833,832		793,299		744,808
Time Deposits over $250,000	75,888		96,580		63,406		32,430		31,067		86,018		97,703		79,346		76,640		75,888
Other Time Deposits	174,731		166,420		164,866		162,907		166,776		285,448		272,104		212,785		186,334		174,731
Total Deposits	$	2,279,709	$	2,325,202	$	2,305,736	$	2,284,206	$	2,193,778	$	2,472,528	$	2,436,290	$	2,347,985	$	2,347,231	$	2,279,709

Percentage of Total Quarterly Average Deposits


	Quarter Ended										Quarter Ended
	9/30/2018		6/30/2018		3/31/2018		12/31/2017		9/30/2017		9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Noninterest-bearing deposits	21.2	%	19.1	%	19.1	%	19.3	%	20.2	%	19.8	%	18.6	%	19.3	%	20.2	%	21.2	%
Interest-Bearing Checking Accounts	35.1		37.3		39.6		41.4		39.6		27.7		30.1		32.7		34.8		35.1
Savings Deposits	32.7		32.2		31.4		30.8		31.2		37.5		36.1		35.5		33.8		32.7
Time Deposits over $250,000	3.3		4.2		2.7		1.4		1.4		3.5		4.0		3.4		3.3		3.3
Other Time Deposits	7.7		7.2		7.2		7.1		7.6		11.5		11.2		9.1		7.9		7.7
Total Deposits	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%

Quarterly Cost of Deposits


	Quarter Ended										Quarter Ended
	9/30/2018		6/30/2018		3/31/2018		12/31/2017		9/30/2017		9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Noninterest-bearing deposits	—	%	—	%	—	%	—	%	—	%
Demand Deposits											—	%	—	%	—	%	—	%	—	%
Interest-Bearing Checking Accounts	0.19		0.18		0.17		0.18		0.17		0.29		0.25		0.25		0.22		0.19
Savings Deposits	0.48		0.38		0.29		0.23		0.21		0.99		0.92		0.78		0.66		0.48
Time Deposits over $250,000	1.57		1.36		1.30		1.17		0.84		2.08		2.11		2.02		1.81		1.57
Other Time Deposits	0.84		0.68		0.64		0.60		0.57		1.74		1.67		1.36		1.08		0.84
Total Deposits	0.34		0.29		0.24		0.20		0.19		0.73		0.68		0.55		0.45		0.34

During the quarter ended September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, the total cost of deposits continued to increase asconsistent with market rates ~~increased,~~leading into the quarter, including the cost of ~~Savings Deposits~~savings deposits and both categories of ~~Time Deposits. Savings~~time deposits. In the third quarter, the Federal Reserve cut the targeted short-term rates on two occasions. In addition, market indicators anticipate a further decline in short-term rates through the remainder of 2019 and ~~time deposit customers are seeking a higher rate~~into 2020. The balance sheet of ~~return in this environment of rising rates. Given the uncertainty surrounding the future of interest rates,~~ the Company is ~~unable to predict at this time what the short- or long-term effect~~well positioned for a variety of ~~the Federal Reserve’s interest~~ rate ~~policy may be.~~environments, see Part I, Item 3, entitled "Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk," for further discussion.

~~Non-Deposit Sources of Funds~~Investment Portfolio Trends

The table below presents the changes in the period-end balances for available-for-sale, held-to-maturity and equity securities from December 31, 2018 to September 30, 2019 (in thousands).

The reduction in the portfolios on a combined basis during the period reflected the Company's ~~other sources~~continued strategy in recent years to reallocate earning assets from investment securities to higher yielding loans to maximize earning asset yields.



	(Dollars in Thousands)
	Fair Value at Period-End							Net Unrealized Gains (Losses) For Period Ended
	9/30/2019		12/31/2018		Change			9/30/2019			12/31/2018			Change
Securities Available-for-Sale:
U.S. Agency Securities	$	5,056	$	46,765	$	(41,709	)	$	53		$	(306	)	$	359
State and Municipal Obligations	965		1,195		(230		)	—			2			(2		)
Mortgage-Backed Securities	307,361		268,775		38,586			987			(4,452		)	5,439
Corporate and Other Debt Securities	800		800		—			(200		)	(200		)	—
Total	$	314,182	$	317,535	$	(3,353	)	$	840		$	(4,956	)	$	5,796

Securities Held-to-Maturity:
State and Municipal Obligations	$	219,296	$	233,359	$	(14,063	)	$	3,635		$	(2,423	)	$	6,058
Mortgage-Backed Securities	39,832		46,979		(7,147		)	398			(715		)	1,113
Total	$	259,128	$	280,338	$	(21,210	)	$	4,033		$	(3,138	)	$	7,171

Equity Securities	$	1,996	$	1,774	$	222		$	—		$	—		$	—

At September 30, 2019, the Company held no investment securities in the securities portfolios that consisted of ~~funds include~~or included, directly or indirectly, obligations of foreign governments or governmental agencies of foreign issuers.

In the periods referenced above, Mortgage-Backed Securities consisted solely of mortgage pass-through securities ~~sold~~and Collateralized Mortgage Obligations ("CMOs") issued or guaranteed by U.S. federal agencies. Mortgage pass-through securities provide to the investor monthly portions of principal and interest pursuant to the contractual obligations of the underlying mortgages. CMOs are pools of mortgage-backed securities, the repayments on which have generally been separated into two or more components (tranches), where each tranche has a separate estimated life and yield. The Company's practice has been to purchase pass-through securities and CMOs that are issued or guaranteed by U.S. federal agencies, and the tranches of CMOs purchased are generally those having shorter average lives and/or durations.

Other-Than-Temporary Impairment

Each quarter all investment securities with a fair value less than amortized cost are evaluated in the available-for-sale portfolio, the held-to-maturity portfolio and the equity securities portfolio, to determine if there exists other-than-temporary impairment for any such security as defined under ~~agreements~~generally accepted accounting principles. There were no other-than-temporary impairment losses in the first nine months of 2019.

Change in Net Unrealized Securities Gains (Losses): Nearly all of the change in net unrealized gains or losses during recent periods has been attributable to ~~repurchase, overnight advances~~changes in the market yields during the periods in question, with no change in the credit-worthiness of the issuers.

Investment Sales, Purchases and ~~term advances~~Maturities

There were no sales of investment securities within the nine-month periods ended September 30, 2019 or 2018.

Investment yields in the debt markets experienced some volatility in 2018 and the first nine months of 2019. The Company regularly reviews its interest rate risk position along with security holdings to evaluate if market opportunities have arisen that may present an opportunity to reposition certain securities as available-for-sale to enhance portfolio performance.

The following table summarizes purchases of investment securities within the available-for-sale and held-to-maturity portfolios for the three and nine-month periods ended September 30, 2019 and 2018, as well as proceeds from the ~~FHLBNY. The~~maturity and calls of investment securities ~~sold under agreements to repurchase are short-term in nature and are collateralized by investment securities. The term advances from~~within each portfolio for the ~~FHLBNY are fixed rate non-callable advances with original maturities of three to five years.~~respective periods presented:

Arrow no longer relies on TRUPs as a source of new funds. As a result of the passage of the Dodd-Frank Act in 2010 and its removal of Tier 1 regulatory capital treatment for TRUPs issued after the Act's grandfathering date, the Company, like other banking organizations of Arrow's size or larger, have not issued any TRUPs since that date and are not likely to issue any TRUPs in the future. However, consistent with the grandfathering provision in Dodd-Frank, the $20 million principal amount of Junior Subordinated Obligations Issued to Unconsolidated Subsidiary Trusts listed on the consolidated balance sheet as of September 30, 2018 will, subject to certain limits, continue to qualify as Tier 1 regulatory capital for Arrow until such TRUPs mature or are redeemed. This is further discussed under "Capital Resources" beginning on page 58 of this Report. These trust preferred securities are subject to early redemption by the Company if the proceeds cease to qualify as Tier 1 capital of Arrow for any reason, or if any of certain other unanticipated but negative events should occur. An example is any adverse change in tax laws that might deny the Company the ability to deduct interest paid on these obligations for federal income tax purposes.



(In Thousands)	Three Months Ended				Nine Months Ended
Purchases:	9/30/2019		9/30/2018		9/30/2019		9/30/2018
Available-for-Sale Portfolio
Mortgage-Backed Securities	$	55,028	$	28,148	$	70,418	$	84,746

Maturities & Calls	$	27,391	$	27,283	$	79,077	$	36.663



	Three Months Ended				Nine Months Ended
Purchases:	9/30/2019		9/30/2018		9/30/2019		9/30/2018
Held-to-Maturity Portfolio
State and Municipal Obligations	$	1,302	$	2,401	$	3,398	$	4,506

Maturities & Calls	$	8,553	$	10,105	$	31,161	$	49.721

Loan Trends

The following two tables present, for each of the last five quarters, the quarterly average balances by loan type and the percentage of total loans represented by each loan type. For purposes of the following tables only, Home Equity loans have been separately disclosed from Residential Real Estate loans (they are otherwise included in a single category in this Report). Commercial ~~Loans~~ and Commercial Real Estate ~~Loans~~loans have been combined into a single category (they are treated as separate categories in other sections of this Report). Over the last five quarters, the average balances for Commercial and Commercial Real Estate, Residential Real Estate and Consumer Loans have steadily increased, although at different rates. Average balances for Home Equity ~~Loans~~loans have shown a slight contraction ~~during the quarters ended June 30 and September 30, 2018.~~in recent quarters.

Quarterly Average Loan Balances

(Dollars in Thousands)


	Quarter Ended										Quarter Ended
	9/30/2018		6/30/2018		3/31/2018		12/31/2017		9/30/2017		9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Commercial and Commercial Real Estate	$	577,793	$	576,311	$	569,126	$	564,073	$	561,260	$	634,412	$	627,634	$	624,058	$	609,343	$	590,254
Consumer Loans											793,340		762,911		733,154		706,849		678,048
Residential Real Estate	640,277		616,519		600,076		584,981		563,793		758,523		739,667		725,274		712,274		686,705
Home Equity	134,644		137,182		139,109		137,975		137,251		122,604		125,087		128,156		131,969		134,644
Consumer Loans	736,937		696,585		662,929		643,562		630,462
Total Loans	$	2,089,651	$	2,026,597	$	1,971,240	$	1,930,591	$	1,892,766	$	2,308,879	$	2,255,299	$	2,210,642	$	2,160,435	$	2,089,651

Percentage of Total Quarterly Average Loans


	Quarter Ended										Quarter Ended
	9/30/2018		6/30/2018		3/31/2018		12/31/2017		9/30/2017		9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Commercial and Commercial Real Estate	27.7	%	28.4	%	28.9	%	29.2	%	29.7	%	27.5	%	27.9	%	28.2	%	28.2	%	28.2	%
Consumer Loans											34.3		33.8		33.2		32.7		32.5
Residential Real Estate	30.7		30.5		30.5		30.3		29.8		32.9		32.8		32.8		33.0		32.9
Home Equity	6.4		6.8		7.1		7.1		7.3		5.3		5.5		5.8		6.1		6.4
Consumer Loans	35.2		34.3		33.5		33.4		33.2
Total Loans	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%

Maintenance of High Quality in the Loan Portfolio: In the first nine months of ~~2018,~~2019, there were ~~not any~~no significant fluctuations in the quality of the loan portfolio or any segment thereof. In general, residential real estate loans have historically been underwritten to secondary market standards for prime loans and the Company has not engaged in subprime mortgage lending as a business line. Similarly, high underwriting standards have generally been applied to commercial and commercial real estate lending operations and generally in the indirect ~~(automobile)~~ lending program as well. The Company has occasionally made loans, including indirect loans, to borrowers having FICO scores below the highest credit quality classifications. The Company has also made extensions of credit to existing borrowers who have developed credit problems after origination resulting in deterioration of their FICO scores.

~~Residential Real Estate Loans:~~ In recent years, residential real estate and home equity loans have represented the largest single segment of the total loan portfolio. Gross originations for residential real estate loans (including refinancings of mortgage loans) for the first nine months of 2018 were $103.8 million. Origination totals exceeded the sum of cash flows received from borrowers in the third quarter and the Company has also sold portions of these originations in the secondary market. In the first nine months of 2018, the Company sold $3.5 million, or 3.4%, of originations. In the first nine months of 2017, $13.7 million, or 9.0%, of our originations were sold at a higher premium. The Company expects to continue to sell a portion of mortgage loan originations in upcoming periods, although perhaps a decreasing percentage of overall originations if rates continue their slow rise across longer maturities. At the same time, if prevailing rates rise substantially, there may be a slowdown in loan growth and perhaps decreasing total originations, particularly if the general economy also falters. At some point, it is possible that the Company may experience a decrease in outstanding loan balances in this largest segment

~~of the loan portfolio. Additionally, if the local economy or real estate market should suffer a major downturn, the quality of the real estate portfolio may also be negatively impacted.~~

Commercial Loans and Commercial Real Estate Loans: For the first nine months of ~~2018,~~2019, combined commercial and commercial real estate loan originations continued to ~~increase.~~grow.

Substantially all commercial and commercial real estate loans in the loan portfolio were extended to businesses or borrowers located in the Company's regional markets. ~~Many~~A portion of the loans in the commercial portfolio have variable rates tied to prime or FHLBNY rates.

Although demand has been steady, it is possible that demand for commercial and commercial real estate loans may generally weaken in upcoming periods and/or that the quality of this segment of the portfolio may experience stress in upcoming periods. This is particularly likely if the ultimate effect of the Fed's current rate hike program triggers a significant and long-lasting increase in prevailing interest rates for medium- or long-term credits. Generally, the business sector in the Company's service area, appeared to be in reasonably good financial condition at period-end.

Consumer ~~Loans (primarily automobile loans through indirect lending):~~Loans: At September 30, ~~2018, automobile~~2019, consumer loans (primarily automobile loans originated through dealerships located primarily in upstate New York and Vermont) ~~represented the second largest category of loans in the loan portfolio, and continued~~continues to be a significant component of business, comprising ~~almost~~more than a third of ~~the~~this total loan portfolio.

New ~~automobile~~consumer loan volume for the first nine months of ~~2018~~2019 remained strong, at ~~$291.8~~$319.6 million, up from the ~~$234.6~~$291.8 million originated in the first nine months of ~~2017.~~2018. As a result of these originations, the quarterly average balance of ~~our~~the consumer loan portfolio at September 30, ~~2018~~2019 grew by ~~$93~~$115.3 million, or ~~14.5%~~17.0%, from ~~our~~the quarterly average balance at ~~December 31, 2017.~~September 30, 2018.

Recently, market data has suggested that auto loan demand is weakening somewhat on a national scale, although not in every market area. The average maturity for automobile loan originations has expanded in recent years. If there is some weakening However, if weakness in auto demand inreturns, the ~~Company's service area, there may be~~portfolio is likely to experience limited, if any, overall growth regardless of whether the auto company affiliates are offering highly-subsidized loans. If demand levels off or declines, the financial performance in this important loan category may be negatively impacted. In addition, the Company may sell a portion of the indirect loan portfolio if market conditions are favorable. Also, if the local economy in the consumer lending areas were to experience a significant downturn, the quality of the consumer loan portfolio may also be negatively impacted.

Residential Real Estate Loans: In recent years, residential real estate loans, including home equity loans, have represented the largest category of the total loan portfolio. Gross originations for residential real estate loans (including refinancings of mortgage loans) for the first nine months of 2019 were $102.2 million. Origination totals exceeded the sum of cash flows received from borrowers in the third quarter and the Company has also sold portions of these originations in the secondary market. In the first nine months of 2019, the Company sold $19.0 million, or 18.6%, of originations. In the first nine months of 2018, $3.5 million, or 3.4%, of originations were sold. The Company expects to continue to sell a portion of mortgage loan originations in upcoming periods if market conditions warrant. At some point, it is possible that the Company may experience a decrease in outstanding loan balances in this segment of the loan portfolio. Additionally, if the local economy or real estate market should suffer a major downturn, the quality of the real estate portfolio in upcoming periods. As in the other segments, any substantial increase in prevailing interest rates in upcoming periods, presumably in response to the Fed's rate rise program, would likely have some negative impact on loan originations. The samemay also ~~may occur if economic conditions in the Company's indirect loan service area should generally weaken in upcoming periods.~~be negatively impacted.

The following table indicates the annualized tax-equivalent yield of each loan category for the past five quarters.

Quarterly Taxable Equivalent Yield on Loans


	Quarter Ended										Quarter Ended
	9/30/2018		6/30/2018		3/31/2018		12/31/2017		9/30/2017		9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Commercial and Commercial Real Estate	4.42	%	4.47	%	4.38	%	4.36	%	4.32	%	4.61	%	4.57	%	4.46	%	4.50	%	4.42	%
Consumer Loans											4.20		3.89		3.68		3.64		3.52
Residential Real Estate	4.05	%	4.06	%	4.09	%	3.99	%	3.98	%	3.87		4.12		4.09		4.09		4.05
Home Equity	4.13	%	3.93	%	3.70	%	3.57	%	3.55	%	5.00		4.92		4.70		4.43		4.13
Consumer Loans	3.52	%	3.44	%	3.34	%	3.29	%	3.23	%
Total Loans	3.97	%	3.96	%	3.90	%	3.83	%	3.80	%	4.25		4.20		4.08		4.05		3.97

The average yield inof the overall total loan portfolio during the third quarter of ~~2018~~2019 increased compared to the average yield during the previous four quarters. In the third quarter, with the exception of ~~2017. For the quarter,~~residential real estate, yields on all other loan types increased in comparison to the comparable quarter ~~of 2017~~in 2018 with the largest increase being in the home equity portfolio mainly because many of these loans have a variable rate tied to the prime rate.

Regardless of the future direction or magnitude of changes in prevailing interest rates, such changes will ultimately have an impact on the yield on the loan portfolio and the impact of such changes which will be dependent on many factors including the makeup of the loan portfolio, the shape of the yield curve, consumer expectations and preferences, and the rate at which the portfolio expands.

Deposit Trends

The following tables provide information on trends in the balance and mix of the deposit portfolio by presenting, for each of the last five quarters, the quarterly average balances by deposit type and the percentage of total deposits represented by each deposit type. Savings deposits have increased each quarter from the third quarter of 2018 through the third quarter of 2019, as a result of the migration to higher yielding deposit accounts due to the previous rise in short-term market rates. The volatility in interest-bearing checking account balances was mainly the result of the decline in municipal deposits. The increase in Other Time Deposits in 2019 from the prior year was largely due to brokered deposits the Company acquired to diversify its source of funds at more favorable rates as compared to FHLBNY overnight advances.

Quarterly Average Deposit Balances

(Dollars in Thousands)



	Quarter Ended
	9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Noninterest-bearing deposits	$	490,177	$	454,130	$	453,668	$	473,170	$	483,089
Interest-Bearing Checking Accounts	686,017		733,327		768,354		817,788		801,193
Savings Deposits	924,868		879,026		833,832		793,299		744,808
Time Deposits over $250,000	86,018		97,703		79,346		76,640		75,888
Other Time Deposits	285,448		272,104		212,785		186,334		174,731
Total Deposits	$	2,472,528	$	2,436,290	$	2,347,985	$	2,347,231	$	2,279,709

Percentage of Total Quarterly Average Deposits



	Quarter Ended
	9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Noninterest-bearing deposits	19.8	%	18.6	%	19.3	%	20.2	%	21.2	%
Interest-Bearing Checking Accounts	27.7		30.1		32.7		34.8		35.1
Savings Deposits	37.5		36.1		35.5		33.8		32.7
Time Deposits over $250,000	3.5		4.0		3.4		3.3		3.3
Other Time Deposits	11.5		11.2		9.1		7.9		7.7
Total Deposits	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%

Quarterly Cost of Deposits



	Quarter Ended
	9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Demand Deposits	—	%	—	%	—	%	—	%	—	%
Interest-Bearing Checking Accounts	0.29		0.25		0.25		0.22		0.19
Savings Deposits	0.99		0.92		0.78		0.66		0.48
Time Deposits over $250,000	2.08		2.11		2.02		1.81		1.57
Other Time Deposits	1.74		1.67		1.36		1.08		0.84
Total Deposits	0.73		0.68		0.55		0.45		0.34

During the quarter ended September 30, 2019, the total cost of deposits continued to increase consistent with market rates leading into the quarter, including the cost of savings deposits and both categories of time deposits. In the third quarter, the Federal Reserve cut the targeted short-term rates on two occasions. In addition, market indicators anticipate a further decline in short-term rates through the remainder of 2019 and into 2020. The balance sheet of the Company is well positioned for a variety of rate environments, see Part I, Item 3, entitled "Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk," for further discussion.

Investment Portfolio Trends

The table below presents the changes in the period-end balances for available-for-sale, held-to-maturity and equity securities from December 31, ~~2017~~2018 to September 30, ~~2018~~2019 (in thousands).

The ~~slight~~ reduction in the portfolios on a combined basis during the period reflected the Company's continued strategy in recent years to reallocate earning assets from investment securities to higher yielding loans to maximize earning asset yields.


	(Dollars in Thousands)																(Dollars in Thousands)
	Fair Value at Period-End							Net Unrealized Gains (Losses) For Period Ended									Fair Value at Period-End							Net Unrealized Gains (Losses) For Period Ended
	9/30/2018		12/31/2017		Change			9/30/2018			12/31/2017			Change			9/30/2019		12/31/2018		Change			9/30/2019			12/31/2018			Change
Securities Available-for-Sale:
U.S. Agency Securities	$	59,602	$	59,894	$	(292	)	$	(533	)	$	(434	)	$	(99	)	$	5,056	$	46,765	$	(41,709	)	$	53		$	(306	)	$	359
State and Municipal Obligations	2,548		10,349		(7,801		)	3			(2		)	5			965		1,195		(230		)	—			2			(2		)
Mortgage-Backed Securities	277,461		227,596		49,865			(6,775		)	(1,481		)	(5,294		)	307,361		268,775		38,586			987			(4,452		)	5,439
Corporate and Other Debt Securities	800		800		—			(200		)	(200		)	—			800		800		—			(200		)	(200		)	—
Equity Securities ¹	—		1,561		(1,561		)	—			441			(441		)
Total	$	340,411	$	300,200	$	40,211		$	(7,505	)	$	(1,676	)	$	(5,829	)	$	314,182	$	317,535	$	(3,353	)	$	840		$	(4,956	)	$	5,796

Securities Held-to-Maturity:
State and Municipal Obligations	$	233,557	$	275,353	$	(41,796	)	$	(5,810	)	$	(177	)	$	(5,633	)	$	219,296	$	233,359	$	(14,063	)	$	3,635		$	(2,423	)	$	6,058
Mortgage-Backed Securities	49,162		60,548		(11,386		)	(1,423		)	171			(1,594		)	39,832		46,979		(7,147		)	398			(715		)	1,113
Total	$	282,719	$	335,901	$	(53,182	)	$	(7,233	)	$	(6	)	$	(7,227	)	$	259,128	$	280,338	$	(21,210	)	$	4,033		$	(3,138	)	$	7,171

Equity Securities ¹	$	1,916	$	—	$	1,916		$	—		$	—		$	—
Equity Securities																	$	1,996	$	1,774	$	222		$	—		$	—		$	—

~~Footnote:~~

~~1. Beginning January 1, 2018, upon adoption of ASU 2016-01, equity securities with readily determinable fair values are reported separately from Available-for-Sale securities.~~

At September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, the Company held no investment securities in the securities portfolios that consisted of or included, directly or indirectly, obligations of foreign governments or governmental agencies of foreign issuers.

In the periods referenced above, Mortgage-Backed Securities consisted solely of mortgage pass-through securities and Collateralized Mortgage Obligations ("CMOs") issued or guaranteed by U.S. federal agencies. Mortgage pass-through securities provide to the investor monthly portions of principal and interest pursuant to the contractual obligations of the underlying mortgages. CMOs are pools of mortgage-backed securities, the repayments on which have generally been separated into two or more components (tranches), where each tranche has a separate estimated life and yield. ~~Our~~The Company's practice has been to purchase ~~only floating rate securities,~~ pass-through securities and CMOs that are issued or guaranteed by U.S. federal agencies, and the tranches of CMOs ~~that we purchase~~purchased are generally ~~are~~ those having shorter average lives and/or durations.

Other-Than-Temporary Impairment

Change in Net Unrealized Securities Gains (Losses): Nearly all of the change in ~~our~~ net unrealized gains or losses during recent periods has been attributable to changes in the market yields during the periods in question, with ~~little or~~ no change in the credit-worthiness of the issuers.

Investment Sales, Purchases and Maturities

~~The following table summarizes~~There were no sales of investment securities within the ~~available-for-sale and held-to-maturity portfolios for the three- and~~ nine-month periods ended September 30, ~~2018 and 2017.~~

Three Months Ended Nine Months Ended
Sales 9/30/2018 9/30/2017 9/30/2018 9/30/2017
Available-For-Sale Portfolio:
U.S. Agency Securities $ —
$ 10,005
$ —
$ 10,005
Total $ —
$ 10,005
$ —
$ 10,005
Net Gains on Securities Transactions —
10
—
10
Proceeds on the Sales of Securities $ —
$ 10,015
$ —
$ 10,015
2019 or 2018.

Investment yields in the debt markets experienced some volatility in ~~2017~~2018 and the first nine months of ~~2018.~~2019. The Company regularly reviews its interest rate risk position along with security holdings to evaluate if market opportunities have arisen that may present an opportunity to reposition certain securities as available-for-sale to enhance portfolio performance.

The following table summarizes purchases of investment securities within the available-for-sale and held-to-maturity portfolios for the ~~three-~~three and nine-month periods ended September 30, ~~2018~~2019 and ~~2017,~~2018, as well as proceeds from the maturity and calls of investment securities within each portfolio for the respective periods presented:


(In Thousands)	Three Months Ended				Nine Months Ended				Three Months Ended				Nine Months Ended
Purchases:	9/30/2018		9/30/2017		9/30/2018		9/30/2017		9/30/2019		9/30/2018		9/30/2019		9/30/2018
Available-for-Sale Portfolio
U.S. Treasury Securities	$	—	$	10,179	$	—	$	10,179
Mortgage-Backed Securities	28,148		—		84,746		12,324		$	55,028	$	28,148	$	70,418	$	84,746
Total Purchases	$	28,148	$	10,179	$	84,746	$	22,503

Maturities & Calls	$	27,283	$	11,750	$	36,663	$	43,617	$	27,391	$	27,283	$	79,077	$	36.663


	Three Months Ended				Nine Months Ended				Three Months Ended				Nine Months Ended
Purchases:	9/30/2018		9/30/2017		9/30/2018		9/30/2017		9/30/2019		9/30/2018		9/30/2019		9/30/2018
Held-to-Maturity Portfolio
State and Municipal Obligations	$	2,401	$	2,583	$	4,506	$	36,018	$	1,302	$	2,401	$	3,398	$	4,506
Total Purchases	$	2,401	$	2,583	$	4,506	$	36,018

Maturities & Calls	$	10,105	$	8,800	$	49,721	$	39,062	$	8,553	$	10,105	$	31,161	$	49.721

Loan Trends

The following two tables present, for each of the last five quarters, the quarterly average balances by loan type and the percentage of total loans represented by each loan type. For purposes of the following tables only, Home Equity loans have been separately disclosed from Residential Real Estate loans (they are otherwise included in a single category in this Report). Commercial and Commercial Real Estate loans have been combined into a single category (they are treated as separate categories in other sections of this Report). Over the last five quarters, the average balances for Commercial and Commercial Real Estate, Residential Real Estate and Consumer Loans have steadily increased, although at different rates. Average balances for Home Equity loans have shown a slight contraction in recent quarters.

Quarterly Average Loan Balances

(Dollars in Thousands)



	Quarter Ended
	9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Commercial and Commercial Real Estate	$	634,412	$	627,634	$	624,058	$	609,343	$	590,254
Consumer Loans	793,340		762,911		733,154		706,849		678,048
Residential Real Estate	758,523		739,667		725,274		712,274		686,705
Home Equity	122,604		125,087		128,156		131,969		134,644
Total Loans	$	2,308,879	$	2,255,299	$	2,210,642	$	2,160,435	$	2,089,651

Percentage of Total Quarterly Average Loans



	Quarter Ended
	9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Commercial and Commercial Real Estate	27.5	%	27.9	%	28.2	%	28.2	%	28.2	%
Consumer Loans	34.3		33.8		33.2		32.7		32.5
Residential Real Estate	32.9		32.8		32.8		33.0		32.9
Home Equity	5.3		5.5		5.8		6.1		6.4
Total Loans	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%

Maintenance of High Quality in the Loan Portfolio: In the first nine months of 2019, there were no significant fluctuations in the quality of the loan portfolio or any segment thereof. In general, residential real estate loans have historically been underwritten to secondary market standards for prime loans and the Company has not engaged in subprime mortgage lending as a business line. Similarly, high underwriting standards have generally been applied to commercial and commercial real estate lending operations and generally in the indirect lending program as well.

Commercial Loans and Commercial Real Estate Loans: For the first nine months of 2019, combined commercial and commercial real estate loan originations continued to grow.

Although demand has been steady, it is possible that demand for commercial and commercial real estate loans may generally weaken in upcoming periods and/or that the quality of this segment of the portfolio may experience stress in upcoming periods. Generally, the business sector in the Company's service area, appeared to be in reasonably good financial condition at period-end.

Consumer Loans: At September 30, 2019, consumer loans (primarily automobile loans originated through dealerships located primarily in upstate New York and Vermont) continues to be a significant component of business, comprising more than a third of this total loan portfolio.

New consumer loan volume for the first nine months of 2019 remained strong, at $319.6 million, up from the $291.8 million originated in the first nine months of 2018. As a result of these originations, the quarterly average balance of the consumer loan portfolio at September 30, 2019 grew by $115.3 million, or 17.0%, from the quarterly average balance at September 30, 2018.

For credit quality purposes, the Company assigns potential automobile loan customers into one of four tiers, ranging from lower to higher quality in terms of anticipated credit risk. The Company's experienced lending staff not only utilizes credit evaluation software tools but also reviews and evaluates each loan individually prior to the loan being funded. The Company believes that this disciplined approach to evaluating risk has contributed to maintaining the strong loan quality in this portfolio. However, if weakness in auto demand returns, the portfolio is likely to experience limited, if any, overall growth regardless of whether the auto company affiliates are offering highly-subsidized loans. If demand levels off or declines, the financial performance in this important loan category may be negatively impacted. In addition, the Company may sell a portion of the indirect loan portfolio if market conditions are favorable. Also, if the local economy in the consumer lending areas were to experience a significant downturn, the quality of the consumer loan portfolio may also be negatively impacted.

The following table indicates the annualized tax-equivalent yield of each loan category for the past five quarters.

Quarterly Taxable Equivalent Yield on Loans



	Quarter Ended
	9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Commercial and Commercial Real Estate	4.61	%	4.57	%	4.46	%	4.50	%	4.42	%
Consumer Loans	4.20		3.89		3.68		3.64		3.52
Residential Real Estate	3.87		4.12		4.09		4.09		4.05
Home Equity	5.00		4.92		4.70		4.43		4.13
Total Loans	4.25		4.20		4.08		4.05		3.97

The average yield of the overall total loan portfolio during the third quarter of 2019 increased compared to the average yield during the previous four quarters. In the third quarter, with the exception of residential real estate, yields on all other loan types increased in comparison to the comparable quarter in 2018 with the largest increase being in the home equity portfolio mainly because many of these loans have a variable rate tied to the prime rate.

Deposit Trends

Quarterly Average Deposit Balances

(Dollars in Thousands)



	Quarter Ended
	9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Noninterest-bearing deposits	$	490,177	$	454,130	$	453,668	$	473,170	$	483,089
Interest-Bearing Checking Accounts	686,017		733,327		768,354		817,788		801,193
Savings Deposits	924,868		879,026		833,832		793,299		744,808
Time Deposits over $250,000	86,018		97,703		79,346		76,640		75,888
Other Time Deposits	285,448		272,104		212,785		186,334		174,731
Total Deposits	$	2,472,528	$	2,436,290	$	2,347,985	$	2,347,231	$	2,279,709

Percentage of Total Quarterly Average Deposits



	Quarter Ended
	9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Noninterest-bearing deposits	19.8	%	18.6	%	19.3	%	20.2	%	21.2	%
Interest-Bearing Checking Accounts	27.7		30.1		32.7		34.8		35.1
Savings Deposits	37.5		36.1		35.5		33.8		32.7
Time Deposits over $250,000	3.5		4.0		3.4		3.3		3.3
Other Time Deposits	11.5		11.2		9.1		7.9		7.7
Total Deposits	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%	100.0	%

Quarterly Cost of Deposits



	Quarter Ended
	9/30/2019		6/30/2019		3/31/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Demand Deposits	—	%	—	%	—	%	—	%	—	%
Interest-Bearing Checking Accounts	0.29		0.25		0.25		0.22		0.19
Savings Deposits	0.99		0.92		0.78		0.66		0.48
Time Deposits over $250,000	2.08		2.11		2.02		1.81		1.57
Other Time Deposits	1.74		1.67		1.36		1.08		0.84
Total Deposits	0.73		0.68		0.55		0.45		0.34

Non-Deposit Sources of Funds

The Company's other sources of funds include securities sold under agreements to repurchase, overnight advances and term advances from the FHLBNY. The securities sold under agreements to repurchase are short-term in nature and are collateralized by investment securities. The term advances from the FHLBNY are fixed rate non-callable advances with original maturities of three to five years.

Arrow no longer relies on TRUPs as a source of new funds. As a result of the passage of Dodd-Frank in 2010 and its removal of Tier 1 regulatory capital treatment for TRUPs issued after Dodd-Frank's grandfathering date, the Company, like other banking organizations of Arrow's size or larger, have not issued any TRUPs since that date and are not likely to issue any TRUPs in the future. However, consistent with the grandfathering provision in Dodd-Frank, the $20 million principal amount of Junior Subordinated Obligations Issued to Unconsolidated Subsidiary Trusts listed on the consolidated balance sheet as of September 30, 2019 (i.e., previously issued TRUPs) will, subject to certain limits, continue to qualify as Tier 1 regulatory capital for Arrow until such TRUPs mature or are redeemed. This is further discussed under "Capital Resources" beginning on page 61 of this Report. These trust preferred securities are subject to early redemption by the Company if the proceeds cease to qualify as Tier 1 capital of Arrow for any reason, or if certain other unanticipated but negative events should occur. An example is any adverse change in tax laws that might deny the Company the ability to deduct interest paid on these obligations for federal income tax purposes.

~~Asset Quality~~

ASSET QUALITY

The following table presents information related to ~~our~~the allowance and provision for loan losses for the past five quarters.

Summary of the Allowance and Provision for Loan Losses

(Dollars in Thousands, Loans Stated Net of Unearned Income)


	9/30/2018			6/30/2018			3/31/2018			12/31/2017			9/30/2017			9/30/2019			6/30/2019			3/31/2019			12/31/2018			9/30/2018
Loan Balances:
Period-End Loans	$	2,126,100		$	2,057,862		$	1,993,037		$	1,950,770		$	1,908,799		$	2,335,591		$	2,280,308		$	2,235,208		$	2,196,215		$	2,126,100
Average Loans, Year-to-Date	2,029,597			1,999,072			1,971,240			1,862,247			1,839,216			2,258,633			2,233,094			2,210,642			2,062,575			2,029,597
Average Loans, Quarter-to-Date	2,089,651			2,026,598			1,971,240			1,930,590			1,892,766			2,308,879			2,255,299			2,210,642			2,160,435			2,089,651
Period-End Assets	2,953,220			2,845,171			2,826,687			2,760,465			2,744,462			3,112,822			3,005,750			2,984,883			2,988,334			2,953,220

Allowance for Loan Losses, Year-to-Date:
Allowance for Loan Losses, Beginning of Period	$	18,586		$	18,586		$	18,586		$	17,012		$	17,012		$	20,196		$	20,196		$	20,196		$	18,586		$	18,586
Provision for Loan Losses, YTD	1,961			1,375			746			2,736			1,580			1,445			927			472			2,607			1,961
Loans Charged-off, YTD	(960		)	(634		)	(370		)	(1,559		)	(1,197		)	(1,232		)	(830		)	(462		)	(1,532		)	(960		)
Recoveries of Loans Previously Charged-off	416			313			95			397			300			522			402			167			535			416
Net Charge-offs, YTD	(544		)	(321		)	(275		)	(1,162		)	(897		)	(710		)	(428		)	(295		)	(997		)	(544		)
Allowance for Loan Losses, End of Period	$	20,003		$	19,640		$	19,057		$	18,586		$	17,695		$	20,931		$	20,695		$	20,373		$	20,196		$	20,003

Allowance for Loan Losses, Quarter-to-Date:
Allowance for Loan Losses, Beginning of Period	$	19,640		$	19,057		$	18,586		$	17,695		$	17,442		$	20,695		$	20,373		$	20,196		$	20,003		$	19,640
Provision for Loan Losses, QTD	586			629			746			1,157			800			518			455			472			646			586
Loans Charged-off, QTD	(325		)	(264		)	(370		)	(363		)	(622		)	(402		)	(368		)	(462		)	(573		)	(325		)
Recoveries of Loans Previously Charged-off	102			218			95			97			75			120			235			167			120			102
Net Charge-offs, QTD	(223		)	(46		)	(275		)	(266		)	(547		)	(282		)	(133		)	(295		)	(453		)	(223		)
Allowance for Loan Losses, End of Period	$	20,003		$	19,640		$	19,057		$	18,586		$	17,695		$	20,931		$	20,695		$	20,373		$	20,196		$	20,003

Nonperforming Assets, at Period-End:
Nonaccrual Loans	$	4,468		$	3,880		$	4,470		$	5,526		$	5,482		$	3,465		$	4,949		$	5,143		$	4,159		$	4,468
Loans Past Due 90 or More Days and Still Accruing Interest	1,172			170			—			319			967			1,066			457			64			1,225			1,172
Restructured and in Compliance with Modified Terms	115			106			100			105			828			150			142			141			138			115
Total Nonperforming Loans	5,755			4,156			4,570			5,950			7,277			4,681			5,548			5,348			5,522			5,755
Repossessed Assets	47			76			120			109			62			76			115			123			130			47
Other Real Estate Owned	1,173			1,412			1,525			1,738			1,651			1,198			1,258			1,322			1,130			1,173
Total Nonperforming Assets	$	6,975		$	5,644		$	6,215		$	7,797		$	8,990		$	5,955		$	6,921		$	6,793		$	6,782		$	6,975

Asset Quality Ratios:
Allowance to Nonperforming Loans	347.58		%	472.57		%	417.00		%	312.37		%	243.16		%	447.15		%	373.02		%	380.95		%	365.74		%	347.58		%
Allowance to Period-End Loans	0.94		%	0.95		%	0.96		%	0.95		%	0.93		%	0.90		%	0.91		%	0.91		%	0.92		%	0.94		%
Provision to Average Loans (Quarter) ⁽¹⁾	0.11		%	0.12		%	0.15		%	0.24		%	0.17		%	0.09		%	0.08		%	0.09		%	0.12		%	0.11		%
Provision to Average Loans (YTD) ⁽¹⁾	0.13		%	0.14		%	0.15		%	0.15		%	0.11		%	0.09		%	0.08		%	0.09		%	0.13		%	0.13		%
Net Charge-offs to Average Loans (Quarter) ⁽¹⁾	0.04		%	0.01		%	0.06		%	0.05		%	0.11		%	0.05		%	0.02		%	0.05		%	0.08		%	0.04		%
Net Charge-offs to Average Loans (YTD) ⁽¹⁾	0.04		%	0.03		%	0.06		%	0.06		%	0.07		%	0.04		%	0.04		%	0.05		%	0.05		%	0.04		%
Nonperforming Loans to Total Loans	0.27		%	0.20		%	0.23		%	0.31		%	0.38		%	0.20		%	0.24		%	0.24		%	0.25		%	0.27		%
Nonperforming Assets to Total Assets	0.24		%	0.20		%	0.22		%	0.28		%	0.33		%	0.19		%	0.23		%	0.23		%	0.23		%	0.24		%
⁽¹⁾ Annualized

Provision for Loan Losses

Through the provision for loan losses, an allowance is maintained that reflects the Company's best estimate of probable incurred loan losses related to specifically identified impaired loans as well as the inherent risk of loss related to the remaining portfolio. Loan charge-offs are recorded to this allowance when loans are deemed uncollectible, in whole or in part. As loans become past due, consideration is given to the status of those loans and whether or not to classify them as nonaccrual loans. Any loans listed as "past due 90 or more days and still accruing interest" have been evaluated and determined to be secured and is the ~~borrowers have been deemed to have the capacity to repay all principal and interest and, therefore, have not been classified as nonaccrual.~~process of collection.

In the third quarter of ~~2018,~~2019, the Company made a ~~$586~~$518 thousand provision for loan losses, compared to a provision of ~~$800~~$586 thousand for the third quarter of ~~2017~~2018 and a provision of ~~$629~~$455 thousand for the second quarter of ~~2018.~~2019. The provision expense was largely driven

by growth in outstanding loan balances. Additional items impacting the current quarter provision ~~included~~include changes to qualitative factors

that reflect management’s view on current economic and market risks, and net charge-offs of ~~$223~~$282 thousand. See Note 3 to the unaudited interim consolidated financial statements for a discussion on how the Company classifies credit quality indicators as well as the balance in each category.

The ratio of the allowance for loan losses to total loans was 0.90% at September 30, 2019, a decrease from 0.92% at December 31, 2018 and a decrease of 4 basis points from 0.94% at September 30, ~~2018, a decrease from 0.95% at December 31, 2017 and an increase of 1 basis point from 0.93% at September 30, 2017.~~2018.

The accounting policy relating to the allowance for loan losses is considered to be a critical accounting policy, given the uncertainty involved in evaluating the level of the allowance required to cover credit losses inherent in the loan portfolio, and the material effect that such judgments may have on ~~our~~the results of operations. The process for determining the provision for loan losses is described in Note 3 to the unaudited interim consolidated financial statements.

Risk Elements

Nonperforming assets at September 30, ~~2018~~2019 amounted to ~~$7.0~~$6.0 million, ~~a decrease of $0.8 million,~~down from the $6.8 million total at December 31, ~~2017 total~~2018 and a decrease of ~~$2.0~~$1.0 million, from ~~the year earlier total.~~June 30, 2018. For the ~~nine-month~~three-month periods ended September 30, ~~2018~~2019 and ~~2017,~~2018, ratios of nonperforming assets to total assets have remained below the average ratios for the peer ~~group, although the average peer group ratios have improved dramatically in recent years.~~group. (See page 3944 for a discussion of the peer group.) At June 30, ~~2018,~~2019, the ratio of loans past due 90 or more days plus nonaccrual loans plus other real estate owned to total assets was ~~0.19%~~0.23%, well below the ~~0.59%~~0.46% ratio of the peer group at such date (the latest date for which peer group information is available). At September 30, ~~2018~~2019 the ratio ~~is 0.24%~~was 0.19%, which is below the most recent ratio for the peer group.

The following table presents the balance of other non-current loans at period-end as to which interest income was being accrued (i.e. loans 30 to 89 days past due, as defined in bank regulatory guidelines). These non-current loans are not included in nonperforming assets, but entail heightened risk.


Loans Past Due 30-89 Days and Accruing Interest ($ in 000's)	Loans Past Due 30-89 Days and Accruing Interest ($ in 000's)						Loans Past Due 30-89 Days and Accruing Interest ($ in 000's)
	9/30/2018		12/31/2017		9/30/2017		9/30/2019		12/31/2018		9/30/2018
Commercial Loans	$	198	$	158	$	122	$	148	$	170	$	198
Commercial Real Estate Loans	—		—		—		30		108		—
Residential Real Estate Loans	2,663		1,696		1,063		1,000		2,190		2,663
Consumer Loans - Primarily Indirect Automobile	6,863		7,064		5,615		6,804		7,414		6,863
Total Loans Past Due 30-89 Days and Accruing Interest	$	9,724	$	8,918	$	6,800	$	7,982	$	9,882	$	9,724

At September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, the loans in ~~this~~the above-referenced category totaled ~~$9.7~~$8.0 million, ~~an increase~~a decrease of ~~$0.8~~$1.9 million, or ~~9.0%~~19.2%, from the ~~$8.9~~$9.9 million of such loans at December 31, ~~2017.~~2018. The September 30, ~~2018~~2019 total of non-current loans equaled ~~0.46%~~0.34% of loans then outstanding, ~~unchanged from the year-end 2017 percentage~~compared to 0.45% at December 31, 2018 and ~~up from the~~0.46% at September 30, ~~2017 level of 0.36%.~~2018. The ~~increase~~decrease from December 31, ~~2017~~2018 is primarily attributable to ~~an increase~~a decrease in delinquent automobile loans ~~which tend to reflect seasonally elevated levels in the second half of the year.~~as well as residential real estate loans.

The number and dollar amount of performing loans that demonstrate characteristics of potential weakness from time-to-time (potential problem loans) typically is a very small percentage of ~~our~~the loan portfolio. See the table of Credit Quality Indicators in Note 3 to the unaudited interim consolidated financial statements. The Company considers all performing commercial and commercial real estate loans classified as substandard or lower (as reported in Note 3) to be potential problem loans. The dollar amount of such loans at September 30, ~~2018~~2019 was ~~$31.95~~$30.6 million, ~~up slightly~~down from the dollar amount of such loans at December 31, ~~2017,~~2018, when the amount was ~~$29.66~~$35.0 million. These loans will continue to be closely monitored and the Company expects to collect all payments of contractual interest and principal in full on these classified loans. Total nonperforming assets at period-end decreased by ~~$2.0~~$1.0 million, or ~~22.4%~~14.6% from September 30, ~~2017.~~2018.

The economy in the Company's market area has been relatively strong in recent years, but any general weakening of the U.S. economy in upcoming periods would likely have an adverse effect on the economy in this market area as well, and ultimately on the loan portfolio, particularly the commercial and commercial real estate portfolio.

As of September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, the Company held for sale two commercial properties and one residential property in other real estate owned. The Company does not expect to acquire a significant number of other real estate properties in the near term as a result of payment defaults or the foreclosure process.

The Company does not currently anticipate significant increases in nonperforming assets, other non-current loans as to which interest income is still being accrued or potential problem loans, but can give no assurances in this regard.

CAPITAL RESOURCES

Regulatory Capital Standards

Capital Adequacy Requirements. An important area of banking regulation is the federal banking system's promulgation and enforcement of minimum capitalization standards for banks and bank holding companies.

As reported in the Regulatory Reform section above, on May 24, 2018 the ~~EGRRCPA~~Economic Growth Act financial reform bill was signed into law. This new law includes provisions requiring the federal bank regulatory agencies to establish a ~~community bank leverage ratio~~Community Bank Leverage Ratio (CBLR) of between 8% and 10%, ~~calculated by dividing tangible equity capital by average total consolidated assets of~~applicable to "qualifying community banks" that meet certain requirements to be set by those regulatory agencies. A qualifying community bank is a depository institution or bank holding company with less than $10 billion in total assets, such as Arrow,. ~~If a qualifying community bank exceeds~~ that meets other requirements to be established by the community bank leverage ratio, it will be deemed to have met all applicable capital and leverage requirements, including the generally applicable leverage capital requirements and risk-based capital requirements and the "well capitalized" requirement under the federal "prompt corrective action" capital standards. Upon its implementation, this new community bank leverage ratio standard is expected to reduce the burden of compliance with regard to regulatory capital adequacy. However, the implementation of this standard will be subject to the notice and comment procedures of rulemaking, and EGRRCPA does not impose a deadline for this rulemaking. regulators.

The federal bank regulators have ~~announced their intention~~issued a final rule to ~~initiate this rulemaking process to define and~~ implement the ~~"community bank leverage ratio" in the near future. Until this rulemaking is finalized, the following~~CBLR, introducing an optional simplified measure of capital adequacy for qualifying community banks that satisfy certain requirements, including having a tier 1 leverage ratio of greater than 9%, less than $10 billion in total consolidated assets, and limited amounts of off-balance-sheet exposures and trading assets and liabilities. A qualifying community bank that opts into the CBLR framework and meets all requirements under the CBLR framework will be considered to have met the well-capitalized ratio requirements under the “prompt corrective action” regulations and will not be required to report or calculate risk-based capital. The CBLR is calculated as ~~implemented under Dodd Frank, are~~ the ratio of “tier 1 capital” divided by “average total consolidated assets.” Based on preliminary estimates, the Company’s CBLR computed in compliance with this new standard is expected to exceed this new 9% threshold. This final rule will be effective as of January 1, 2020, and qualifying community banks can utilize the CBLR framework for purposes of filing their call reports or Form FR Y-9C, as applicable, ~~capital standards~~ for the ~~Company~~first quarter of 2020 (i.e., as of March 31, 2020).

Until the rules becomes effective and ~~its bank subsidiaries.~~final, the Capital Rules promulgated under Dodd-Frank will remain applicable to Arrow.

The following is a summary of certain definitions of capital under the various capital measures in the ~~capital rules under Dodd-Frank:~~Dodd-Frank Capital Rules:

Common Equity Tier 1 Capital (CET1): Equals the sum of common stock instruments and related surplus (net of treasury stock), retained earnings, accumulated other comprehensive income (AOCI), and qualifying minority interests, minus applicable regulatory adjustments and deductions. Such deductions will include AOCI, if the organization has exercised its irrevocable option not to include AOCI in capital ~~(we~~(the Company made such an election). Mortgage-servicing assets, deferred tax assets, and investments in financial institutions are limited to 15 percent of CET1 in the aggregate and 10 percent of CET1 for each such item individually.

Additional Tier 1 Capital: Equals the sum of noncumulative perpetual preferred stock, tier 1 minority interests, grandfathered TRUPs, and Troubled Asset Relief Program instruments, minus applicable regulatory adjustments and deductions.

Tier 2 Capital: Equals the sum of subordinated debt and preferred stock, total capital minority interests not included in Tier 1, and allowance for loan and lease losses (not exceeding 1.25% of risk-weighted assets) minus applicable regulatory adjustments and deductions.

The following table presents the ~~current~~ minimum regulatory capital ratios applicable to ~~our~~the holding company and banks under the revised capital rules (as of January 1, 2018), as well as the increased minimum capital ratios that will apply at certain dates over the remaining portion of the phase-in period (i.e., as of January 1, 2019):

current Capital Rules:

Capital Ratio
Year, as of January 1

2018 2019
Minimum CET1 Ratio 4.500 % 4.500 %
Capital Conservation Buffer ("Buffer") 1.875 % 2.500 %
Minimum CET1 Ratio Plus Buffer 6.375 % 7.000 %
Minimum Tier 1 Risk-Based Capital Ratio 6.000 % 6.000 %
Minimum Tier 1 Risk-Based Capital Ratio Plus Buffer 7.875 % 8.500 %
Minimum Total Risk-Based Capital Ratio 8.000 % 8.000 %
Minimum Total Risk-Based Capital Ratio Plus Buffer 9.875 % 10.500 %
Minimum Leverage Ratio 4.000 % 4.000 %



Capital Ratio
	2019
Minimum CET1 Ratio	4.500	%
Capital Conservation Buffer ("Buffer")	2.500	%
Minimum CET1 Ratio Plus Buffer	7.000	%
Minimum Tier 1 Risk-Based Capital Ratio	6.000	%
Minimum Tier 1 Risk-Based Capital Ratio Plus Buffer	8.500	%
Minimum Total Risk-Based Capital Ratio	8.000	%
Minimum Total Risk-Based Capital Ratio Plus Buffer	10.500	%
Minimum Leverage Ratio	4.000	%

These minimum capital ratios, especially the CET1 ratio (4.5%) and the enhanced Tier 1 risk-based capital ratio (6.0%), represent a heightened and more restrictive capital regime than institutions like Arrow previously had to meet under the prior capital rules.

At September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, Arrow's holding company and both of its subsidiary banks exceeded by a substantial amount each of the applicable minimum capital ratios established under the ~~revised capital rules,~~Capital Rules, including the minimum CET1 Ratio, the minimum Tier 1 Risk-Based Capital Ratio, the minimum Total Risk-Based Capital Ratio, and the minimum Leverage Ratio, including in the case of each risk-based ratio, ~~the phased-in portion of~~ the capital buffer.

Prompt Corrective Action Capital Classifications. Under applicable banking law, federal banking regulators are required to take prompt corrective action with respect to depository institutions that do not meet certain minimum capital requirements. For these purposes, the regulators have established five capital classifications for banking institutions, ranging from the highest category of "well-capitalized" to the lowest category of "critically under-capitalized". Under the current capital classifications, a banking institution is considered "well-capitalized" if it meets the following capitalization standards on the date of measurement: a CET1 risk-based capital ratio of 6.50% or

~~ratio of 6.50% or~~ greater, a Tier 1 risk-based capital ratio of 8.00% or greater, a total risk-based capital ratio of 10.00% or greater, and a Tier 1 leverage ratio of 5.00% or greater, provided the institution is not subject to any regulatory order or written directive regarding capital maintenance. Federal banking law also ties the ability of banking organizations to engage in certain types of activities and to utilize certain procedures to such organizations' continuing to qualify for inclusion in one of the two highest rankings of these capitalization categories, i.e., as "well-capitalized" or "adequately capitalized."

Current Capital Ratios: The table below sets forth the regulatory capital ratios of Arrow's holding company and two subsidiary banks, Glens Falls National and Saratoga National, under the current ~~capital rules,~~Capital Rules, as of September 30, ~~2018:~~2019:

Common Tier 1 Total
Equity Risk-Based Risk-Based Tier 1
Tier 1 Capital Capital Capital Leverage
Ratio Ratio Ratio Ratio
Arrow Financial Corporation 12.89 % 13.90 % 14.90 % 9.67 %
Glens Falls National Bank & Trust Co. 13.49 % 13.49 % 14.49 % 9.24 %
Saratoga National Bank & Trust Co. 13.02 % 13.02 % 14.04 % 9.53 %

Current Regulatory Minimum (2018)
6.375%⁽¹⁾

7.875%⁽¹⁾

9.875%⁽¹⁾

4.000 %
FDICIA's Prompt Corrective Action - "Well-Capitalized" Standard (2018) 6.500 % 8.000 % 10.000 % 5.000 %
Final Regulatory Minimum (1/1/2019)
7.000%⁽²⁾

8.500%⁽²⁾

10.500%⁽²⁾

4.000 %

⁽¹⁾ Including currently phased-in 1.875% capital conservation buffer
⁽²⁾ Including the fully phased-in 2.50 % capital conservation buffer



	Common		Tier 1		Total
	Equity		Risk-Based		Risk-Based		Tier 1
	Tier 1 Capital		Capital		Capital		Leverage
	Ratio		Ratio		Ratio		Ratio
Arrow Financial Corporation	12.93	%	13.85	%	14.81	%	10.04	%
Glens Falls National Bank & Trust Co.	13.46	%	13.47	%	14.43	%	9.56	%
Saratoga National Bank & Trust Co.	13.03	%	13.03	%	13.94	%	9.99	%

FDICIA's Prompt Corrective Action - "Well-Capitalized" Standard (2019)	6.500	%	8.000	%	10.000	%	5.000	%
Regulatory Minimum effective 1/1/2019	7.000%⁽¹⁾		8.500%⁽¹⁾		10.500%⁽¹⁾		4.000	%

⁽¹⁾ Including the fully phased-in 2.50% capital conservation buffer

At September 30, ~~2018, Arrow's holding company~~2019, Arrow and ~~both~~its subsidiary banks exceeded the minimum regulatory capital ratios established under the current ~~capital rules~~Capital Rules and each also qualified as "well-capitalized", the highest category in the new capital classification scheme established by federal bank regulatory agencies under the "prompt corrective action" standards, as described above.

Capital Components; Stock Repurchases; Dividends

Stockholders' Equity: Stockholders' equity was ~~$264.8~~$292.2 million at September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, an increase of ~~$15.2~~$22.6 million, or ~~6.1%~~8.4%, from December 31, ~~2017.~~2018. This increase was largely due to the result of net income for the period of ~~$27.5 million, and~~$27.7 million; increases in book equity from various stock-based compensation and dividend reinvestment plans of ~~$3.9~~$3.8 million; and other comprehensive income of $4.8 million. These increases to equity ~~enhancing developments~~ during the quarter were offset by a decrease related to ~~other comprehensive loss of $3.8 million,~~ cash dividends of ~~$10.6~~$11.3 million and purchases of the Company's own common stock in the aggregate amount of ~~$1.8~~$2.4 million under the Board-approved stock repurchase program described below.

Trust Preferred Securities: In each of 2003 and 2004, the Company issued $10 million of trust preferred securities (TRUPs) in a private placement. Under the Federal Reserve Board's regulatory capital rules then in effect, TRUPs proceeds typically qualified as Tier 1 capital for bank holding companies such as ~~ours,~~Arrow, but only in amounts up to 25% of Tier 1 capital, net of goodwill less any associated deferred tax liability. Under the Dodd-Frank Act, any trust preferred securities that Arrow might issue on or after the grandfathering date set forth in Dodd-Frank (May 19, 2010) would not qualify as Tier 1 capital under bank regulatory capital guidelines. For Arrow, TRUPs outstanding prior to the grandfathering cutoff date set forth in Dodd-Frank (May 19, 2010) would continue to qualify as Tier 1 capital until maturity or redemption, subject to limitations. Thus, Arrow's outstanding TRUPs continue to qualify as Tier 1 regulatory capital, subject to such limitations.

Stock Repurchase Program: In ~~October 2017,~~January 2019, the Board of Directors approved a $5.0 million stock repurchase program ~~effective January 1, 2018~~ (the ~~2018 stock repurchase program). Management~~2019 Repurchase Program), under which management is authorized, in its discretion, to permit the Company to repurchase up to $5 million of shares of Arrow's common stock over the period from ~~time-to-time during 2018,~~January 30, 2019 through December 31, 2019, in the open market or in privately negotiated transactions, ~~up to $5 million of Arrow common stock,~~ to the extent management believes ~~purchase of~~ the Company's stock is reasonably priced and such repurchases appear to be an attractive use of available capital and in the best interests of ~~stockholders. The 2018 stock repurchase program~~shareholders. This 2019 Repurchase Program replaced a similar repurchase program which was in effect during ~~2017~~2018 (the ~~2017 stock repurchase~~2018 program), which also authorized the repurchase of up to $5.0 million of ~~Arrow~~shares of Arrow's common stock. As of September 30, ~~2018~~2019 approximately ~~$595 thousand~~$1.2 million had been used under the ~~2018 stock repurchase program~~2019 Repurchase Program to repurchase Arrow shares. This total does not include repurchases of Arrow's Common Stock other than through its ~~repurchase program,~~2019 Repurchase Program, i.e., repurchases of Arrow shares on the market utilizing funds accumulated under Arrow's Dividend Reinvestment Plan and the surrender or deemed surrender of Arrow stock to the Company in connection with employees' stock-for-stock exercises of compensatory stock options to buy Arrow stock.

In October 2019, the Board of Directors approved a new stock repurchase program authorizing the repurchase, at the discretion of senior management, of up to $5 million of Arrow common stock over the 12-month period starting January 1, 2020, in open market or negotiated transactions. This new repurchase program will replace the existing 2019 Repurchase Program, which expires December 31, 2019.

Dividends: The Company's common stock is traded on NasdaqGS^® under the symbol AROW. The high and low stock prices for the past seven quarters listed below represent actual sales transactions, as reported by NASDAQ. On October ~~31, 2018,~~30, 2019, the Board of Directors declared a ~~2018~~2019 fourth quarter cash dividend of $0.26 payable on December ~~14, 2018.~~13, 2019. Per share amounts and share counts in the following ~~table~~tables have been restated for ~~our~~the September 27, ~~2018~~2019 3% stock dividend.


					Cash						Cash
	Market Price				Dividends		Market Price				Dividends
	Low		High		Declared		Low		High		Declared
2017
2018
First Quarter	$	30.87	$	38.60	$	0.236	$	29.04	$	33.53	$	0.236
Second Quarter	29.27		33.93		0.236		30.96		36.15		0.236
Third Quarter	28.94		33.98		0.236		34.17		37.85		0.245
Fourth Quarter	32.52		37.48		0.243		29.56		36.46		0.252
2018
2019
First Quarter	$	29.91	$	34.53	$	0.243	$	29.57	$	35.19	$	0.252
Second Quarter	31.89		37.23		0.243		30.96		33.93		0.252
Third Quarter	35.19		38.98		0.252		30.26		35.31		0.252
Fourth Quarter (dividend payable December 14, 2018)	TBD		TBD		0.260
Fourth Quarter (dividend payable December 13, 2019)							TBD		TBD		0.260


	Quarter Ended September 30,						Quarter Ended September 30,
	2018			2017			2019			2018
Cash Dividends Per Share	$	0.252		$	0.236		$	0.252		$	0.245
Diluted Earnings Per Share	0.64			0.52			0.67			0.62
Dividend Payout Ratio	39.38		%	45.38		%	37.61		%	39.52		%
Total Equity (in thousands)	264,810			$	244,648		292,228			$	264,810
Shares Issued and Outstanding (in thousands)	14,441			14,308			14,969			14,875
Book Value Per Share	$	18.34		$	17.10		$	19.52		$	17.80
Intangible Assets (in thousands)	23,827			24,268			23,586			23,827
Tangible Book Value Per Share	$	16.69		$	15.40		$	17.95		$	16.20

LIQUIDITY

The objective of effective liquidity management is to ensure that the Company has the ability to raise cash when needed at a reasonable cost. This includes the capability of meeting expected and unexpected obligations to the Company's customers at any time. Given the uncertain nature of customer demands and the need to maximize earnings, the Company must have available reasonably priced sources of funds, both on- and off-balance sheet, that can be accessed quickly in time of need.

The primary sources of available liquidity are overnight investments in federal funds sold, interest bearing bank balances at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, and cash flow from investment securities and loans. Certain investment securities are selected at purchase as available-for-sale based on their marketability and collateral value, as well as their yield and maturity. The securities available-for-sale portfolio was ~~$340.4~~$314.2 million at September 30, ~~2018, an increase~~2019, a decrease of ~~$40.2~~$3.4 million, from the year-end ~~2017~~2018 level. Due to the potential for volatility in market values, the Company may not always be able to sell securities on short notice at their carrying value, even to provide needed liquidity.

In addition to liquidity from short-term investments, investment securities and loans, the Company has supplemented available operating liquidity with additional off-balance sheet sources such as a federal funds lines of credit with ~~one~~ correspondent ~~bank~~banks and credit lines with the FHLBNY. The federal funds ~~line~~lines of credit isare with athree correspondent ~~bank~~banks totaling ~~$15~~$57 million which ~~was~~were not drawn on during the three months ended September 30, ~~2018.~~2019.

To support the borrowing relationship with the FHLBNY, the Company has pledged collateral, including residential mortgage, ~~and~~ home equity and commercial real estate loans. At September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, the Company had outstanding collateral obligations with the FHLBNY of ~~$306~~$148 million; as of that date, the unused borrowing capacity at the FHLBNY was approximately ~~$233~~$577 million. Brokered deposits have also been identified as an available source of funding accessible in a relatively short time period. At September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, the balance of outstanding brokered deposits totaled ~~$45~~$115.1 million. Also, the Company's two bank subsidiaries have each established a borrowing facility with the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, pledging certain consumer loans as collateral for potential "discount window" advances, which are maintained for contingency liquidity purposes. At September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, the amount available under this facility was approximately ~~$487~~$574 million, and there were no advances then outstanding.

The Company measures and monitors basic liquidity as a ratio of liquid assets to total short-term liabilities, both with and without the availability of borrowing arrangements. Based on the level of overnight funds investments, available liquidity from the investment securities portfolio, cash flows from the loan portfolio, the stable core deposit base and the significant borrowing capacity, the Company believes that the available liquidity is sufficient to meet all funding needs that may arise in connection with any reasonably likely events or occurrences. At September 30, ~~2018,~~2019, the basic liquidity ratio, including the FHLBNY collateralized borrowing capacity, was ~~9.3%~~18.6% of total assets, or ~~$158~~$454 million in excess of the internally-set minimum target ratio of 4%.

Because of its consistently favorable credit quality and strong balance sheet, the Company did not experience any significant liquidity constraints in the ~~three-month~~nine-month period ended September 30, ~~2018~~2019 and did not experience any such constraints in recent prior ~~years, back to and including the financial crisis~~ years. The Company has not at any time during such period been forced to pay above-market rates to obtain retail deposits or other funds from any source.

RESULTS OF OPERATIONS

Three Months Ended September 30, ~~2018~~2019 Compared With

Three Months Ended September 30, ~~2017~~2018

Summary of Earnings Performance

(Dollars in Thousands, Except Per Share Amounts)


	Quarter Ended											Quarter Ended
	9/30/2018			9/30/2017			Change			% Change		9/30/2019			9/30/2018			Change			% Change
Net Income	$	9,260		$	7,416		$	1,844		24.9	%	$	10,067		$	9,260		$	807		8.7	%
Diluted Earnings Per Share	0.64			0.52			0.12			23.1	%	0.67			0.62			0.05			8.1	%
Return on Average Assets	1.28		%	1.08		%	0.20		%	18.5	%	1.32		%	1.28		%	0.04		%	3.1	%
Return on Average Equity	13.96		%	12.07		%	1.89		%	15.7	%	13.82		%	13.96		%	(0.14		)%	(1.0	)%

Net income was ~~$9.3~~$10.1 million and diluted earnings per share (EPS) of ~~$.64~~$.67 for the third quarter of ~~2018,~~2019, compared to net income of ~~$7.4~~$9.3 million and diluted EPS of ~~$.52~~$.62 for the third quarter of ~~2017.~~2018. Return on average assets (ROA) for the third quarter of ~~2018~~2019 was ~~1.28%~~1.32%, up ~~20 basis points~~ from ~~1.08%~~1.28% in the third quarter of ~~2017.~~2018. In addition, return on average equity (ROE) ~~increased~~decreased to ~~13.96%~~13.82% for the third quarter of ~~2018, up 189 basis points~~2019, down from ~~12.07%~~13.96% in the third quarter of ~~2017.~~2018.

The following narrative discusses the quarter-to-quarter changes in net interest income, noninterest income, noninterest expense and income taxes.

Net Interest Income

Summary of Net Interest Income

(Dollars in Thousands)

Quarter Ended
9/30/2018 9/30/2017 Change % Change
Interest and Dividend Income $ 24,495
$ 21,599
$ 2,896
13.4 %
Tax-Equivalent Adjustment 376
966
(590 ) (61.1 )%
Interest and Dividend Income (Tax-equivalent) ⁽²⁾
24,871
22,565
2,306
10.2 %

Interest Expense 3,498
1,949
1,549
79.5 %
Net Interest Income 20,997
19,650
1,347
6.9 %
Net Interest Income (Tax-equivalent) ⁽²⁾
21,373
20,616
757
3.7 %
Average Earning Assets ⁽¹⁾
2,757,020
2,597,277
159,743
6.2 %
Average Interest-Bearing Liabilities 2,110,924
2,012,802
98,122
4.9 %

Yield on Earning Assets ⁽¹⁾
3.52 % 3.30 % 0.22 % 6.7 %
Yield on Earning Assets (Tax-equivalent) ^{(1) (2)}
3.58
3.45
0.13 % 3.8 %
Cost of Interest-Bearing Liabilities 0.66
0.38
0.28 % 73.7 %

Net Interest Spread 2.86
2.92
(0.06 )% (2.1 )%
Net Interest Spread (Tax-equivalent) ⁽²⁾
2.92
3.07
(0.15 )% (4.9 )%

Net Interest Margin 3.02
3.00
0.02 % 0.7 %
Net Interest Margin (Tax-equivalent) ⁽²⁾
3.08
3.15
(0.07 )% (2.2 )%



	Quarter Ended
	9/30/2019			9/30/2018			Change			% Change
Interest and Dividend Income (GAAP Basis)	$	27,952		$	24,495		$	3,457		14.1	%
Tax-Equivalent Adjustment	344			376			(32		)	(8.5	)%
Interest and Dividend Income (Tax-equivalent Basis) ⁽²⁾	28,296			24,871			3,425			13.8	%

Interest Expense	5,649			3,498			2,151			61.5	%
Net Interest Income (GAAP Basis)	22,303			20,997			1,306			6.2	%
Net Interest Income (Tax-equivalent Basis) ⁽²⁾	22,647			21,373			1,274			6.0	%
Average Earning Assets ⁽¹⁾	2,881,035			2,757,020			124,015			4.5	%
Average Interest-Bearing Liabilities	2,213,642			2,110,924			102,718			4.9	%

Yield on Earning Assets (GAAP Basis) ⁽¹⁾	3.85		%	3.52		%	0.33			9.4	%
Yield on Earning Assets (Tax-equivalent Basis) ^{(1) (2)}	3.90			3.58			0.32			8.9
Cost of Interest-Bearing Liabilities	1.01			0.66			0.35			53.0

Net Interest Spread (GAAP Basis)	2.84			2.86			(0.02		)	(0.7	)
Net Interest Spread (Tax-equivalent Basis) ⁽²⁾	2.89			2.92			(0.03		)	(1.0	)

Net Interest Margin (GAAP Basis)	3.07			3.02			0.05			1.7
Net Interest Margin (Tax-equivalent Basis) ⁽²⁾	3.12			3.08			0.04			1.3

⁽¹⁾ Includes Nonaccrual Loans.

⁽²⁾See "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" on page ~~40;~~45; reported on a fully taxable basis using a marginal federal tax rate of ~~35% for 2017,~~ 21% ~~for 2018.~~.

Net interest income for the ~~just~~recently completed quarter, on a GAAP basis, increased by $1.3 million, or ~~6.9%~~6.2%, from the third quarter of ~~2017,~~2018, due primarily to continued loan growth and improved balance sheet mix. Total loans increased $55.3 million in ~~part, to an increase in~~the third quarter of 2019. In addition, average earning assets increased 4.5% from September 30, 2018. In order to fund the consistent loan growth, total average-interest-bearing liabilities increased 4.9% from the third quarter of ~~6.2%, as compared to the 4.9% increase in average interest-bearing liabilities. In addition, net~~2018. Net interest margin on a GAAP basis increased 25 basis points in the third quarter of ~~2018~~2019 to ~~3.02%~~3.07%, from ~~3.00%~~3.02% during the third quarter of ~~2017. The composition of average~~2018. Average earning assets during the 2018 period includes more relatively higher yielding loans again this quarter, with less relatively lower yielding investment securities due to the strategy of not reinvesting a portion of the securities maturing during the quarter. Earning asset yields were 2233 basis points higher ~~in the 2018 quarter due~~as compared to the ~~continued~~third quarter of 2018 due primarily to the increase in market yields and the higher composition of loans inas a percentage of earning assets. Yield on loans specifically increased 27 basis points from the third quarter of 2018. The cost of interest-bearing liabilities increased 2835 basis points quarter over quarter due to rate-sensitive deposit customers continuing to reallocate their deposit investments to higher yielding money market savings products and time deposits, especially time deposits over $250,000. In this rising rate environment, the cost of brokered deposits and overnight borrowings from the ~~FHLBNY increased in the 2018 quarter.~~quarter ended September 30, 2018. The Company defines net interest margin as net interest income divided by average earning assets, annualized. The Company defines tax-equivalent net interest margin as net interest income on a tax-equivalent basis divided by average earning assets, annualized. Tax-equivalent net interest margin, as well as tax-equivalent net interest income, from

which the margin is derived, are non-GAAP financial measures. (See the discussion under "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures," on page ~~40,~~45, and the tabular information and notes on pages 4146 through ~~44,~~49, regarding the Company's

reasons for using these and other non-GAAP measures and the reconciliation thereof to comparable GAAP measures.) Further detailed information is presented above under the section entitled "Average Consolidated Balance Sheets and Net Interest Income Analysis." The impact of recent interest rate changes on Arrow's deposit and loan portfolios are discussed above in this Report under the sections entitled "Deposit Trends" and "Loan Trends."

As discussed previously under the heading "Asset Quality" beginning on page ~~56,~~59, the provision for loan losses for the third quarter of ~~2018~~2019 was ~~$586~~$518 thousand, compared to a provision of ~~$800~~$586 thousand for the ~~2017 quarter.~~third quarter of 2018.

Noninterest Income

Summary of Noninterest Income

(Dollars in Thousands)


	Quarter Ended									Three Months Ended
	9/30/2018		9/30/2017		Change			% Change		9/30/2019		9/30/2018		Change			% Change
Income From Fiduciary Activities	$	2,262	$	2,116	$	146		6.9	%	$	2,212	$	2,262	$	(50	)	(2.2	)%
Fees for Other Services to Customers	2,605		2,453		152			6.2	%	2,623		2,605		18			0.7	%
Insurance Commissions	2,024		2,113		(89		)	(4.2	)%	1,936		2,024		(88		)	(4.3	)%
Net Gain on Securities	114		10		104			1,040.0	%
Net Gain on Securities Transactions										146		114		32			28.1	%
Net Gain on the Sale of Loans	54		182		(128		)	(70.3	)%	257		54		203			375.9	%
Other Operating Income	291		267		24			9.0	%	517		291		226			77.7	%
Total Noninterest Income	$	7,350	$	7,141	$	209		2.9	%	$	7,691	$	7,350	$	341		4.6	%

Total noninterest income in the current quarter was ~~$7.4~~$7.7 million, ~~up $209~~an increase of $341 thousand from ~~total noninterest income for~~ the ~~third~~comparable quarter of ~~2017. ��~~2018. Income from fiduciary activities for the third quarter of ~~2018 increased~~2019 decreased by ~~$146~~$50 thousand, or ~~6.9% over~~2.2% from the third quarter of ~~2017 due to favorable equity market returns.~~2018. The income from fiduciary activities was fairly consistent with both the third quarter 2018 and the second quarter of 2019, which generated $2.3 million of income.

Fees for other services to customers ~~increased to~~were $2.6 million for the third quarter of ~~2018.~~2019. In addition to service charge income on deposits, this category also includes debit card interchange income, revenue related to the sale of mutual funds to customers by third party providers, and servicing income on sold loans. Debit card usage by customers continues to grow, which has had ~~(and if such growth persists, will continue to have)~~ a positive impact on debit card fee income.

~~The $104 thousand increase in net gain on securities between the periods was primarily due~~Insurance commissions decreased to ~~the change in the fair value of marketable equity securities as compared to~~$1.9 million for the third quarter of ~~2017. For periods prior~~2019 compared to $2.0 million for the third quarter of 2018, ~~accounting guidance resulted~~due primarily to continued competitive pressure in ~~these~~the property, casualty and employee benefits sectors of the business.

Net security gains ~~being recorded as a component~~for the third quarter of ~~accumulated comprehensive income.~~2019 increased $32 thousand from the comparable quarter in 2018.

Net gain on the sale of loans in the third quarter of ~~2018decreased~~2019 increased by ~~$128~~$203 thousand from the third quarter of ~~2017. This decrease~~2018. The change was a result of ~~a decrease~~favorable market conditions leading to an increase in loan sale volume. See page 5157 for the discussion of loan sales.

~~Insurance commissions decreased to $2.0 million for~~Other operating income increased $226 thousand from the ~~third~~comparable quarter in 2018, primarily the result of ~~2018 compared to $2.1 million for the third quarter~~fees received as part of ~~2017 due~~interest rate swap agreements offset by disposal of fixed asset charges related to the ~~increased competition for commercial insurance clients in~~optimization of the ~~Company's markets.~~branch network as part of the continued efforts to improve customer experience.

~~Noninterest Expense~~

~~Summary of Noninterest Expense~~

~~(Dollars in Thousands)~~

Quarter Ended
9/30/2018 9/30/2017 Change % Change
Salaries and Employee Benefits $ 9,771
9,382
$ 389
4.1 %
Occupancy Expense of Premises, Net 1,132
1,145
(13 ) (1.1 )%
Furniture and Equipment Expense 1,130
1,226
(96 ) (7.8 )%
FDIC and FICO Assessments 218
225
(7 ) (3.1 )%
Amortization 65
69
(4 ) (5.8 )%
Other Operating Expense 3,710
3,501
209
6.0 %
Total Noninterest Expense $ 16,026
$ 15,548
$ 478
3.1 %
Efficiency Ratio 55.79 % 55.79 % — % — %

Noninterest expense for the third quarter of 2018 was $16.0 million, an increase of $478 thousand, or 3.1%, from the expense for the third quarter of 2017. The increase in salaries and benefits quarter-over-quarter was due to salary increases. Pursuant to ASU 2017-07 Compensation-Retirement Benefits, Arrow has reclassified the non-service cost components of its retirement plans from salaries and benefits to other operating expenses. The increase in other operating expense was due to increased loan costs combined with increased spending on technology. The reductions in the other noninterest expense categories were due to the ongoing expense control program.

The efficiency ratio was 55.79% for both the third quarter of 2018 and for the comparable 2017 quarter. The efficiency ratio (a ratio where lower is better), is a commonly used non-GAAP financial measure in the banking industry that purports to reflect an institution's operating efficiency. The Company calculates the efficiency ratio as the ratio of noninterest expense (excluding, under the Company's definition, intangible asset amortization) to (i) net interest income (on a tax-equivalent basis) plus (ii) noninterest income (excluding net securities gains or losses). See the discussion on this non-GAAP measure on page 40 of this Report under the heading "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" and the related tabular information and notes on pages 41 through 44 of this Report. The efficiency ratio

included by the Federal Reserve Board in its "Bank Holding Company Performance Reports" excludes net securities gains or losses from the denominator (as does the Company's calculation), but unlike the Company's ratio does not exclude intangible asset amortization from the numerator. The Company's efficiency ratios in recent periods have generally compared favorably to the ratios of the peer group as disclosed in the Fed's Performance Reports (see page 39 for a discussion of the peer group). For the three-month period ended June 30, 2018 (the most recent reporting period for which peer group information is available), the peer group's efficiency ratio was 65.87% compared to the Company's ratio of 55.38% (not adjusted for the definitional difference).

~~Income Taxes~~

~~Summary of Income Taxes~~

~~(Dollars in Thousands)~~

Quarter Ended
9/30/2018 9/30/2017 Change % Change
Provision for Income Taxes $ 2,475
$ 3,027
$ (552 ) (18.2 )%
Effective Tax Rate 21.1 % 29.0 % (7.9 ) (27.2 )

~~The effective tax rate for the 2018 quarter reflects the impact of the Tax Act which decreased the federal statutory income tax rate from 35% in 2017 to 21% in 2018.~~

~~RESULTS OF OPERATIONS~~

~~Nine Months Ended September 30, 2018 Compared With~~

~~Nine Months Ended September 30, 2017~~

~~Summary of Earnings Performance~~

~~(Dollars in Thousands, Except Per Share Amounts)~~

Nine Months Ended
9/30/2018
9/30/2017 Change % Change
Net Income $ 27,521
$ 21,255
$ 6,266
29.5 %
Diluted Earnings Per Share 1.90
1.48
0.42
28.4
Return on Average Assets 1.30 % 1.06 % 0.24 % 22.6
Return on Average Equity 14.32 % 11.86 % 2.46 % 20.7

Net income was $27.5 million and diluted earnings per share (EPS) of $1.90 for the first nine months of 2018, compared to net income of $21.3 million and diluted EPS of $1.48 for the first nine months of 2017. Return on average assets (ROA) for the first nine months of 2018 was 1.30%, an increase of 22.6% ~~from~~ ~~1.06% for the first nine months of 2017. In addition, return on average equity (ROE) increased to 14.32% for the first nine months of 2018 from 11.86% for the first nine months of 2017.~~

~~The following narrative discusses the period-to-period changes in net interest income, noninterest income, noninterest expense and income taxes.~~

~~Net Interest Income~~

~~Summary of Net Interest Income~~

~~(Taxable Equivalent Basis, Dollars in Thousands)~~

Nine Months Ended
9/30/2018 9/30/2017 Change % Change
Interest and Dividend Income $ 70,503
$ 62,522
$ 7,981
12.8 %
Tax-Equivalent Adjustment 1,335
2,863
(1,528 ) (53.4 )%
Interest and Dividend Income (Tax-equivalent) ⁽²⁾
71,838
65,385
6,453
9.9 %

Interest Expense 8,142
5,184
2,958
57.1 %
Net Interest Income 62,361
57,338
5,023
8.8 %
Net Interest Income (Tax-equivalent) ⁽²⁾
63,696
60,201
3,495
5.8 %
Average Earning Assets ⁽¹⁾
2,701,001
2,550,076
150,925
5.9 %
Average Interest-Bearing Liabilities 2,087,445
1,998,746
88,699
4.4 %

Yield on Earning Assets ⁽¹⁾
3.49 % 3.28 % 0.21 % 6.4 %
Yield on Earning Assets (Tax-equivalent) ^{(1) (2)}
3.56
3.43
0.13 % 3.8 %
Cost of Interest-Bearing Liabilities 0.52
0.35
0.17 % 48.6 %

Net Interest Spread 2.97
2.93
0.04 % 1.4 %
Net Interest Spread (Tax-equivalent) ⁽²⁾
3.04
3.08
(0.04 )% (1.3 )%

Net Interest Margin 3.09
3.01
0.08 % 2.7 %
Net Interest Margin (Tax-equivalent) ⁽²⁾
3.15
3.16
(0.01 )% (0.3 )%

⁽¹⁾ ~~Includes Nonaccrual Loans~~

⁽²⁾~~See "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" on page 40; reported on a fully taxable basis using a marginal federal tax rate of 35% for 2017, 21% for 2018.~~

Net interest income on a GAAP basis, for the nine-month period ended September 30, 2018 increased by $5.0 million, or 8.8%, over the 2017 amount due to the positive impact of a 5.9% increase in the level of average earning assets as compared to the 4.4% increase in average interest-bearing liabilities, and due to an increase in net interest margin for the period. For the first nine months of 2018, net interest margin increased to 3.09% from the 3.01% for the first nine months of 2017. The composition of average earning assets during the 2018 period continued to include more relatively higher yielding loans and less relatively lower yielding investment securities due to the strategy of not reinvesting a portion of the maturing securities. Earning assets yields were 21 basis points higher in the 2018 period due to the continued increase in market yields and the higher composition of loans in earning assets. The cost of interest-bearing liabilities increased 17 basis points in the 2018 period due to rate-sensitive deposit customers continuing to reallocate their deposit investments to higher yielding money market savings products and time deposits, especially time deposits over $250,000. In this continued rising rate environment, the cost of brokered deposits and overnight borrowings from the FHLBNY increased in the 2018 period. The Company defines net interest margin as net interest income divided by average earning assets, annualized. The Company defines tax-equivalent

net interest margin as net interest income on a tax-equivalent basis divided by average earning assets, annualized.Tax-equivalent net interest margin, as well as tax-equivalent net interest income, from which the margin is derived, are non-GAAP financial measures. (See the discussion under "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures," on page 40, and the tabular information and notes on pages 41 through 44, regarding net interest margin and tax-equivalent net interest income, which are commonly used non-GAAP financial measures.) Further detailed information is presented above under the section entitled "Average Consolidated Balance Sheets and Net Interest Income Analysis." The impact of recent interest rate changes on Arrow's deposit and loan portfolios are discussed above in this Report under the sections entitled "Deposit Trends" and "Loan Trends."

As discussed previously under the heading "Asset Quality" beginning on page 56, the provision for loan losses for the first nine months of 2018 was $1.96 million, compared to a provision of $1.58 million for the 2017 period.

~~Noninterest Income~~

~~Summary of Noninterest Income~~

~~(Dollars in Thousands)~~

Nine Months Ended
9/30/2018 9/30/2017 Change % Change
Income From Fiduciary Activities 7,106
6,284
$ 822
13.1 %
Fees for Other Services to Customers 7,555
6,875
680
9.9
Insurance Commissions 6,119
6,426
(307 ) (4.8 )
Net Gain on Securities 355
10
345
3,450.0
Net Gain on the Sale of Loans 115
431
(316 ) (73.3 )
Other Operating Income 900
867
33
3.8
Total Noninterest Income $ 22,150
$ 20,893
$ 1,247
6.0 %

Total noninterest income in the first nine months of 2018 was $22.2 million, an increase of $1.3 million, or 6.0%, from total noninterest income of $20.9 million for the first nine months of 2017. Fees for other services to customers, the largest segment of noninterest income, increased 9.9% to $7.6 million for the first nine months of 2018, as compared to $6.9 million the first nine months of 2017.

Income from fiduciary activities for the first nine months of 2018 increased by $822 thousand, or 13.1% over the first nine months of 2017 due to the closing of a large estate in the second quarter of 2018 and favorable equity market returns. Insurance commissions declined 4.8% to $6.1 million for the first nine months of 2018, compared to $6.4 million in the first nine months of 2017 due to the increased competition for commercial insurance clients in the Company's markets.

The $345 thousand increase in net gain on securities between the periods was primarily due to a change in the fair value of marketable equity securities as compared to the third quarter of 2017, pursuant to Accounting Standards Update 2016-01. See the discussion on the investment securities portfolio beginning on page 54 of this Report.

The increase in other operating income between the periods was due to the fact that the Company recognized losses in the 2017 period from the investment in regional business incubation enterprises (limited partnerships), and a small gain in the 2018 period, in addition to various credits and fees collected, none of which were individually material.

Net gain on the sale of loans in the first nine months of 2018 decreased by $316 thousand, or 73.3% from the first nine months of 2017. This decrease was a result of lower loan sale volume which is consistent with the Company's business strategy to sell fewer earning assets, in favor of retaining them in the loan portfolio. See page 51 for the discussion of loan sales.

Noninterest Expense

Summary of Noninterest Expense

(Dollars in Thousands)


	Nine Months Ended											Quarter Ended
	9/30/2018			9/30/2017			Change			% Change		9/30/2019			9/30/2018			Change			% Change
Salaries and Employee Benefits	$	28,952		$	27,740		$	1,212		4.4	%	$	10,015		9,771			$	244		2.5	%
Occupancy Expense of Premises, Net	3,742			3,761			(19		)	(0.5	)	1,324			1,132			192			17.0	%
Furniture and Equipment Expense	3,481			3,649			(168		)	(4.6	)
Technology and Equipment Expense												3,305			2,759			546			19.8	%
FDIC and FICO Assessments	658			679			(21		)	(3.1	)	(480		)	218			(698		)	(320.2	)%
Amortization	197			210			(13		)	(6.2	)	61			65			(4		)	(6.2	)%
Other Operating Expense	11,144			10,622			522			4.9		2,566			2,081			485			23.3	%
Total Noninterest Expense	$	48,174		$	46,661		$	1,513		3.2		$	16,791		$	16,026		$	765		4.8	%
Efficiency Ratio	56.12		%	57.29		%	(1.17		)%	(2.0	)	55.41		%	55.79		%	(0.38		)	(0.7	)%

Noninterest expense for the third quarter of 2019 was $16.8 million, an increase of $765 thousand, or 4.8%, from the third quarter of 2018. Salaries and benefit expenses increased slightly from the comparable quarter in 2018. Occupancy expense of premises as well as technology and equipment expenses have increased from the previous year as a result of the continued efforts with ongoing projects to achieve operational efficiencies while delivering improved customer experiences and strengthening the branch network. FDIC Small Bank Assessment Credits of $687 thousand were fully recorded in the third quarter of 2019.

The efficiency ratio continues to be solid at 55.41% for the third quarter of 2019 and 55.79% for the comparable 2018 quarter. The efficiency ratio (a ratio where lower is better), is a commonly used non-GAAP financial measure in the banking industry that purports to reflect an institution's operating efficiency. The Company calculates the efficiency ratio as the ratio of noninterest expense (excluding, under the Company's definition, intangible asset amortization) to (i) net interest income (on a tax-equivalent basis) plus (ii) noninterest income (excluding net securities gains or losses). See the discussion on this non-GAAP measure on page 45 of this Report under the

heading "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" and the related tabular information and notes on pages 46 through 49 of this Report. The efficiency ratio included by the Federal Reserve Board in its "Bank Holding Company Performance Reports" excludes net securities gains or losses from the denominator (as does the Company's calculation), but unlike the Company's ratio does not exclude intangible asset amortization from the numerator. The Company's efficiency ratios in recent periods have generally compared favorably to the ratios of the peer group as disclosed in the Federal Reserve Performance Reports (see page 44 for a discussion of the peer group). For the three-month period ended June 30, 2019 (the most recent reporting period for which peer group information is available), the peer group's efficiency ratio was 61.22% compared to the Company's ratio of 58.19% (not adjusted for the definitional difference).

Income Taxes

Summary of Income Taxes

(Dollars in Thousands)



	Quarter Ended
	9/30/2019			9/30/2018			Change			% Change
Provision for Income Taxes	$	2,618		$	2,475		$	143		5.8	%
Effective Tax Rate	20.6		%	21.1		%	(0.5		)	(2.4	)%

The decrease in the effective tax rate in the first three months ended September 30, 2019 over the three months ended September 30, 2018 was primary due to the the reduction in the projected annual tax benefit related to dividends paid to the ESOP causing an increase in the third quarter 2018 effective tax rate.

RESULTS OF OPERATIONS

Nine Months Ended September 30, 2019 Compared With

Nine Months Ended September 30, 2018

Summary of Earnings Performance

(Dollars in Thousands, Except Per Share Amounts)



	Nine Months Ended
	9/30/2019			9/30/2018			Change			% Change
Net Income	$	27,735		$	27,521		$	214		0.8	%
Diluted Earnings Per Share	1.85			1.84			0.01			0.5
Return on Average Assets	1.24		%	1.30		%	(0.06		)%	(4.6	)
Return on Average Equity	13.21		%	14.32		%	(1.11		)%	(7.8	)

Net income was $27.7 million and diluted earnings per share (EPS) of $1.85 for the first nine months of 2019, compared to net income of $27.5 million and diluted EPS of $1.84 for the first nine months of 2018. Return on average assets (ROA) for the first nine months of 2019 was 1.24%, a decrease from 1.30% for the first nine months of 2018. In addition, return on average equity (ROE) decreased to 13.21% for the first nine months of 2019 from 14.32% for the first nine months of 2018.

The following narrative discusses the period-to-period changes in net interest income, noninterest income, noninterest expense and income taxes.

Net Interest Income

Summary of Net Interest Income

(Taxable Equivalent Basis, Dollars in Thousands)



	Nine Months Ended
	9/30/2019			9/30/2018			Change			% Change
Interest and Dividend Income	$	81,392		$	70,503		$	10,889		15.4	%
Tax-Equivalent Adjustment	1,093			1,335			(242		)	(18.1	)%
Interest and Dividend Income (Tax-equivalent) ⁽²⁾	82,485			71,838			10,647			14.8	%

Interest Expense	16,261			8,142			8,119			99.7	%
Net Interest Income	65,131			62,361			2,770			4.4	%
Net Interest Income (Tax-equivalent) ⁽²⁾	66,224			63,696			2,528			4.0	%
Average Earning Assets ⁽¹⁾	2,864,816			2,701,001			163,815			6.1	%
Average Interest-Bearing Liabilities	2,224,463			2,087,445			137,018			6.6	%

Yield on Earning Assets ⁽¹⁾	3.80		%	3.49		%	0.31		%	8.9	%
Yield on Earning Assets (Tax-equivalent) ^{(1) (2)}	3.85			3.56			0.29		%	8.1	%
Cost of Interest-Bearing Liabilities	0.98			0.52			0.46		%	88.5	%

Net Interest Spread	2.82			2.97			(0.15		)%	(5.1	)%
Net Interest Spread (Tax-equivalent) ⁽²⁾	2.87			3.04			(0.17		)%	(5.6	)%

Net Interest Margin	3.04			3.09			(0.05		)%	(1.6	)%
Net Interest Margin (Tax-equivalent) ⁽²⁾	3.09			3.15			(0.06		)%	(1.9	)%

⁽¹⁾ Includes Nonaccrual Loans

⁽²⁾See "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" on page 45; reported on a fully taxable basis using a marginal federal tax rate of 21%.

Net interest income on a GAAP basis, for the nine-month period ended September 30, 2019 increased by $2.8 million, or 4.4%, over the nine-month period ended September 30, 2018. The largest driver of the increase in net interest margin was the $209.5 million year-over-year increase in loans. For the first nine months of 2019, net interest margin decreased to 3.04% from 3.09% for the comparative period of 2018. The cost of interest-bearing liabilities to fund continued loan growth have increased to 0.98% from 0.52% for the comparable prior period due largely to the higher short-term market rates that were prevalent during the majority of the current year. The Company defines net interest margin as net interest income divided by average earning assets, annualized. The Company defines tax-equivalent net interest margin as net interest income on a tax-equivalent basis divided by average earning assets, annualized.Tax-equivalent net interest margin, as well as tax-equivalent net interest income, from which the margin is derived, are non-GAAP financial measures. (See the discussion under "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures," on page 45, and the tabular information and notes on pages 46 through 49, regarding net interest margin and tax-equivalent net interest income, which are commonly used non-GAAP financial measures.) Further detailed information is presented above under the section entitled "Average Consolidated Balance Sheets and Net Interest Income Analysis."

The impact of recent interest rate changes on Arrow's deposit and loan portfolios are discussed above in this Report under the sections entitled "Deposit Trends" and "Loan Trends."

As discussed previously under the heading "Asset Quality" beginning on page 59, the provision for loan losses for the first nine months of 2019 was $1.45 million, compared to a provision of $1.96 million for the 2018 period.

Noninterest Income

Summary of Noninterest Income

(Dollars in Thousands)



	Nine Months Ended
	9/30/2019		9/30/2018		Change			% Change
Income From Fiduciary Activities	6,571		7,106		$	(535	)	(7.5	)%
Fees for Other Services to Customers	7,570		7,555		15			0.2
Insurance Commissions	5,590		6,119		(529		)	(8.6	)
Net Gain on Securities	222		355		(133		)	(37.5	)
Net Gain on the Sale of Loans	501		115		386			335.7
Other Operating Income	1,020		900		120			13.3
Total Noninterest Income	$	21,474	$	22,150	$	(676	)	(3.1	)%

Total noninterest income in the first nine months of 2019 was $21.5 million, a decrease of $0.7 million, or 3.1%, from total noninterest income of $22.2 million for the first nine months of 2018. Fees for other services to customers, the largest segment of noninterest income, were $7.6 million consistent with the first nine months of 2018.

Income from fiduciary activities for the first nine months of 2019 decreased by $535 thousand, or 7.5% over the first nine months of 2018 primarily due to large estate settlements that occurred in 2018.

Insurance commissions declined 8.6% to $5.6 million for the first nine months of 2019, compared to $6.1 million in the first nine months of 2018, due primarily to the increased competition in the property, casualty and employee benefits sectors of the business.

Net gains on securities were $222 thousand in the first nine months of 2019 compared to $355 thousand for the first nine months of 2018.

Net gain on the sale of loans in the first nine months of 2019 increased by $386 thousand, or 335.7% from the first nine months of 2018. The change was a result of favorable market conditions leading to an increase in loan sale volume. See page 57 for the discussion of loan sales.

Other operating income was $1.0 million, an increase of 13.3% from the comparative nine month period of 2018. The increase is primarily the result of fees received as part of interest rate swap agreements offset by disposal of fixed asset charges related to the optimization of the branch network as part of the continued efforts to improve customer experience.

Noninterest Expense

Summary of Noninterest Expense

(Dollars in Thousands)



	Nine Months Ended
	9/30/2019			9/30/2018			Change			% Change
Salaries and Employee Benefits	$	29,061		$	28,952		$	109		0.4	%
Occupancy Expense of Premises, Net	4,023			3,742			281			7.5
Technology and Equipment Expense	9,689			8,306			1,383			16.7
FDIC and FICO Assessments	(56		)	658			(714		)	(108.5	)
Amortization	184			197			(13		)	(6.6	)
Other Operating Expense	7,450			6,319			1,131			17.9
Total Noninterest Expense	$	50,351		$	48,174		$	2,177		4.5
Efficiency Ratio	57.35		%	56.12		%	1.23			2.2

Noninterest expense for the first nine months of ~~2018~~2019 was ~~$48.2~~$50.4 million, an increase of ~~$1.5~~$2.2 million, or ~~3.2%~~4.5%, from the expense for the first nine months of ~~2017. This increase on a year-over-year basis represents less than~~2018. Salaries and employee benefits expense increased 0.4% in the ~~growth in average total loans~~first nine months of 2019 over the 2018 period, reflecting an effort to manage open positions and control benefit costs. Pursuant to ASU 2017-07 Compensation-Retirement Benefits, Arrow has reclassified the non-service cost components of retirement plans from salaries and benefits to other operating expenses.Occupancy expense of premises have increased $281 thousand, or ~~in average total assets between the same two periods. The Company's efficiency ratio was 56.12%~~7.5%, for the first nine months of ~~2018, down~~2019 in comparison to the first nine months of 2018. The increase is primarily the result of the continued focus on strengthening the branch network. Technology and Equipment Expense increased by ~~1.17%~~$1.4 million, or 16.7%, ~~representing an improvement~~ as compared to the 2018 period. The increase was primarily the result of the continued commitment to ongoing projects to improve efficiency and the customer experience. FDIC Small Bank Assessment Credits of $687 thousand were fully recorded in the third quarter of 2019.

The Company's efficiency ratio was 57.35% for the first nine months of 2019 and 56.12% for the comparable ~~2017~~2018 period. This ratio (a ratio where lower is better), is a commonly used non-GAAP financial measure in the banking industry that purports to reflect operating efficiency. The Company calculates the efficiency ratio as the ratio of noninterest expense (excluding, under the Company's definition, intangible asset amortization) to (i) net

interest income (on a tax-equivalent basis) plus (ii) noninterest income (excluding net securities

gains or losses). See the discussion on this non-GAAP measure on page 4045 of this Report under the heading "Use of Non-GAAP Financial Measures" and the related tabular information and notes on pages 4146 through 4449 of this ~~Report.~~Report

Salaries and employee benefits expense increased 4.4% in the first nine months of 2018 over the 2017 period, reflecting an increase of 4.8% in salaries and an increase of 3.2% in benefits. The increase in salary expense was due in part to staffing expansion and merit increases. The increase in the benefits expense was primarily due to increases in pension expense combined with awards related to the Company's short term incentive plan during the 2018 period. Pursuant to ASU 2017-07 Compensation-Retirement Benefits Arrow has reclassified the non-service cost components of retirement plans from salaries and benefits to other operating expenses.

~~Other operating expenses increased 4.9% in the first nine months of 2018 compared to the 2017 period primarily due to increased loan costs combined with increased spending on technology.~~

Furniture and Equipment Expense decreased by 4.6% due to reduced depreciation expense recorded in the first first nine months of 2018 compared to the 2017 period. FDIC and FICO assessments decreased by $21 thousand for the first nine months of 2018, as compared to the first nine months of 2017. This decrease is primarily the result of a reduction in the requirements for community banks of Arrow's size and a repositioning of balance sheet components on which the assessment is based.

Income Taxes

Summary of Income Taxes

(Dollars in Thousands)


	Nine Months Ended											Nine Months Ended
	9/30/2018			9/30/2017			Change			% Change		9/30/2019			9/30/2018			Change		% Change
Provision for Income Taxes	$	6,855		$	8,735		$	(1,880	)	(21.5	)%	$	7,074		$	6,855		$	219	3.2	%
Effective Tax Rate	19.9		%	29.1		%	(9.2		)	(31.6	)	20.3		%	19.9		%	0.4		2.0

The ~~decrease~~increase in the effective tax rate in the first nine months of ~~2018~~2019 over the first nine months of ~~2017,~~2018 was ~~primarily attributable~~primary due to the ~~impact~~reduction of tax exempt investments held and the ~~Tax Act which decreased the federal statutory income tax rate from 35% in 2017 to 21% in 2018.~~related investment income.

Item 3.

QUANTITATIVE AND QUALITATIVE DISCLOSURES ABOUT MARKET RISK

In addition to credit risk in the loan portfolio and liquidity risk, discussed earlier, the Company's business activities also generate market risk. Market risk is the possibility that changes in future market rates (interest rates) or prices (market value of financial instruments) will make the Company's position (i.e., ~~our~~ assets and operations) less valuable. The Company's primary market risk is interest rate volatility. The ongoing monitoring and management of interest rate risk is an important component of the asset/liability management process, which is governed by policies that are reviewed and approved annually by the Board of Directors. The Board of Directors delegates responsibility for carrying out asset/liability oversight and control to management's Asset/Liability Committee ("ALCO"). In this capacity ALCO develops guidelines and strategies impacting the asset/liability profile based upon estimated market risk sensitivity, policy limits and overall market interest rate levels and trends.

Changes in market interest rates, whether increases or decreases, can trigger repricing and changes in the pace of payments for both assets and liabilities (prepayment risk). This may individually or in combination affect net interest income, net interest margin, and ultimately net income, either positively or negatively. ALCO utilizes the results of a detailed and dynamic simulation model to quantify this interest rate risk by projecting net interest income in various interest rate scenarios.

The Company's standard simulation model applies a parallel shift in interest rates, ramped over a 12-month period, to capture the impact of changing interest rates on net interest income. The results are compared to ALCO policy limits which specify a maximum tolerance level for net interest income exposure over a ~~one- year~~one-year horizon, assuming no balance sheet growth and a 200 basis point upward and a 100 basis point downward shift in interest rates. Additional tools to monitor potential longer-term interest rate risk, including periodic stress testing involving hypothetical sudden and significant interest rate spikes, are also evaluated.

The following table summarizes the percentage change in net interest income as compared to the base scenario, which assumes no change in market interest rates as generated from the standard simulation model. The results are presented for each of the first two years of the simulation period for the 200 basis point increase in interest rate scenario and the 100 basis point decrease in interest rate scenario. ~~These results are well within the ALCO policy limits as shown.~~

As of September 30, ~~2018:~~2019:


	Change in Interest Rate		Policy Limit	Change in Interest Rate
	+ 200 basis points	- 100 basis points		+ 200 basis points	- 100 basis points
Calculated change in Net Interest Income - Year 1	(2.70)%	1.20%	(10.00)%	(2.90)%	0.70%
Calculated change in Net Interest Income - Year 2	2.20%	2.00%	(15.00)%	0.90%	(3.70)%

Historically, there has existed an inverse relationship between changes in prevailing rates and the Company's net interest income, suggesting that liabilities and sources of funds generally reprice more quickly than earning ~~assets.~~assets (near-term liability sensitivity). However, when net interest income is simulated over a longer time frame, this exposure is limited, and actually reverses, as asset yields continue to reprice while the cost of funding reaches assumed ceilings or floors (long-term asset sensitivity).

The hypothetical estimates underlying the sensitivity analysis are based upon numerous assumptions, including: the nature and timing of changes in interest rates including yield curve shape, prepayments on loans and securities, deposit decay rates, pricing decisions on loans and deposits, reinvestment/replacement of asset and liability cash flows, and others. While assumptions are developed based upon current economic and local market conditions, the Company cannot make any assurance as to the predictive nature of these assumptions including how customer preferences or competitor influences might change.

Also, as market conditions vary from those assumed in the sensitivity analysis, actual results will differ due to: prepayment/refinancing levels likely deviating from those assumed, the varying impact of interest rate changes on caps or floors on adjustable rate assets, the potential effect of changing debt service levels on customers with adjustable rate loans, depositor early withdrawals and product preference changes, unanticipated shifts in the yield curve and other internal/external variables. Furthermore, the sensitivity analysis does not reflect actions that ALCO might take in responding to or anticipating changes in interest rates.

Item 4.

CONTROLS AND PROCEDURES

Senior management, including the Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer, has evaluated the effectiveness of the design and operation of Arrow's disclosure controls and procedures (as defined in Rule 13a-15(e) under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended) as of September 30, ~~2018.~~2019. Based upon that evaluation, senior management, including the Chief Executive Officer and Chief Financial Officer, concluded that ~~our~~ disclosure controls and procedures were effective. Further, there were no changes made in the Company's internal control over financial reporting that occurred during the most recent fiscal quarter that had materially affected, or are reasonably likely to materially affect, the Company's internal control over financial reporting.

PART II - OTHER INFORMATION

Item 1.

Legal Proceedings

The Company, including its subsidiary banks, ~~are~~is not currently the subject of any material pending legal proceedings, other than ordinary routine litigation occurring in the normal course of their business. On an ongoing basis, the Company is often the subject of, or a party to, various legal claims by other parties against the Company, by the Company against other parties, or involving the Company, which arise in the normal course of business. The various pending legal claims against the Company will not, in the opinion of management based upon consultation with counsel, result in any material liability.

Item 1.A.

Risk Factors

The Risk Factors identified in the Company's Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, ~~2017~~,2018, continue to represent the most significant risks to the Company's future results of operations and financial conditions, without modification or amendment. Please refer to such Risk Factors as listed in Part I, Item 1A, of ~~our~~the Annual Report on Form 10-K for the fiscal year ended December 31, ~~2017~~.2018.

Item 2.

Unregistered Sales of Equity Securities and Use of Proceeds

Unregistered Sales of Equity Securities

~~There were no unregistered sales of the Company's equity securities by or on behalf of the Company during the just-completed quarter.~~None.

Issuer Purchases of Equity Securities

The following table presents information about purchases by Arrow ~~of its common stock~~ during the ~~quarter~~three months ended September 30, ~~2018:~~2019 of common stock (our only class of equity securities registered pursuant to Section 12 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934):


Third Quarter 2018 Calendar Month	(A) Total Number of Shares Purchased ¹	(B) Average Price Paid Per Share ¹		(C) Total Number of Shares Purchased as Part of Publicly Announced Plans or Programs ²	(D) Maximum Approximate Dollar Value of Shares that May Yet be Purchased Under the Plans or Programs ²
Third Quarter 2019 Calendar Month							(A) Total Number of Shares Purchased ¹	(B) Average Price Paid Per Share ¹		(C) Total Number of Shares Purchased as Part of Publicly Announced Plans or Programs ²	(D) Maximum Approximate Dollar Value of Shares that May Yet be Purchased Under the Plans or Programs ²
July	2,594	$	37.56	—	$	4,610,800	1,850	$	33.31	—	$	3,932,734
August	2,888	38.55		—	4,610,800		8,366	31.57		5,488	3,760,025
September	22,168	37.40		5,500	4,404,627		18,286	32.95		—	3,760,025
Total	27,650	37.54		5,500			28,502	32.57		5,488

¹ The total number of shares purchased by the Company and the average price paid per share listed in columns (A) and (B) consist of (i) any shares purchased in such periods in open market or private transactions under the Arrow Financial Corporation Automatic Dividend Reinvestment Plan (the "DRIP") by the administrator of the DRIP, ~~and~~ (ii) shares surrendered or deemed surrendered to Arrow in such periods by holders of options to acquire Arrow common stock received by them under Arrow's long-term incentive plans ~~("LTIPs")~~ in connection with their stock-for-stock exercise of such ~~options.~~options and (iii) shares purchased under the publicly-announced 2019 Repurchase Program. In the months indicated, the listed number of shares purchased included the following number of shares purchased by Arrow through such methods: July - DRIP purchases ~~(1,574 shares) and stock-for-stock exercises (1,020~~(1,850 shares); August - DRIP purchases ~~(2,298~~(2,878 shares) and ~~stock-for-stock exercises (590~~repurchased under the 2019 Repurchase Program (5,488 shares); and September - DRIP purchases ~~(12,934~~(13,334 shares), and stock-for-stock exercises ~~(3,734 shares) and repurchased under the publicly-announced Repurchase Program (5,500 shares.~~(4,952.)

² Includes only those shares acquired by Arrow pursuant to its ~~2018~~publicly-announced stock repurchase ~~program. The~~programs. Our only publicly-announced stock repurchase program in effect for the third quarter of ~~2018~~2019 was the ~~program~~2019 Repurchase Program approved by the Board of Directors and announced in ~~October 2017,~~January 2019, under which the Board authorized management, in its discretion, to repurchase from time to time ~~during 2018,~~from January 30, 2019 through December 31, 2019, in the open market or in privately negotiated transactions, up to $5 million of Arrow common stock subject to certain ~~exceptions (the "2018 stock repurchase program").~~exceptions.

Item 3.

Defaults Upon Senior Securities - None

Item 4.

Mine Safety Disclosures - None

Item 5.

Other Information - None

Item 6.

Exhibits



Exhibit Number	Exhibit
3.(i)	Certificate of Incorporation of the Registrant, as amended, incorporated by reference from the Registrant's Current Report on Form 8-K filed June 5, 2019, Exhibit 3.1
3.(ii)	By-laws of the Registrant, as amended, incorporated herein by reference from the Registrant’s Current Report on Form 8-K filed on November 24, 2009, Exhibit 3.(ii)
15	Awareness Letter
31.1	Certification of Chief Executive Officer under SEC Rule 13a-14(a)/15d-14(a)
31.2	Certification of Chief Financial Officer under SEC Rule 13a-14(a)/15d-14(a)
32	Certification of Chief Executive Officer under 18 U.S.C. Section 1350 and Certification of Chief Financial Officer under 18 U.S.C. Section 1350
101.INS	XBRL Instance Document
101.SCH	XBRL Taxonomy Extension Schema Document
101.CAL	XBRL Taxonomy Extension Calculation Linkbase Document
101.DEF	XBRL Taxonomy Extension Definition Linkbase Document
101.LAB	XBRL Taxonomy Extension Labels Linkbase Document
101.PRE	XBRL Taxonomy Extension Presentation Linkbase Document

SIGNATURES

Pursuant to the requirements of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, the Registrant has duly caused this Report to be signed on its behalf by the undersigned thereunto duly authorized.

ARROW FINANCIAL CORPORATION

Registrant




November ~~8, 2018~~5, 2019	/s/Thomas J. Murphy
Date	Thomas J. Murphy, President and
	Chief Executive Officer

November ~~8, 2018~~5, 2019	/s/Edward J. Campanella
Date	Edward J. Campanella, Senior Vice President,
	Treasurer and Chief Financial Officer
	(Principal Financial Officer and
	Principal Accounting Officer)

# 7074



	Page
PART I - FINANCIAL INFORMATION
Item 1. Financial Statements	3
Item 2. Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations	3944
Item 3. Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk	6771
Item 4. Controls and Procedures	6771


PART II - OTHER INFORMATION
Item 1. Legal Proceedings	6872
Item 1.A. Risk Factors	6872
Item 2. Unregistered Sales of Equity Securities and Use of Proceeds	6872
Item 3. Defaults Upon Senior Securities	6872
Item 4. Mine Safety Disclosures	6872
Item 5. Other Information	6973
Item 6. Exhibits	6973

SIGNATURES	7074




Roll-Forward of Shares Outstanding:
Outstanding at January 1, 2018	356,540
Granted	56,843
Exercised	(94,742		)
Forfeited	(14,953		)
Outstanding at September 30, 2018	303,688
Exercisable at Period-End	185,547
Vested and Expected to Vest	118,141

Roll-Forward of Shares Outstanding - Weighted Average Exercise Price:
Outstanding at January 1, 2018	$	23.42
Granted	29.95
Exercised	20.85
Forfeited	26.61
Outstanding at September 30, 2018	25.24
Exercisable at Period-End	22.47
Vested and Expected to Vest	29.59

Schedule of Other Long Term Incentive Plan Information
Grants Issued During 2018 - Weighted Average Information:
Fair Value	$	5.59
Fair Value Assumptions:
Dividend Yield	2.98		%
Expected Volatility	21.55		%
Risk Free Interest Rate	2.68		%
Expected Lives (in years)	6.98



Share-Based Compensation Expense
	For the Three Months Ended September 30,				For the Nine Months Ended September 30,
	2018		2017		2018		2017
Share-Based Compensation Expense	$	89	$	90	$	267	$	262



Schedule of Fair Values by Balance Sheet Grouping
					Fair Value Hierarchy
	Book Value		Fair Value		Level 1		Level 2		Level 3
September 30, 2018
Cash and Cash Equivalents	$	92,295	$	92,295	$	92,295	$	—	$	—
Securities Available-for-Sale	340,411		340,411		—		340,411		—
Securities Held-to-Maturity	289,952		282,719		—		282,719		—
Equity Securities	1,916		1,916		—		1,916		—
Federal Home Loan Bank and Federal Reserve Bank Stock	10,866		10,866		—		10,866		—
Net Loans	2,106,097		2,030,278		—		—		2,030,278
Accrued Interest Receivable	8,028		8,028		—		8,028		—
Deposits	2,407,855		2,398,987		—		2,398,987		—
Federal Funds Purchased and Securities Sold Under Agreements to Repurchase	62,503		62,503		—		62,503		—
Federal Home Loan Bank Overnight Advances	131,000		131,000		—		131,000		—
Federal Home Loan Bank Term Advances	45,000		44,488		—		44,488		—
Junior Subordinated Obligations Issued to Unconsolidated Subsidiary Trusts	20,000		20,000		—		20,000		—
Accrued Interest Payable	485		485		—		485		—

December 31, 2017
Cash and Cash Equivalents	$	72,838	$	72,838	$	72,838	$	—	$	—
Securities Available-for-Sale	300,200		300,200		—		300,200		—
Securities Held-to-Maturity	335,907		335,901		—		335,901		—
Federal Home Loan Bank and Federal Reserve Bank Stock	9,949		9,949		—		9,949		—
Net Loans	1,932,184		1,901,046		—		—		1,901,046
Accrued Interest Receivable	6,753		6,753		—		6,753		—
Deposits	2,245,116		2,236,548		—		2,236,548		—
Federal Funds Purchased and Securities Sold Under Agreements to Repurchase	64,966		64,966		—		64,966		—
Federal Home Loan Bank Overnight Advances	105,000		105,000		—		105,000		—
Federal Home Loan Bank Term Advances	55,000		54,781		—		54,781		—
Junior Subordinated Obligations Issued to Unconsolidated Subsidiary Trusts	20,000		20,000		—		20,000		—
Accrued Interest Payable	410		410		—		410		—

September 30, 2017
Cash and Cash Equivalents	$	80,666	$	80,666	$	80,666	$	—	$	—
Securities Available-for-Sale	315,459		315,459		64,730		250,729		—
Securities Held-to-Maturity	341,526		343,899		—		343,899		—
Federal Home Loan Bank and Federal Reserve Bank Stock	6,704		6,704		—		6,704		—
Net Loans	1,891,104		1,870,379		—		—		1,870,379
Accrued Interest Receivable	6,563		7,692		—		7,692		—
Deposits	2,307,116		2,299,011		—		2,299,011		—
Federal Funds Purchased and Securities Sold Under Agreements to Repurchase	61,419		61,419		—		61,419		—
Federal Home Loan Bank Overnight Advances	33,000		33,000		—		33,000		—
Federal Home Loan Bank Term Advances	55,000		55,110		—		55,110		—
Junior Subordinated Obligations Issued to Unconsolidated Subsidiary Trusts	20,000		20,000		—		20,000		—
Accrued Interest Payable	260		260		—		260		—



	Three Months Ended				Nine Months Ended
Sales	9/30/2018		9/30/2017		9/30/2018		9/30/2017
Available-For-Sale Portfolio:
U.S. Agency Securities	$	—	$	10,005	$	—	$	10,005
Total	$	—	$	10,005	$	—	$	10,005
Net Gains on Securities Transactions	—		10		—		10
Proceeds on the Sales of Securities	$	—	$	10,015	$	—	$	10,015



Capital Ratio	Year, as of January 1
	2018		2019
Minimum CET1 Ratio	4.500	%	4.500	%
Capital Conservation Buffer ("Buffer")	1.875	%	2.500	%
Minimum CET1 Ratio Plus Buffer	6.375	%	7.000	%
Minimum Tier 1 Risk-Based Capital Ratio	6.000	%	6.000	%
Minimum Tier 1 Risk-Based Capital Ratio Plus Buffer	7.875	%	8.500	%
Minimum Total Risk-Based Capital Ratio	8.000	%	8.000	%
Minimum Total Risk-Based Capital Ratio Plus Buffer	9.875	%	10.500	%
Minimum Leverage Ratio	4.000	%	4.000	%